They say if you’re bottom at Christmas you go down

December 18, 2011 4:20 pm

In the history of the Premiership, only one club has survived after being bottom of the league going into the St Stephen’s Day fixtures, and even then it was the fewest points a team has ever stayed up with. Depending on the result of Tuesday’s derby match, it’ll either be Blackburn Rovers or Bolton Wanderers occupying last place next weekend.

That’s not the kind of cool 2011 political fad of ‘occupying’, by the way, the kind Cambridge Defend Education would do because they think someone might disagree with them or that Ed Miliband would support – I mean a different kind of occupying. The bad kind of occupying.

I was in Blackburn last weekend and morale is low. For us Rovers fans, times are bleak. History is against us. The graphs do not make good reading. The team is managed by Steve Kean, a man who seems to have some noble ideas (he likes flowing, attacking football) that arguably pay off to some extent (only six teams have scored more goals), but who, ultimately, is not a football manager. His tactics don’t work. He’s awful at interviews. When faced with criticism, he claims that those against him are part of the 1%. He looks a bit like a waxwork of Brad Friedel, who played for Rovers when they were good, that has melted.

About a year ago, the decision to give Kean a job he is not capable of, against the will of most fans, was made by the select group of owners who bankroll the club. They have not only shown little idea how to run a football club, but have also driven out anyone who did. Yet they are brimming full of fancy ideas of what the manager should do. “Sign Ronaldinho!” they said, “Get David Beckham to come to Blackburn! Then everything will be better!”

Of course, in the real world, these players were never likely to sign for us – nor, in fact, would our problems have been solved if they were (although that might be an allegorical blog post for another time).

There might have been a good victory recently, but that was more a reflection of the quality of the team rather than any tactical masterstrokes. Especially against Swansea. It doesn’t change anything.

Blackburn fans have begun to embrace what seems to be the inevitable. We’ll be bottom at Christmas. We’ll be relegated and the manager will finally go. Then the owners might pull out, but without top-flight status and appearing to have only a small fan base to tap into, the club will struggle to attract new investors. The success of the 1990s and 2000s will look like a blip. We’ll be back where we spent most of the 20th century: the lower leagues.

Opposition.

The graphs don’t make good reading for Labour supporters either. Ed Miliband might encompass some noble values, but they’re not ones delivering results. Labour may have won Feltham and Heston this week, but that is more a reflection of the quality of candidate and hard work of members than a victory for the leader. Especially as we won it at the last General Election. The party polls do not look good (6 points behind in today’s ICM) and Miliband’s personal polling is even worse: half of all voters think he has no good qualities.

I don’t wish to labour the point, so I’ll let you stretch the rest of the analogy as far as you wish, allowing for political leanings and football allegiances.

Blackburn Rovers fans are in revolt; they want the manager gone. Many have been saying that for a long time now. It’s come to Christmas though, and it looks too late.

The Labour Party is not in revolt, though many have been calling for Ed Miliband to go for a long time now. For Labour, the festive season is not yet here. But it will come. And we can’t be bottom at Christmas.

  • Anonymous

    You must be pretty bored on a Sunday afternoon.  Get a life and stop spouting out this nonsense; no one really cares much about these ridiculous comparisons, well i certainly don’t.  Why not try to be more positive than this constant negativity every time an opinion poll go against Labour. I’m pretty certain that you sit around and wait for some negative Labour polls and then pounce on Ed.  Really it is time to change the broken record and try something a bit more positive, it might just do wonders for your ego

  • Anonymous

    This article is bad. Actually it is really bad.

    The season doesn’t end next year. We need to think beyond the next polling day if we want to actually have a long term beneficial effect on this country. Neither should we be pandering to every fluctuation in public opinion which makes us look flaky, inconsistent and dishonest.

    And you know why that image is a bad one for Labour? Because the only long term effect of this EU veto politically will probably be the leadership ratio of Cameron. Leadership. And that’s what Miliband needs to show. And the first year isn’t perfect, people living in the real world with real expectations understood this.

    You come across as an impatient fan who’s all talk and bad mouthing the management because we’re not top of the table the first match after promotion. Be patient my friend and look at the history of opposition leaders, stop fermenting mistrust and doubt and work to change the narrative. Let’s talk about the Coalitions failings and what Labour has to offer. Remember there are big rewards if we can show the economic failings of the Government with sound economics.

    This poll bounce is just that, a bounce, and it will come down rest assured. You moaning (or to be more precise, engaging in a blunt attack on Ed Miliband) does nothing but damage us. If you want to be constructive in developing Labour and think something needs to change then let’s have that conversation, this isn’t that conversation. This is just sad.

  • Stuart

    Calm  yourself down now and have a read of this - 
    http://stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_and_mumbling/2011/09/cognitive-biases-in-football.html, and this - 
    http://stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_and_mumbling/2010/06/class-and-football.html, and this - 
    http://stumblingandmumbling.typepad.com/stumbling_and_mumbling/2011/01/the-dictatorship-of-the-moment.html.

    Now there’s a fella who knows how to mix football and analysis. I’m gonna give Ed another year or so and see what Labour look like then. The party were a joke going into the last election and it’ll take longer than a year or two (if at all) for it to regain a 1997 kind of spark – one of the reasons I actually quite like Ed is that he seems to realise that and seems to be giving the party space to go away and have a long hard look at itself in a context that is very different to the mid-90s. The only thing that worries me about Ed at the moment is this rumour that he has a weak handshake. Anyway, thanks for the 3 points on Saturday, Boing Boing!

  • alex williams

    Not to be unexpected comment from a Blackburn Rovers fan. Miliband was elected by a system that attempted to represent the Party he now leads. He has faults, and many of us wish he was packing more of a punch and highlighting more effectively the failings of this gvt, however I do not see many obvious alternative candidates, getting rid of a leader prematurely and in this way, is pretty much counterproductive, and creates the factions and grudges. Still your conclusion is about as desperate as the metaphor.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=36910622 Edward Carlsson Browne

    Tempting as the invitation to panic based off one poll, from the pollster which shows the worst figures for Labour, which captures a bounce that other polls suggest is already fading, is, I think I’ll pass.

  • Daniel Speight

    Seeing that we know plots are hatched at dinner parties in the deputy leader’s country house, maybe Ed should ask Harman for a peek at her guest lists.

Latest

  • Comment Housing upheaval can be traced back to Thatcher

    Housing upheaval can be traced back to Thatcher

    If further evidence was needed that the Government is destroying our communities then it came by the bucket load with proposals to relocate hundreds of housing benefit claimants. Councils across London desperately searched for a solution to the housing benefit cap that made it impossible for some of the capital’s poorest residents to stay in their homes. First we heard of plans to move residents to Darlington, Stoke, Hull and parts of Yorkshire. But the revelation that Westminster Council planned [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured The austerity consensus has collapsed

    The austerity consensus has collapsed

    There is no alternative: the only way out of Britain’s current economic plight is massive cuts to public spending. Taxes on the wealthiest must be slashed: they are blocks on aspiration and economically counterproductive. Austerity is the only game in town. Or so we have been told ever since the Coalition was formed in the rose gardens of Number 10 Downing Street. The overwhelming majority of the media has gladly reinforced the Government line, and those voices calling for an [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Should Labour go further on football reform?

    Should Labour go further on football reform?

    “As a party, Labour should take great pride in the fact that we initiated Supporters Direct, but now is the time to go further.” These sentiments, expressed in a recent article for Progress by Steve Rotheram MP, hark back to a time where the landscape was somewhat different for the Labour party, but similar in many ways to that faced by football supporters in 2012. The Football Taskforce was established soon after Labour came to power in 1997, with the [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Making Labour Policy: Who calls the tune?

    Making Labour Policy: Who calls the tune?

    Excellent election results and rising polls have brought a mood of unity and created space and time for serious work on policy. Francois Hollande’s victory shows that austerity is not the only option, and Labour must start to develop an alternative agenda, rejecting the Tory politics of resentment and division in favour of policies which are fair, principled and credible: on housing, crime, transport, health, schools, higher education, manufacturing, tax, defence, social care, equality, employment rights and the environment. We [...]

    Read more →
  • News It’s the budget what won it…

    It’s the budget what won it…

    Why did Labour win the 2010 local elections so convincingly? It’s the budget right? This graph of polling from TNS BMRB certainly suggests that. Labour’s slim lead extends rapidly following the budget (highlighted) – and current stands at 12 points (42/30). And as for why Labour did better in 2012 compared to the 2011 elections – just compare May and May 2012. A year is a long time in politics…

    Read more →