Biscuitgate: it never happened

October 28, 2009 3:56 pm

BiscuitBy Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

It is a truth universally acknowledged that Gordon Brown is a tragic ditherer who can’t even make up his mind on which is his favourite biscuit, right?

Wrong.

The famous bickie-question, apprently asked of the PM twelve times in a recent MumsNet webchat and mocked by Murdoch knows how many newspapers and blogs since, was never actually put to the PM, according to MumsNet founder Justine Roberts.

In a new comment on Mumsnet, Roberts clarifies:

“The truth is that Gordon Brown didn’t follow the live chat on the screen directly – he answered the questions grouped and fed to him by Mumsnet HQ and his advisers. He didn’t avoid the biscuit question because it didn’t cross his path…

“We were conscious of not merely focusing on frivolities. Fun as biscuits are, access to the Prime Minister is precious and we would have hated to waste time on Rich Tea Fingers at the expense of miscarriage or school starting age. Plus, of course, we’d rather not be seen as a soft touch.”

So, although the question was asked of the PM, Mumsnet themselves never fed it through to him because they thought it wasn’t a worthwhile question.

Unfortunately, David Cameron didn’t think biscuit-gate was as frivalous as Justine Roberts does. Instead, Cameron chose to accept the story as presented to him and raise it in the middle of PMQs last week half way through a debate about Afghanistan and the economy.

Will Cameron now apologise or retract his own juvenile mockery…?

<!–

tweetmeme_source = ‘talktweetmeme’;
// –>

Related posts:

  1. Biscuitgate won’t decide the election – but Gordon still might need a lucky break
  2. What really happened in Erith and Thamesmead?
  3. The banging desks of apparent support: more detail on what happened in the PLP meeting emerges

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Europe Video Chuka Umunna on what Britain can learn from Germany

    Chuka Umunna on what Britain can learn from Germany

    Read more →
  • Comment In Defence of Social Democracy

    In Defence of Social Democracy

    Firstly, I would like to thank David Miliband for taking seriously the arguments which were presented in my recent article in The Political Quarterly, ‘In Praise of Social Democracy’ co-authored with Roy Hattersley. Obviously we disagree over the recent past and the future of the Labour Party, but this should be a debate over principles and not personalities. What does David argue? The implication is that we are being intellectually complacent – lazy even – wishing to retreat into some [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured The tragedy of Chris Huhne

    The tragedy of Chris Huhne

    It was inevitable that he had to go – in fairness, it had been coming for some time. The spectre of the court case hung over him, further tarnishing his credibility. Powerful friends and allies had already exhausted their capacity for patience with him. He surely knew the game was up. Today he was cast adrift. Now the courts must decide whether he is guilty (and therefore banished from public life) or innocent (and perhaps, once again able to return [...]

    Read more →
  • Local Government News Resignation calls after Tory Councillor’s “pudding bowl attack” on wife

    Resignation calls after Tory Councillor’s “pudding bowl attack” on wife

    According to local paper the Express and Star, a Dudley councillor is facing calls to resign after admitting assaulting his wife: “A councillor has admitted assault after throwing a pudding bowl at his wife’s head – sparking calls for him to resign. Tory councillor Paul Woodall’s wife Joanne was left with a one-inch cut to her forehead and blood pouring down her face, a court heard. Dudley Magistrates was told Woodall, 45, elected two years ago for Kingswinford North and [...]

    Read more →
  • News Caroline Flint on Ed Davey’s appointment

    Caroline Flint on Ed Davey’s appointment

    After Ed Davey was announced as Chris Huhne’s replacement in the cabinet today, Caroline Flint called on him to “stand up to vested interests in the energy industry”: “David Cameron promised this would be the “greenest Government ever”. But on his watch the Green Investment Bank has been delayed, thousands of jobs and businesses in the solar industry have been put at risk and the UK has fallen from third in the world for investment in green growth to thirteenth. [...]

    Read more →