A vile attack on young women

May 16, 2011 9:28 pm

DorriesBy Lisa Hamilton / @lefty_lisa

Nadine Dorries is a serious politician. We know this because where else do serious politicians tout their latest policies than the Vanessa Show. Other hard hitting topics covered on the Vanessa show have included “invite your fiance to your stag do” (apparently called a ‘Hag do’) and “intolerant of food intolerance”. Yet amongst this background of ridiculousness Dorries has still managed to shine.

She began by trotting out the usual sex education myths: 7 year old girls are taught how to put condoms on bananas, pupils are not told that not having sex is also an option and, rather bizarrely that pupils are taught the ‘mechanics of sex’. So far, so Monty Python.

Then the conversation took a rather more sinister turn. Julie Bentley the Chief Executive of the Family Planning Agency ruined Dorries argument with facts. The ‘Just Say No’ campaign spent billions on the abstinence message, had celebrity endorsements from the likes of the Jonas brothers and the result was an increase in teenage pregnancies and STIs. Clearly losing the ‘abstinence equals fewer teenage pregnancies’ argument Dorries plumped for the utterly absurd and offensive:

“some of the evidence I have heard is that if a stronger ‘Just Say No’ message was given…there might be an impact on sex abuse”.

She went on to say that “when sex abuse takes place [the girls] don’t realise that that was a wrong thing to do”.

If Dorries argument wasn’t credible before, it certainly isn’t now. The idea that a child could be held responsible for sexual abuse is vile and only someone as narrow minded and hateful as Dorries could ever think otherwise. Its clear that this Dorries’ bill is not, as she claims, an attack on the ‘sexualisation of society’ but instead an attack on young women.

Before the show aired Dorries described her time on Vanessa as “one of the more pleasurable media experiences I’ve ever had.” At least someone enjoyed it.

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Featured Labour’s lead is slipping and its main rivals are still the Tories (remember them?)

    Labour’s lead is slipping and its main rivals are still the Tories (remember them?)

    The Independent’s poll of polls announced last week showed two things: the first is that Labour’s poll lead is slipping (to five points, its lowest level in a year, a year which has been abysmal for the Tories). This is exactly what we would expect, it is doing what pretty much every mid-term lead has ever done – evaporating. There’s a bit more analysis behind that here. That does not mean it should not concern us and growing consciousness of [...]

    Read more →
  • News Seats and Selections Selections roundup – including the No.1 seat on Labour’s target seat list, and a double-header in Brighton

    Selections roundup – including the No.1 seat on Labour’s target seat list, and a double-header in Brighton

    There were a number of Labour PPCs selected over the weekend as the selection process for 2015 continues to heat up. There were two selections on the same day in Brighton, one in Warrington – and the candidate for Labour’s No.1 target seat was selected. North Warwickshire and Bedworth – the party’s No.1 target seat chose their PPC on Saturday, and former MP Mike O’Brien was (re)selected on Saturday to try and reclaim the seat for Labour. He lost out in [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Say No to the recall of MPs!

    Say No to the recall of MPs!

    I have been surprised by the extent of media and other support, including editorially by the Guardian, for the proposal now espoused by the government for a given percentage of an MP’s constituents to be allowed to ‘recall’ him or her between elections, either ending his political career or forcing him to vacate his seat and stand for re-election in a by-election. This whole idea seems to me misconceived.  Fear of de-selection already makes too many MPs slaves of their [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured There’s much to welcome from Stephen Twigg’s speech – but many questions too. What do you want to ask him?

    There’s much to welcome from Stephen Twigg’s speech – but many questions too. What do you want to ask him?

    There’s much to welcome from Stephen Twigg’s major speech on schools today. Some will doubtless dwell on the news that Labour has no plans to close pre-existing free schools, but this isn’t a new policy – it’s one Twigg made clear was Labour’s policy when I interviewed him last year and one he reiterated a few months later. I’d rather focus on his announcement that there will be no more Free Schools under a Labour government (which some have hilariously try [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured News “It’s not over until it’s over” – Waheed Alli and the fight for Equal Marriage

    “It’s not over until it’s over” – Waheed Alli and the fight for Equal Marriage

    Waheed Alli doesn’t strike me as someone who leaves things to chance. Being successful in politics, finance and the media doesn’t come by chance. And neither does winning a vote in the Lords on Equal Marriage. Over the past fifteen years (since he became a peer aged just 34 – making him the then youngest peer in parliament – in 1998) Alli has been closely involved with many important pieces of Equality legislation. In particular, he is credited with spearheading [...]

    Read more →