Sometimes the home fixtures are the hardest

June 28, 2012 9:31 am

As I may have mentioned (once or twice), I’m a Sunderland fan. During my nearly twenty years of supporting them they have achieved the record lowest points total for a Premier League club.

Twice.

Watching your football team lose every week takes its toll on even the most upbeat fan. Eventually many otherwise loyal supporters snap. Players are booed off at half time. At full time. After a misplaced shot, or a wayward pass.

Sunderland – eventually – got better. But for some fans the booing Rubicon had been crossed. Now being behind at half time, or drawing even, was a boo-able offence. Despite times changing, and the relationship between the club and it’s supporters improving, some people had just lost faith.

It meant that at times, the home games could be the hardest.

I’m using this torturous metaphor because I’m on my way to hear Ed Miliband address Unite’s conference in Brighton. On paper this is a home fixture, but like at Sunderland’s Stadium of Light, there will be those there who once gave Labour their wholehearted support, but have now lost faith.

Some might even boo. It wouldn’t surprise me.

The knee-jerk reaction from the party would be to argue that those who oppose Miliband aren’t Labour supporters. For some that may be true – there are always a number of union activists who are part of the rag tag bunch of parties on the ultra-left (recognisable by their obsession with newsprint and acronym based party names).

They never liked Labour anyway.

But a more substantial proportion of trade union activists and members are part of the great mass of people who became disillusioned with Labour – a segment of the 5 million lost voters as it were. They may grumble and gripe about Labour’s direction. About Labour in power. They might even, like the frustrated Sunderland fans, continue to boo even when – as with Ed Miliband – performances improve.

What they are looking for – and I admit I’m looking for it too – is something that will restore faith in Labour, and what we’re here to do. Too often we are told that New Labour did little – nonsense of course, the minimum wage, maternity pay, paternity leave, equal rights, slashing child poverty. You know the list. But New Labour ran out of steam inspirationally before it hit the buffers electorally.

What those disillusioned delegates down in Brighton want to hear today is a reason to believe again. They want to believe that Labour can win, and by doing so change Britain. There will no doubt be questions about Labour’s direction, public sector pay, and support for strike action. But most of all they want their faith restored. The sense of expectation at best and disappointment at worst will be overwhelming.

I know the sensation well. I’m a Sunderland fan. And that’s why I never forget that sometimes the home fixtures are the hardest…

Update: Ed Miliband’s speech was well received in the end. Perhaps because he restored a little faith. We shall see…

20120628-093124.jpg

  • Daniel Speight

    Well Mark comparing Labour with Sunderland is good in a way as at least both are at (in) the top table.

    My team Charlton, despite having one of the best games in living memory in beating Sunderland in a play-off final, are no longer there. So just like Labour’s sister party PASOK, it’s very easy and very quick to no longer be up at that table. Maybe we should learn from at least some of those people booing at both places.

  • PaulHalsall

    We need to find an Alex Ferguson!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Homfray/510980099 Mike Homfray

    I’m an Evertonian, and we have one of the best leaders in the form of David Moyes – but we still haven’t achieved silverware although we have  made huge progress with hardly anything in the way of resources.

    So lets not put too much stress on individuals to take us to the promised land

    I think that people fall in to one of two camps

    1. The impatient – who want to see evidence of change, definitive policy etc and think it needs to happen now

    2. The long-haulers – who think our current position is sound and we should take our time to develop policy in the light of the 2015 election and the evidence of the Tory-Lib squabbling. Kepp steady, build it up slowly and soundly

    I am in the second category but can understand the feelings of those in the first

  • jonathanmorse

    Surely we either have to accept full guilt for the crash or defend our actions. I think we should talk about all the school roofs we fixed. Until we do the 2 Ed’s will be seen as guilty and complicit, and I don’t see us winning with them. I’m not sure if an election defeat would be so bad if it meant getting rid of them, though. I don’t want 5 more years of the Tories, yet I’m sure most Labour MP’s are content with being in opposition, since they don’t have to have the sort of discipline necessary to win nor the calibre to be any good in office – they’re there because of who they know, who they worked for, not because they’re any good or in any way Labour.

    • Jeremy_Preece

      I would agree with the first part of your comment, Labour needs to be positive. Labour did not cause the banking crisis, that was world wide and started in the USA. Labour did react quickly and posistively there after. No government seem to have seen the crisis coning and so you are right that Labour today should never have allowed the Conservatives to have tried to fix the blame on Labour.

      To an extent many of the governments who were in power at the time throughout the world, ahave taken some kick back over the crisis. The error in this country, was to allow the Conservatives to have got away with pinning the blame, and not chaellenging the Tories on their behavour while in opposition. Inparticualr the Tory pledge to match Labour’s spending as well as their rejection of any kind of control over the banks at all.

      While you cannot dredge up all past grudges, it is important that the electorate is reminded that Cameron’s projection of himself as “above it all” and as economically brilliant, needs to be challenged as it is clearly not true.

      • Daniel Speight

        Labour did not cause the banking crisis, that was world wide and started in the USA.

        But in many ways it was a political problem. The cause goes way back to before Blair, to the ‘Big Bang’ in the City under Thatcher. What does come back to haunt new Labour is that they went along with this light touch, under regulated financial system. The independence of the Bank of England was Blair and Brown’s policy after all. So yes New Labour did not cause the crash all by themselves, but the likes of Blair, Brown and Mandelson have to take some of the blame.

  • robertcp

    Politics in a democracy is about convincing the electorate that you are less idiotic and objectionable than the other lot.  People are rightly cynical about politicians at the moment but they can see that this government is even more awful than New Labour.

Latest

  • Comment Europe We do not stigmatise your country, Deputy Prime Minister. It is you and your party we find distasteful

    We do not stigmatise your country, Deputy Prime Minister. It is you and your party we find distasteful

    Last Saturday a senior European politician wrote an article in the British press which made you want to shout at the computer screen. Not such an unusual event, you might think, but this was not a debater’s disagreement as one might have had with the viewpoint of a Tory, a Gaullist or a Christian Democrat. It was one which also left the reader feeling a bit nauseous. And that is because, rather than an honestly-expressed case justified with some evidence, it was [...]

    Read more →
  • News Watson urges investigation of “supressed” Leveson evidence – Media roundup: May 21st, 2013

    Watson urges investigation of “supressed” Leveson evidence – Media roundup: May 21st, 2013

    Subscribers to our morning email get the best of LabourList – including the Media and blog round up – every weekday morning. If you were a subscriber you would have already received this in your inbox. You can sign up here. Labour proposes teachers spend time in industry “All teachers involved in vocational education would have to spend a period of each year in industry, under Labour plans to integrate further education with emerging skills gaps identified by businesses. The strategy – announced on [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Is party politics dying out?

    Is party politics dying out?

    This week has brought the role of party members and activists back to the front pages. That’s rather unusual to be honest – and rightly so, as party members (swivel eyed and otherwise) make up only 1% of the British population. Being a party member is already a niche interest. You are somewhat odd if you’re a party member – sorry to break that to you, but of course I’m odd too (and quite possibly odder than you). What swivel-eyed [...]

    Read more →
  • News Labour Equal marriage amendment gets Tory backing

    Labour Equal marriage amendment gets Tory backing

    From: HERBERT, Nick Sent: 20 May 2013 16:29 To: HERBERT, Nick Subject: Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill – voting today   Dear Colleague Thank you for your support for the Marriage (Same Sex Couples) Bill at Second Reading. You will be aware of the amendments tabled by Tim Loughton and others (new Clauses 10 & 11) to extend civil partnerships to heterosexual couples I have no issue with the principle of this proposal, but I am very worried that adding this measure to the [...]

    Read more →
  • News Whitewash report claims that there’s no such thing as DWP “league tables” for sanctions

    Whitewash report claims that there’s no such thing as DWP “league tables” for sanctions

    Whilst the Westminster village has been working itself up into a lather over the rise of UKIP and when/if there should be an EU referendum, the DWP snuck out a report on the evidence of DWP league tables that we brought you recently. It’s a total whitewash. The report – which you can read here – argues that claims of a league table are entirely down to individual managers at a number of job centres. You could call it the [...]

    Read more →