Fisking a wilfully ignorant private school parent

July 17, 2009 9:43 am

TimesBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

It doesn’t take much to provoke me into writing in support of state schools, but Evening Standard reporter Paul Waugh is normally somewhat less sanguine.

So it’s interesting to read Paul’s angry fisking of an article in yesterday’s Times in which Heather McGregor, MD of an “executive search company” (his quotation marks, not mine) displays herself as what Paul calls a “snobbish, 80′s shoulder-padded businesswoman who had fallen on hard times.”

Paul writes:

“Ms McGregor freely admits that what drove her to educate her sons at private school was that they would benefit from “a network – membership of a club”. This is why I thought the piece a cunning parody – it’s so rare that you hear parents admit the real reason they educate Sebastian and Jemima privately was for sheer social status.”

But, he says:

“The best bit of the satire was when she admitted that as a result of the [recession and sending their children to the local state school] she and her husband “will need to adjust our lives to do more hands-on parenting; that too is no bad thing.” Jaw-droppingly funny.”

I’m highlighting these passages because they are the same parts of McGregor’s article that shocked me most, and that I’d circled in blotty ink to question myself. But McGregor’s article is worth reading in full (as is Paul’s rebuke), if for no other reason as to understand the level of wilful ignorance it betrays.

Local state schools are not the enemy. On the contrary, they are pillars of stability for many families, and on the whole give the children that attend them a more rounded and worldly education than a private school ever could.

Just this week, in fact, my Mum read me a letter from a parent of one of her schoolchildren that was moving and inspiring in a way that is unique and personal to the multi-cultural and mulit-talented school that she works in. The letter thanked my Mum for her skills and dedication in teaching this child. I’ve called my Mum to try and get an extract from it, which I’ll add here later. It’s worth waiting for…

Related posts:

  1. Fisking Tory council cuts
  2. Private schools and the pursuit of privilege
  3. Private Investigations?
  4. Parents in poverty need extra financial support during school holidays
  5. Let’s be careful with our outrage and remember Network Rail works in the private sector

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Local Government News Prezza for Police Commissioner?

    Prezza for Police Commissioner?

    According to the Hull and East Riding Mail: “Lord Prescott said: “I want the opportunity to continue my public service to the region with a mandate from the people to protect the community and target criminals. “I feel that after proudly serving as a local MP for 40 years and as a cabinet minister for 10 years, I have the experience to listen to the public and help be their strong voice in supporting the police and holding them to [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured A big moment for the NHS – and for blogging

    A big moment for the NHS – and for blogging

    Today marks a big moment – not just in British blogging history, but in British political history. The decision by cabinet ministers to go to ConHome calling for the health bill to be dropped is a breach of collective responsibility, that much is clear. That they have briefed ConHome anonymously makes very little difference – Tim Montgomerie is a scrupulous character who can be taken at his word. These cabinet ministers, whoever they are, are angry. And they want this [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Is there a thin blue line for the new Police and Crime Commissioners?

    Is there a thin blue line for the new Police and Crime Commissioners?

    The process to select candidates for the new Police Crime Commissioners is underway. The Labour Party NEC will be long-listing at the end of February. The Liberal Democrats have, I understand, said that they do not intend to field candidates from a nationally organised position but will offer support to local parties taking the initiative. In the past, the Conservatives have declared that they will be hosting open primaries but no news is yet emerging on when and where these [...]

    Read more →
  • Video Another Lembit video

    Another Lembit video

    Earlier this week we brought you the internet sensation that is “Pop Lembit”. But as we all know Lembit has always been an extrovert, and it turns out he has something in his back catalogue that is almost as spectacular as his most recent output. It’s a little longer, but it’s just as …engaging. Ladies and gentlemen – introducing…retro Lembit… (Via Popbitch (via Mark Pack))

    Read more →
  • News Quote of the day: Miliband wants PMQs reform

    Quote of the day: Miliband wants PMQs reform

    According to the Guardian: “I find the Westminster village gets much more excited about it than the population, I believe. I don’t know how to change it so I’m not going to make false promises about changing it but I would love to change it if I could.”

    Read more →