Ex-SNP deputy leader says the party is “Totalitarian”

11th September, 2012 3:24 pm

Jim Sillars lays into Salmond and co:

“Totalitarian would be a fair description of Scotland’s majority party.”

(h/t and full story over at Left Foot Forward)

  • franwhi

    Totalitarian compared to who ? The guy who took his party and his country into war on two fronts – Iraq and Afghanistan – in complete disregard of international law and the protests of millions of Uk citizens. Aye right !!

    • John Ruddy

      And if any SNP MPs/MSPs disagree with Salmond in the way many Labour MPs/MSPs did with Tony Blair over Iraq – they would be out. De-selected, banished and retired – permanently.  Some might be able to make a come back (such as Jim’s wife, Margo McDonald) – but not many.

      And they all know that. One wrong move, and its gone.

  • NT86

    To be honest I’ve always thought that there’s something of night (to quote Ann Widdecombe) about Salmond. Too presidential for my liking.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Chris-Brown/1622196102 Chris Brown

    Does anyone really care what Sillars thinks? He did n’t have the courage of his convictions in the 1970s when he formed the Scottish Labour Party with Dick Douglas. His problem is that it is Salmond at the top of the tree and not him.

  • http://twitter.com/youngian67 Ian Young

    All leaders who have a grip on their party will be accused of acting like Stalin at some point, usually by a disgruntled bitter ex-rival. I’m not flag waving for Salmon, but any leader who doesn’t have a grip on their party is not going to win an election.  


  • Comment Unions Why we joined the tens of thousands marching in Manchester

    Why we joined the tens of thousands marching in Manchester

    By Cllr Jim McMahon and Cllr Kieran Quinn If you believe the hype, Greater Manchester’s aspiration and politics is all about the “Northern Powerhouse”. As Leaders of two Greater Manchester Councils playing important roles on the GM Combined Authority, we should be at the front and centre of this Tory ideal, keenly setting out our stall to display the “Powerhouse” at conference season. So when the Tory Party Conference descended on Manchester this week you be forgiven for thinking we’d […]

    Read more →
  • News Weekly Survey: Tuition fees, London and Scotland

    Weekly Survey: Tuition fees, London and Scotland

    During the leadership election, Jeremy Corbyn declared that he would want to abolish tuition fees if he becomes Prime Minister. The policy will have to go through Labour’s policy review channels, and his campaign team calculates that it would cost around £10 billion. Do you think that Labour should commit to spending that on scrapping university fees? Zac Goldsmith has now been selected by the Tories to take on Labour’s Sadiq Khan in next year’s Mayor of London contest. What […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Reaching out to micro businesses and self-employed, the Labour Party way

    Reaching out to micro businesses and self-employed, the Labour Party way

    At the moment, it seems one of the big questions is – how Labour are you really? As we couldn’t have experienced more viscerally than since 7 May, the party that we love covers a huge spectrum of people from all walks of live, with their different experiences, perspectives and approaches. And it’s growing by the day. In an age of such frustration at politics, Jeremy Corbyn can take great heart from and credit for that. I would argue that […]

    Read more →
  • News George Osborne “doesn’t live in the real world”

    George Osborne “doesn’t live in the real world”

    George Osborne’s failure to mention the Redcar steel plant, where 1,700 workers are losing their jobs, shows that he “doesn’t live in the real world”, according to Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell. Osborne made a half hour speech at the Conservative conference in Manchester earlier today, with McDonnell slamming the Chancellor’s omission of the job losses from his address. McDonnell is today visiting Redcar with Shadow Business Secretary Angela Eagle to speak to steelworkers losing their livelihoods. “They want substantive answers […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured So long, Denis

    So long, Denis

    I was once writing a column about leadership and those moments when you really have to be tough and probably end up upsetting people. In my head was a phrase I was sure I had heard Denis Healey use on one occasion – that while “sometimes you may have to be a bastard you must never be a shit”. But as this column was for the FT, there was no way I was going to be allowed just to claim […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends