Ex-SNP deputy leader says the party is “Totalitarian”

11th September, 2012 3:24 pm

Jim Sillars lays into Salmond and co:

“Totalitarian would be a fair description of Scotland’s majority party.”

(h/t and full story over at Left Foot Forward)

  • franwhi

    Totalitarian compared to who ? The guy who took his party and his country into war on two fronts – Iraq and Afghanistan – in complete disregard of international law and the protests of millions of Uk citizens. Aye right !!

    • John Ruddy

      And if any SNP MPs/MSPs disagree with Salmond in the way many Labour MPs/MSPs did with Tony Blair over Iraq – they would be out. De-selected, banished and retired – permanently.  Some might be able to make a come back (such as Jim’s wife, Margo McDonald) – but not many.

      And they all know that. One wrong move, and its gone.

  • NT86

    To be honest I’ve always thought that there’s something of night (to quote Ann Widdecombe) about Salmond. Too presidential for my liking.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chris-Brown/1622196102 Chris Brown

    Does anyone really care what Sillars thinks? He did n’t have the courage of his convictions in the 1970s when he formed the Scottish Labour Party with Dick Douglas. His problem is that it is Salmond at the top of the tree and not him.

  • http://twitter.com/youngian67 Ian Young

    All leaders who have a grip on their party will be accused of acting like Stalin at some point, usually by a disgruntled bitter ex-rival. I’m not flag waving for Salmon, but any leader who doesn’t have a grip on their party is not going to win an election.  

Latest

  • Comment Staying together for the kids

    Staying together for the kids

    Can a political party attend relationship counselling? Never mind the big tent: how big would the couch have to be? Or is the Labour party now displaying signs of having irreconcilable differences? Is it time to cut the ties, and the losses, call it a day and move on? The abuse currently being hurled in several directions hardly points to a sense of common purpose, solidarity or collective action. The anger on social media is quite something. Dip any digit […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Having the ambition to put ending child poverty at the heart of leadership is why I’m backing Yvette

    Having the ambition to put ending child poverty at the heart of leadership is why I’m backing Yvette

    Leading the Labour Party is a big job, and it’s a serious job – that’s why we need a leader who brings strength and a track record to the role. Nobody doubts Yvette’s toughness or her experience, but what’s really important to me is the way she’s drawing on that experience to set out her stall for the future of our country and our party, and how that reflects her values. Yvette’s achievements in government, and as shadow home secretary, […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured London needs a Mayor with conviction

    London needs a Mayor with conviction

    Labour supporters have a clear choice when selecting our Mayoral candidate. We can settle for mediocrity – picking a bland candidate, who won’t rock the boat and is too scared to challenge the inequality that increasingly prevents Londoners from reaching their potential. Or we can choose a conviction politician, with real Labour values – someone not afraid to stand up to the powerful and fight for social justice and equality for all Londoners. A Mayor who will deliver a new […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Victory is what we owe to the people we represent

    Victory is what we owe to the people we represent

    In 1963 JFK prepared (but never got to deliver) a speech attacking ‘voices preaching doctrines which apparently assume that … vituperation is as good as victory.’ Reading that last phrase recently I knew immediately what he meant. Years ago, after the 1980 local elections in the wake of Thatcher’s victory, there was a view in some quarters that, even when we won control locally, we should remain in opposition to ‘teach the electorate a lesson’. The idea was that if […]

    Read more →
  • Comment How well does Labour know its own members?

    How well does Labour know its own members?

    Reading an article on ConservativeHome provided a clear demonstration of how the Conservatives have embraced technology and have left Labour behind.  Without a clear signal of intent and without significant investment in tech, the Party will be hobbled at future elections. Fundamentally, the Party does not appear to have the level of information and detail required about its own members, let alone its voters and potential voters.  Without this it cannot motivate anyone.  The ability to tailor a pitch, an […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit