Luciana Berger is a strong, committed candidate for Liverpool Wavertree – others should join the campaign, not criticise

February 16, 2010 11:40 am

Luciana BergerBy Dannie Grufferty / @DannieGruff

The fuss over the selection of Luciana Berger as PPC for Liverpool Wavertree is a storm in a very small, but enlarging, teacup. The storm symbolises Ricky Tomlinson’s pseudo-Scouse loyalty and the ‘regionalism’ of the prejudicial type; the teacup is our dear old collectively value-driven party.

Ricky is one thing, but one does wonder what drives Peter Kilfoyle to the local and national press on this issue. Admittedly, as the ‘mastermind’ of Blair’s leadership campaign, he may have a bitter taste in his mouth when he hears of up-and-coming ‘rising stars’. Peter has taken to backbench jeering in recent years and has told me so himself. But the student unions of Liverpool did not hold it against him when he failed to come sign a pledge asking him to “Come Clean” on fees as he promised, or when he didn’t turn up, as promised, to the NUS lobby of Parliament in November. Peter, if you want to sign the pledge committing yourself to supporting a fairer funding system, I have it ready for you. Ricky Tomlinson also said he would be in touch about speaking at our fees debate; he has still yet to send his apologies.

But this isn’t a critique of Peter Kilfoyle. Having a go at Government policy is one thing – Kilfoyle does it often enough and I have no doubt he generally means well – but to have a go at a recently selected PPC is unfair, particularly in this case. While myself and other students get out on the doorstep every week, many for Kilfoyle himself, he seems to think it’s OK to publicly criticise a candidate fighting to keep a key target seat for the Lib Dems in Labour’s column.

Students are a diverse bunch. The majority in Higher Education are part time, and almost a third here in Liverpool are over 26. They are not the stereo-typical 18-21 binge-drinking undergraduates. So it is unfair for Kilfoyle to criticse Luciana on the basis of her being what he calls a “student politician”.

Luciana’s experience outshone that of her opponents in the Parliamentary selection process – she has more than most people twice her age. Moreover, students represent 10% of the Wavertree constituency – that could easily swing the result here. Luciana is working hard to engage a cohort of society who often feel disaffected, and who vote proportionately less than other demographic groups. Yet she is criticised for it.

The assertion that she was selected merely on the basis that students supported her is a joke. For one thing, none of the other selection candidates ever approached us students for our support. If we therefore chose to support Luciana – who did ask for our support – that’s our prerogative. A few of us did get out on the doorstep for her in the run up to her selection, but surely other candidates should know that a selection, like a campaign, takes hard work, communication and organisation. Luciana worked very hard to get selected, approaching members who had never before been engaged in the local Party, and never previously spoken to a fellow member. Moreover, there were only a small handful – perhaps half a dozen – students who even voted in the selection. I have no doubt Luciana would have won whether students had campaigned for her or not.

These public outcries are not only unfairly damaging to the innocent individual – Luciana’s only ‘flaw’ is that she was born south of the Watford Gap – they are also unfairly perjorative of students. Imagine it the other way round. There’d be outage if remarks referred to any other group as if it were a homogeneous. Yet, some people within the Party think it’s perfectly acceptable to somehow blame students – who put hundreds of hours into Labour’s doorstep campaigning every week.

And on whether Luciana’s place on birth matters? Jane Kennedy, the incumbent MP here, wasn’t ‘local’. Luciana’s Lib Dem opponent Colin Eldridge certainly isn’t. Ricky Tomlinson hasn’t lived in Liverpoool for years, and he was born in Blackpool. People need to get over the post code obsession and realise that if Wavertree is going to put up a fight against the Lib Dems, we need the candidate who will fight the hardest. Luciana’s commitment has been proven during her selection campaign, as well as through her previous record within the NUS.

If we settle for second best for Labour, then the people of Liverpool Wavertree may well find themselves with a falky Lib Dem MP, and one who only signed NUS’s “Come Clean on Fees” pledge last week.

Most importantly of all, if we settle for second best in our Parliamentary selections, and if we split the vote at the election (that’s for you, Ricky), then we really will be handing power back to the Tories.




Comments are closed

Latest

  • Comment Europe McFadden’s appointment comes at a time of big opportunity for Labour on Europe

    McFadden’s appointment comes at a time of big opportunity for Labour on Europe

    Pat McFadden is taking over the Europe brief just at the time when the issue can work in Labour’s favour. Provided we hold to Ed Miliband’s decision not to cave in to the calls to offer an in-out referendum. Europe is again becoming toxic for the Tories. How Cameron must be looking back wistfully to that time when he told his party to stop banging on about Europe. That’s exactly what it is now doing. And it’s largely his own […]

    Read more →
  • Comment The Next Portillo Moment

    The Next Portillo Moment

    Undoubtedly the highlight of election night ‘97 was seeing Labour record the unlikeliest of victories where I live in Enfield Southgate. We did it through hard work, at the time all three Enfield seats were blue and though the Labour swing meant that Edmonton and Enfield North were going red regardless it took a special campaign lead by an extraordinarily good candidate in Stephen Twigg to record what was an iconic victory in the Party’s history. We held the seat […]

    Read more →
  • Comment The business backlash against Tory EU exit plans 

    The business backlash against Tory EU exit plans 

    It’s not just José Manuel Barroso who has warned David Cameron that his party is taking the wrong approach when it comes to talk of an EU exit. There is a clear sense of concern and anger from the UK and international business community in respect of the Tory plans for an in/out referendum on the UK’s membership of the EU in 2017. This has led to a serious business backlash against the Tories. Standard & Poor’s, the international rating […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Miliband sets out 5 point immigration reform plan (but won’t join “Operation Pander”)

    Miliband sets out 5 point immigration reform plan (but won’t join “Operation Pander”)

    Ed Miliband is in Rochester today, where he’s campaigning for the party’s by-election candidate Naushabah Khan against what he called the “two Tory opponents” of UKIP and the Tories in the Rochester and Strood by-election. But the main purpose of Miliband’s speech was to set out what Labour’s approach to immigration will be – specifically an Immigration Reform Bill in the first Queen’s Speech of the new Parliament. Miliband announced it’d be based around five key principles (most of which […]

    Read more →
  • News Sadiq Khan asks Mansion Tax critics – how would you fund the NHS?

    Sadiq Khan asks Mansion Tax critics – how would you fund the NHS?

    Since Labour conference, the majority of Labour’s potential London mayoral candidates have been critical of the party’s Mansion Tax proposals. However one presumptive candidate has been consistently positive about the plans – Sadiq Khan. That’s understandable and expected, as he’s a Shadow Cabinet member and a Miliband loyalist. But Khan has now launched a public defence of the tax (calling it “absolutely fair”) and a broadside against critics, asking them “why they are opposed to hiring thousands more nurses and doctors […]

    Read more →