How Labour lost (and how we might lose again)

24th May, 2010 1:10 pm

By Declan Gaffney

The idea that Labour’s election defeat was due to the sudden desertion of the party by skilled working class voters – known as ‘C2’s in the jargon of market research – has gained widespread currency, reflected in the convergence of most of the candidates for the leadership around certain themes: notably immigration and welfare reform.

As Liam Byrne put it in a Progress pamphlet published on Friday:

“These voters are the bedrock of our coalition. But their support for Labour has fallen off a cliff. In 2005, 43% of C2’s were Labour. Now Mori say it’s down 20%, to just 23%.”

How accurate is this picture? Estimates released by Mori on Friday allow us to compare Labour’s vote share among different social groups since 1997 on a consistent basis. While this sort of analysis is not an exact science, and different methodologies will yield different results, these are the best estimates we have to go on at the moment, and they tell a more complex story.

On these figures, Labour’s vote share among the ‘C2′ demographic did fall in 2010, but by 11 percentage points, rather than 20 (see chart, below).*

Declan Chart

Secondly, on Mori’s figures, the fall in the C2 vote share in 2010 was nothing new. In 2005, Labour’s share in this group fell by 9 percentage points. This suggests that Labour’s problem with the C2 demographic is longer term in nature than the narrative offered by Liam Byrne indicates.

Thirdly, Labour lost vote share across all these demographics in 2005 and 2010. While the fall among C2’s is proportionally greatest, it looks like part of a broader pattern.

Fourthly, consider what has happened to Labour’s share of the lower income DE demographic since 1997. In 1997, Labour had 59% of votes in this group; by 2010, this was down to 40%. Liam Byrne’s pamphlet virtually ignores this group, which is no less important in terms of Labour’s share of the national popular vote than the C2’s. (Lower turnout among DE’s is offset by the greater size of the group.)

These figures do not, on the face of it, support the sort of post-election narrative offered by Progress or the leadership candidates so far. They suggest that Labour’s electoral problems are longer term in nature and more widely spread across social groups.

Much of the post-election debate has been couched in terms of how to win back the C2 vote. But there is little reason to think that task can be accomplished by focussing on this demographic in isolation. Meanwhile, there is another question which nobody seems to be asking. How did Labour, with its highly redistributionary policies, manage to lose nearly a third of its vote share among the lowest income demographic while in government?

There will be no simple answer to that question, but the very invisibility of this group in Labour’s post-election narrative points to one line of explanation. Labour’s political strategy has long been concentrated on maintaining what was seen as the winning coalition of C2’s and more affluent voters of 1997. For many in the party, the most persuasive argument for this approach lay in the progressive policies Labour pursued in power, which directly benefited lower income groups. But the political strategy meant that voters in these groups were not an important target of Labour’s political messaging. Could it be that many lower income voters stopped supporting a party which often spoke about them but rarely addressed itself to them?

*The difference is easily explained. The figure cited in the Progress pamphlet used an earlier estimate by Mori produced just after the election, which gave Labour a lower share of the C2 vote for 2010, and combined it with an estimate of Labour’s 2005 share from a different source, which gave Labour a higher share than Mori.

Source for graph: Ipsos-Mori ‘How Britain voted’ 1997, 2001, 2005, 2010′

Comments are closed

Latest

  • News 2 out of 3 hospitals face potentially huge cuts this year, leaked analysis reveals

    2 out of 3 hospitals face potentially huge cuts this year, leaked analysis reveals

    Labour will tomorrow release a leaked analysis from NHS Providers which shows that two-thirds of Trusts expect to be in deficit in 2015/16 – up from just one in five in 13/14. Analysis of 98 trusts’ financial forecasts shows a projected deficit this year of £759 million – the equivalent of £1.86 billion across all England’s 240 trusts. This is three times higher than just one year earlier in 2014/15.  In order to get out of deficit, hospitals now face having […]

    Read more →
  • Comment “Your struggle is my my struggle” – what Miliband’s Citizens UK speech says about how he might govern

    “Your struggle is my my struggle” – what Miliband’s Citizens UK speech says about how he might govern

    Your fight is my fight Your struggle is my my struggle Your vision is my vision Lets put working people first Lets change the country together 22 simple words. 5 short sentences. But it says a whole lot about Ed Miliband and the way this campaign has suggested he might govern. These were the words that Miliband used to close his speech at Citizens UK this afternoon – the second powerful speech I’ve seen him deliver today. He showed David […]

    Read more →
  • Video “A nation and a movement” – Scottish Labour’s final election broadcast

    “A nation and a movement” – Scottish Labour’s final election broadcast

    Scottish Labour faces a tough election day on Thursday (after a tough election campaign with Jim Murphy hounded on the streets of Glasgow today, nationalists “hunting” Labour MPs and even appealing to Tories – who they claim to hate – for backing). But tomorrow Scottish Labour’s final Party Election Broadcast will be aired, and it’s a passionate appeal to the emotional argument for Labour. The video, narrated by David Tennant, is based on the hugely popular “Fighters and Believers” broadcast, and […]

    Read more →
  • News Video Ed Miliband’s full Citizens UK speech

    Ed Miliband’s full Citizens UK speech

    Ed Miliband today made a speech at the Citizen UK conference, which David Cameron controversially pulled out of yesterday. In a short but well-received speech (at the place where Gordon Brown made his most famous speeches as PM on the Monday before the last election), the Labour leader said: “Friends, that’s why your fighting my fight. Your struggle is my struggle. Your vision is my vision. Let’s put working people first. Let’s change the country together.”

    Read more →
  • News Polling Quid pro quo? Tories set to save Clegg’s skin in Sheffield Hallam

    Quid pro quo? Tories set to save Clegg’s skin in Sheffield Hallam

      New polling from the Guardian and ICM show that Nick Clegg may hang on to his seat in Sheffield Hallam – but only thanks to tactical voting from nominally Tory voters. The headline figures are Labour’s Oliver Coppard on 34% to Nick Clegg on 42%. Were this to be translated into votes on the day Nick Clegg will be comfortably re-elected though with an 11% loss between now and 2010. In recent months leading Tory figures like former Conservative Home and […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit