Ed, speak human!

July 2, 2011 11:39 am

ed speaks human.jpgBy Vincenzo Rampulla / @VMRampulla

“Message discipline, just remember message discipline” – I can easily imagine the advisers intoning this to Ed Miliband for his recent BBC interview. It is what communications professional always advise. So why didn’t it work?

Putting aside whether the position was right or not (that’s a totally different blog post) – there was a cogent position but the team failed to get it out properly.

Shane Greer’s already tackled the challenge of modern media consumption sets for this type of technique. But the wider point is that all the tactics, the strategy and effort should be based on letting Ed ‘speak human’.

If anyone could turn to me and convince me that the reality is that “put aside your twittery and online chatter, the public understand what Ed’s saying” then that would be fine. But that is manifestly not the case.

If anything ordinary people now just see Ed being castigated by his supporters for being robotic. He hasn’t come out as a leader, fiercely independent and able to fight his own battles, he’s come off as just another politician.

Surely it could have been different…

I’m no expert but, hindsight apart, where was the well crafted opinion column in The Sun before the strike talking to normal people outside of the Westminster bubble?

He’s done it before. It is Sun readers that the ordinary people Ed should be looking to speaking to.

The blog post on the June 28th wouldn’t of and didn’t have the same impact.

On the day of the strikes the feeling was probably that he needed to face down (or maybe fan) criticism, so where was the blog on LabourList? Time was spent crafting “I wanted to respond to people who disagree with me about today’s strike” but the post could only have been read on the margins.

That post should have been dropped in the midst of Ed’s natural community (on LabourList or wherever), and cast as Ed facing down his critics on their own turf.

Finally, it was the right decision to do a BBC spot and to speak for himself.

Yet presumably his people knew the basis of the interview and knew that Ed had a cogent position that he’d be articulating in his LGA speech a little later. It wasn’t a combative or aggressive interview. So he could have ignored the interviewer’s questions and just spoke around the same points as in his speech.

‘Message discipline’ just means don’t get pulled away from what you want to say, it doesn’t necessarily mean at all times repeat yourself ad nauseam. Hopi Sen has a good post on this here.

But what do I know is this – I want Ed to speak human.

Comments are closed

Latest

  • Featured 8 questions Iain Duncan-Smith must now answer

    8 questions Iain Duncan-Smith must now answer

    In November 2011 Iain Duncan Smith promised – one million people would be on Universal Credit by April 2014. Three years on fewer than 18,000 people are receiving Universal Credit. Despite over £600million being spent on the new benefit the programme is beset by chaos, waste and delays. This afternoon Iain Duncan Smith was forced to appear before the House of Commons to answer questions about this failing programme. But once again he refused to answer the simplest of questions about his […]

    Read more →
  • Comment They left us wanting more – Gordon Brown is only the latest big beast to depart

    They left us wanting more – Gordon Brown is only the latest big beast to depart

    “Always leave them wanting more.” It’s not entirely clear who said it first, but this has become one of the more popular, if rarely achieved, political clichés. Of all the recent political leaders we might have expected to stand aside with a clamour for more ringing in his ears, Gordon Brown would not have featured prominently in discussions. Brown’s Labour leadership culminated in the party’s second worst General Election performance in the post-war era. Although he opted to remain in […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Regional banks: a crucial ingredient to help small business

    Regional banks: a crucial ingredient to help small business

    On 19 November, I was at a meeting at the German Embassy with the head of the German Savings Banks Group, Sparkassen, Georg Fahrenschon. Herr Fahrenschon told us that local savings banks were the biggest single driver of economic resilience through the global financial crisis and in the recovery since. This was because of their support for small businesses, which are the backbone of the German economy. In the US, the economic recovery has been far stronger and more sustained […]

    Read more →
  • Comment To win back people’s trust, we need to be honest about what the limits of politics are

    To win back people’s trust, we need to be honest about what the limits of politics are

    With just over 6 months to go until the next General Election, one would expect there be to a lively debate across the political spectrum mapping the key battlegrounds of the election campaign over the coming months and presenting some of the major policy ideas of each party. Instead there appears to be a general mood of helplessness among both the Conservatives and Labour. Numerous commentators have highlighted a fundamental disconnect between the political class and the electorate; an insidious […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour will set up a national refuge fund

    Labour will set up a national refuge fund

    Today it’s International Day to Eliminate Violence Against Women. Yvette Cooper has marked this by announcing that Labour will set up a national refuge fund and is committed to continuing support for rape crisis centres. Cooper, writing in the Guardian, says that Labour will use the £3million they would save by abolishing police and crime commissioners to do this. This pledge is significant given that under the Coalition, cuts have meant that between 2010 and July 2014  the number of […]

    Read more →