The Lib Dem betrayal of students takes effect this month

September 7, 2012 1:44 pm

Up and down the land, parents will this month go through the rollercoaster of emotions as they see their children leaving home to begin new chapters in their lives at university. But along with the normal mixture of pride in their children’s achievements and sorrow because they are leaving home, we can now add anxiety because of the Liberal Democrats’ broken promises.

For this is also the month when the shame of increased tuition fees of up to £9,000 becomes a reality.

And it is perhaps that decision more than any other which demonstrates the betrayal of the voters who placed their trust in the Lib Dems at 2010 General Election.

Let us not be mistaken – it may not be the most far reaching or damaging of their decisions.  The Lib Dems have also played their part by supporting policies that are damaging our economy, increasing poverty, worsening the housing crisis and giving huge tax cuts to millionaires. But the Lib Dems’ support of hiking tuition fees was about more than impact – it was about disloyalty to the people who voted yellow and got blue.

It begs the question why Nick Clegg agreed to go into coalition with David Cameron.  What have the Liberal Democrat voters and supporters got out of this deal?

To turn on students, and the hard-working parents who support them, was perhaps the Lib Dems’ ultimate treachery.

Of course, we’ve seen examples of this locally.  Those among us who have witnessed the incompetence of Lib Dem politics at local level have been totally unsurprised by their lack of skill, guile and wit on the national stage too.

Here in Derby, we’ve already been through the rigmarole of seeing less than able Liberal Democrats being played for fools by their Tory puppeteers. We’ve also witnessed coalitions between the two in which the Lib Dems have been bullied into voting through Tory decisions with seemingly no incentive to support their own views.

But this comes back to a fundamental point I’ve made time and again: the reason the Lib Dems are not capable of standing up for their own policies is because, in reality, they don’t really have any. They say what they need to say to appeal to voters and, until the last couple of years, they have never had to deliver. It’s a great approach to winning votes but one which is bound to end in failure and betrayal when you finally find a way to take power.

But while the students and parents having to stump up the £9,000 tuition fees are the most visible victims of the Lib Dems’ broken promises, they are not the only ones. We also have to consider the many young people across the country who won’t be going to university – not because they didn’t make the grades because it is simply unaffordable.

One of Labour’s many achievements in Government was to make sure university entry was not based on financial clout, but in one fell swoop the Tories and Lib Dems have wiped that out.

It is a travesty.  The Lib Dems promised to help students then did the opposite, but the people who voted for them aren’t stupid.  As local election results around the country have indicated, people are showing the Lib Dems what they think of them in the best way possible: at the ballot box.

Chris Williamson is the Labour MP for Derby North

  • http://twitter.com/willmill82 Will Millinship

    “One of Labour’s many achievements in Government was to make sure university entry was not based on financial clout, but in one fell swoop the Tories and Lib Dems have wiped that out.”
    Did you really type that with a straight face? Labour introduced, then tripled, tuition fees. 

  • binny_uk

    Where are the parents having to stump up £9000? Show them to us.

    You can’t, because there aren’t any. Whatever the rights and wrongs of the Lib Dems voting for the tuition fee reforms, there are no parents or first-time students having to pay any fees at all, never mind £9000. In fact, all but those students who end up earning the highest wages upon graduation will pay less per month and less overall than those who went to university under the old system.

    As a long-time Lib Dem I welcome Labour to the anti-fees cause. If Labour MPs had been so vehemently opposed to fees all along, Tony Blair wouldn’t have been able to introduce them or raise them as he did.

    But articles like this, falsely suggesting that parents or students will have to find the money to pay student tuition, have a terribly corrosive effect on young people and parents making decisions about their future. The worst thing Labour politicians could do for raising education levels amongst the poor was to bring in university tuition fees. You already did that. The second most damaging thing you could do is to run campaigns and write articles like this one which frighten people from low-income families out of going to university because of misinformation about the cost.

    If you really are more concerned with winning votes than with getting people out of poverty – as Liberals have always suspected – then carry on, I’m sure you’ll win lots of seats, but it will be at the expense of hundreds and maybe thousands of people your party claims to represent having lower life achievement and missing out on countless opportunities to improve their lives.

    It’s entirely up to you.

  • postageincluded

    The reason the LDs are so…. well let’s be charitable…”flexible” is that they have no real constituency, only “principles” and “ideas”. Labour may sometimes fail to represent workers very well (some will say “often not at all” I know) but the party is held together by the feeling that we should be doing it.

    Who do the LDs represent? Without that anchor to humanity, principles can be restated as justification of anything, and we’ve seen just about everything, including the student fees measures, described as “progressive” by these modern day Whigs. Pshaw to your Progress I say!

    You’re right to remind us, Chris. How about a regular “Betrayal of the Month”? You’ll never run out of material.

  • markfergusonuk

    If Labour lost the moral high ground on tuition fees when we ignored a manifesto commitment and voted for them (and I think that’s probably the case), there is no way a Lib Dem can say ” I welcome Labour to the anti-fees cause” with a straight face.
    None of the major parties comes out well from the tuition fees mess

  • paul_volt

    ‘Libdems have no policies’..really…can I remind you that Ed wrote your last manifesto…your MP’s got elected on it …then he tore it up….started a public consultation …sidelined that…and now back into internal policy making….the only policy labour seems to have is to say they wouldn’t do that…or that…or that …or that….but wont tell us how in gods name they intend to pay for it…remember the note…’sorry there’s no money left’

    As to the betrayal over tuition fees..the betrayal would have been to leave it as it was…do you realise that under the new system someone leaving uni and going into work on an average salary for grads (£17K-£23K) will pay a fraction of what they would have done under the old system. Yes the students under your system may very well pay off the loan after say 16 years and pay back around £26k…but under the new system based on a similar pay level rise they will pay much less even than the £26k even after 30 years. All you are doing is going for cheep votes and those cheep votes are about putting the fear of god into families.

  • Hamish Dewar

    The situation in Scotland is a strong argument for English Independence.

  • williamtheconker

    I don’t remember my own tax going down because students were going to be forced to pay for their own tuition.
    It didn’t did it, that was just another sneaky tax-raising measure – Kerching Gordon!

Latest

  • Featured Why we love Woolwich

    Why we love Woolwich

    Woolwich is an amazing place. It’s where the Labour party was founded as a mass membership organization. The Woolwich Provident was one of Britain’s first building societies. The Royal Arsenal Coop one of our first cooperative societies. Woolwich had the second Polytechnic in the country, created with the aim of providing education for working adults. Woolwich is my nearest big town centre, where I shop and go to meet friends. In the last few days, for many people, its name [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Technology isn’t just something for geeks to worry about

    Technology isn’t just something for geeks to worry about

    If you Google ‘Ed Miliband,’ you quickly get the old stuff about him being a bit of geek. His appearance at Google’s big Tent on Wednesday almost begged the headline “Geek Goes Home”. But that assumes technology is just something for geeks to worry about, and that Ed is a techie. Neither are true. What we saw on Wednesday was a leader with the courage to tell Google straight that it should live up to its founding principles on the [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Woolwich: The British people – and our politicians – have risen to the occasion

    Woolwich: The British people – and our politicians – have risen to the occasion

    “We want to start a war” – Woolwich attacker “right now it is only you versus many people, you are going to lose” - Ingrid Loyau-Kennett Only 24 hours ago, news began to trickle through about a barbarous crime, committed on the streets of our capital city, in broad daylight. It seems that the murderers who attacked and brutally murdered a soldier felt they were acting in a way endorsed by their religious beliefs and their god. But to try and [...]

    Read more →
  • News Labour NEC Report – 21st May 2013

    Labour NEC Report – 21st May 2013

    Party Organisation The General Secretary (GS) noted the party’s good performance in the recent Local, Mayoral and South Shields elections and thanked all members, activists and staff for their contribution to that success. The committee discussed the work of Blue State Digital who have been brought in to revolutionise the party’s use of new and social media as part of our suite of campaign tools. It was noted that Matthew McGregor, Head of Blue State Digital’s London Office and former [...]

    Read more →
  • News Labour’s London Assembly Leader responds to Woolwich attack

    Labour’s London Assembly Leader responds to Woolwich attack

    Following yesterday’s attack in Woolwich, Leader of the Labour Group on the London Assembly Len Duvall AM said: “The attack in Woolwich was horrific, the actions of local people in response and the head-teacher and staff at the school are a reflection of the values and strength of our community. “At this afternoon’s London Assembly Police and Crime Committee questions will be asked about yesterday’s attack and the response, and at a future assembly meeting we will come together to [...]

    Read more →