You are here: Home » Comment »

PMQs verdict: Miliband lets Cameron off the hook

December 7, 2011 1:10 pm

Author:

Tags:

Share this Article

PMQs started ominously for the PM this week. As his backbenchers grumbled and plotted behind him he won’t have been pleased to see arch-Eurosceptic Andrew Rossindell leap to his feet with the first question. The subject matter – perhaps predictably – was the EU. Was the PM going to be steely/a bulldog/Mrs Thatcher? “I’ll be all of them and more, anything you want”, the grinning PM appeared to say, “just stop talking about Europe. Please?”.

So up stepped Ed Miliband, and talked about Europe. The Tory benches were mute. There was none of the primal whooping that Miliband seems to draw from the Tory benches. They listened intently as the Labour leader pinned down the PM on what – exactly – he planned to do at this week’s EU summit. Back came the reply from the PM:

“Waffle waffle waffle, EU, waffle waffle, Germany, waffle.”

I’m paraphrasing of course, but not much. The PM was in a tailspin, his voice suddenly sounded hoarse, and he was talking, and talking (and talking), until even he seemed to wonder what on earth he was talking about. For the first time in months, Miliband genuinely seemed to have Cameron on the rack. Miliband has won many recent PMQs encounters, but he’s yet to smash the PM to smithereens.

Would it be today?

Could it be?

And over Europe?

No.

Miliband split his questions. Perhaps he thought three was enough – more likely he’d been unable to stretch his limited material to six questions. Either way it was a tactical error, Cameron was able to wriggle free. Flashman showed his teeth an snapped at the backbenches, so by the time Ed returned Dave was back on his feet.

The resulting exchanges weren’t memorable. At best they could have put down a marker for another time. But the knockout blow never came.

Cameron will no doubt feel relieved as he returns to No.10. A dreadful PMQs avoided, he merely had a bad one. Miliband can still chalk up today as a victory, and having done some leg work for the Tory Right, he can watch the vipers nest tear itself apart when Cameron returns from Brussels later this week. Because there’s nothing he can do that’ll appease his right flank, nothing at all…

Related posts:

  1. Rude, crude and Crass Cameron cornered by Miliband – PMQs verdict, March 30th
  2. PMQs verdict: Calm down Cameron
  3. Iraq Inquiry lets Blair off one hook, impales him on another
  4. PMQs verdict – Cameron isn’t working
  5. PMQs verdict: Cameron unveils Flashman 2.0
  • Ianrobo

    well there is one thing he can do Mark but he is a pro european at heart and his backers aactually want to be in the EU

    • Anonymous

      Miliband did OK for a long spell and you could see Cameron get angry, and then lost he was looking for help, Miliband should have been able to pounce and get a result but failed. I suspect Miliband does not have the great put downs of Thatcher, Blair, and to some degree Brown and it’s a pity.

      He needs to get help because next year these PMQ’s will be important as they head into full election mode.

  • derek

    Did Cameron let slip why he is so reluctant to force the financial sector to bare a greater responsibility for this recession? by stating that the banks create 7% of employment and contribute 10% of our GDP? because some may argue fairly that their responsible for 3% additional unemployment and a massive over spend which reflects heavily on our GDP.

  • http://twitter.com/tommilleruk Tom Miller

    Does anyone else get the impression that too much of what Ed says is pre-scripted?

    They could do with hiring a barrister to do a bit of the prep, if he wants to get better at flexibility.

    I did like Ed Balls’s giant graphs though.

    • Ian

      PMQ’s is and has been since the televised era 

      it is when it goes off line it becomes interested, Cameron, Ed, Blair, brown, IDS, Hague, Howard all had prescripted lines, sometimes they work, sometimes not.

      The person with the biggest effect is of course Bercow, how strange he picked all eurosceptic tories today and no planted questions ?

Latest

  • News Ed Miliband statement on Woolwich murder

    Ed Miliband statement on Woolwich murder

    In a statement this evening, Ed Miliband said: “This is a truly appalling murder which will shock the entire country. “All of my thoughts are with the family and friends of the victim. “The British people will be horrified by what has happened in Woolwich. They will be united in believing that this terror on our streets cannot be allowed to stand. “The Labour Party will offer the Government our complete support in establishing the facts of what happened and [...]

    Read more →
  • News Equal marriage – How every Labour MP voted at every stage of the bill

    Equal marriage – How every Labour MP voted at every stage of the bill

    By Kirstin Hay

    With much jubilation, the 3rd reading of the same-sex marriage bill passed the House of Commons last night, carried through on the weight of Labour votes, but how have individual MPs voted on this bill? In the 2nd reading of the equal marriage bill, Labour MP voting totals were: 217 – for 22 – against 14 – non-voters For the third reading 192 – for 14 – against 49 – non-voters —————————————————————- 192 Labour MPs who voted yes on 3rd reading (9 didn’t [...]

    Read more →
  • News Ed Miliband’s Google Speech – full text

    Ed Miliband’s Google Speech – full text

    Speaking at the Google Big Tent event Ed Miliband said (please note, Miliband spoke without notes, but this is the text released by the party): It is great to be here inside the Google Big Tent. My sons Daniel and Sam think I do a very boring job, so they will be excited when I tell them I appeared along with the “Killer Robots” and the “Captain of the Moonshots” at your sessions. I’d like to start by showing you [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Unions The chutzpah of Peter Mandelson – and why we need more trade unionists

    The chutzpah of Peter Mandelson – and why we need more trade unionists

    By Mark Seddon

    Lord Mandelson, or Baron Mandelson of Foy, as he should be referred to since he was packed off to the House of Lords by a small cabal, recently accused the Unite union of ‘manipulating selection procedures’ in the Labour Party. He went on to warn Ed Miliband that this ‘stores up danger for a future Labour government’. Irony has always been in as short supply as sheer chutzpah has been plentiful with old Mandy – but since his faithful disciple [...]

    Read more →
  • News Cameron says no more EU-turns – Media roundup: May 22nd, 2013

    Cameron says no more EU-turns – Media roundup: May 22nd, 2013

    Subscribers to our morning email get the best of LabourList – including the Media and blog round up – every weekday morning. If you were a subscriber you would have already received this in your inbox. You can sign up here. Cameron says no more EU-turns “After one of his most difficult weeks since becoming prime minister, David Cameron put in a polished and assured peformance on the Today programme this morning. The most notable line came on Europe, with Cameron [...]

    Read more →