This is what conference should be about

September 30, 2012 2:47 pm

Although conference didn’t really start until today, yesterday was the day that events really started. Women’s conference appears to have been a success (and the biggest one yet), but where I spent the afternoon was in an academy in Moss Side, listening to Ed Miliband host a Q&A organised by Manchester Evening News. It was an interesting, if largely uneventful affair. There was briefly some confusion about Miliband’s position on repealing the NHS reform bill (later clarified), and some mood music around tackling youth unemployment and investment in infrastructure spending (especially housing) which I’d expect to be fleshed out more on Tuesday in the leader’s speech.

But I don’t really want to talk about Ed Miliband’s Q&A (even I thought it was a relatively positive experience). The audience were broadly Labour supporting and he didn’t get too many tough questions. I want to talk instead about a conversation I had on the way to the event.

I was picked up by a cab outside my hotel. We made small talk for a few minutes as we weaved our way towards the east of the city. Why was I in Manchester? What was happening at the conference? What do I do? (always a tricky one for a blogger to answer).

But then he started talking to me, openly and honestly. He told me about how his job has driven him to distraction, and recently, almost to tears. He told me about how his work was made harder by competitors who broke the law, wouldn’t play by the rules, and stole his customers. He told me about how he hadn’t had a day off for three years, despite working seven day weeks. He told me that every time he lost a customer to someone who had cheated him out of it, it was a real blow – he relied on the fares to make ends meet. No fares = no money.

We talked about how this was the same in many other professions. From temporary agency workers to contractors. How it often feels like those who play by the rules, try to be honest and do the right thing, are left behind. Whilst those who break the rules, cut corners and don’t give anything back seem to reap the rewards. In banking, like his line of work, risky behaviour and lawlessness seemed to be rewarded financially. Yet for all of the banker-bashing you hear in the party, how often does the plight of the agency worker, the cabbie, the zero hour contract shift worker get a mention?

Labour has the potential to seize a really compelling narrative about the way this country has gone wrong – at a really basic level – for millions of people, and how it could be put right. A narrative that speaks to the British sense of fair play and the sort of pride in the advance of British society that Danny Boyle’s Olympic opening ceremony engendered. The idea of a fair day’s pay for an honest day’s work, fair holidays, punishments for those who break societies rules and rewards for those who follow them. A society where working hard is genuinely rewarded. The predators and the producers aren’t just at the top of society, they’re at every level.

If Miliband wants to “rebuild Britain”, then a good place to start would be with rebuilding the kind of society that my honest, hard working cabbie could make a decent living in, playing by the rules and giving his fair share.

Because if we can’t/won’t do it – who will?

  • Dave Postles

    ‘Because if we can’t/won’t do it – who will?’
    Only the unions, it seems.

  • MarkHoulbrook

    “If Miliband wants to “rebuild Britain”, then a good place to start would be with rebuilding the kind of society that my honest, hard working cabbie could make a decent living in, playing by the rules and giving his fair share”.

    Now where have you heard that before Ed.

    Len McCluskey and Paul Kenny are spot on about their recent contribution to the state of the Labour Party

    The Blairite dead and the other website are now defunct with the challenges of our modern day society.  They need to be replaced…and replaced they will. The polite elite are dominating the  narrow space at the top of the party. Lets not pretend.

    Excellent presentation by Michael Sandel. Where now for predistribution. Just a thought did David or the other Ed put him up to it. Very alternative Communitarian philosophy. Move on Etzioni, you time is done

  • AlanGiles

    “How it often feels like those who play by the rules, try to be honest
    and do the right thing, are left behind. Whilst those who break the
    rules, cut corners and don’t give anything back seem to reap the
    rewards.”.

    Yes and when you look at the behaviour of politicians, from David Laws, Michael Gove, Duncan-Smith, not to mention “Boat-rocker” Blears, The Balls, Kaufmann etc etc etc, you realise how insulting it is, for politicians to dare talk about such matters.

  • https://mikestallard.virtualgallery.com/ Mike Stallard

    “The idea of a fair day’s pay for an honest day’s work, fair holidays, punishments for those who break societies rules and rewards for those who follow them. A society where working hard is genuinely rewarded. The predators and the producers aren’t just at the top of society, they’re at every level.”
    Allow me to say that this is exactly what the Right are saying. We are both on the same side.

    Benefit cheats and Bankers.
    People who rip off the County by taking enormous salaries and expenses and people who falsely say they are disabled when they aren’t.
    People who suck the blood out of ordinary people by living off the Welfare State and people who abuse the system by expenses swindles.
    Pilgrims and people who rip off their own employees.

    If only we could all come together and deal with it instead of being so utterly short sighted.

    PS Anyone ever realised that Baroness Ashton earns more than Hillary Clinton?

  • Serbitar

    There is a further complication.

    In the modern world it no longer seems to be sufficient to love “hard-working families” and pledge yourself to advantage them: in the modern world it now seems de rigueur to hate the needy, sick, and helpless and attempt to make their already too hard lives even harder by cutting support to them, briefing against them, and attacking their interests collectively and individually.

    Based on speeches and literature made and written by significant Labour figures, from Ed Miliband downwards, many vague promises of help to “ordinary” workers (like cabbies) are interleaved with hints about the opposite intentions as far as “scrounging” benefit claimants are concerned, i.e., Labour expresses its intention to help people who are lucky enough to enjoy secure, waged employment coupled with hints at simultaneous parallel reductions in assistance and imposition of penalties in respect to the needy, just like the Tories, despite the fact that most of the latter group would give their right arms to be elevated to the status of a cabbie or some other gainfully employed “ordinary” worker. One concrete example of this nonsense is Labour’s idea to skew offers of council house tenancies to favour working people and disadvantage the non-working irrespective of relevant need which is entirely because it implicitly blames the non-working for their plight and punishes them for circumstances almost certainly beyond their control. Allocating council house tenancies by raffle or similar would be infinitely fairer. 

    Labour should have a mission to help ALL citizens, working AND non-working.

    It should not be sectional or pillory benefit claimants because the Daily Mail says so.

  • uglyfatbloke

    AlanGiles makes an excellent point. The political community has chosen to let hundred (yes hundreds) of MPs and ‘Lords’ off the hook for stealing absolute fortunes as if it it was OK because they were all at it. 
    Well it was n’t OK, but the media and the politicians have cooperated to get the whole question out of the public eye and we are all failing ourselves and one another by not pursuing the issue relentlessly and at every opportunity. Over 400 MPs – and god knows how many ‘Lords’  - gave back money that they had stolen; they were mostly guilty abnd they knew it. Half of the theives and cheats are still in the Commons getting a minimum of £1300 per week . How have we let them get away with it and  why is nothing being done about it?

  • Monkey_Bach

    Eeek! This sounds like a paraphrase of an episode from the West Wing called “20 Hours in America Part II” during which Toby Ziegler meets an affable chap in a bar whom he chats to casually about static wages, direct taxes, university fees and how difficult it is to make ends meet as an “ordinary Joe” and head of a “hard-working family” which “does the right thing” and yet finds itself stretched and struggling all the time. Eeek. Is this an example of art imitating life or life imitating art? Eeek. What a condrundrum. Eeek.

  • Carolekins

    You’re right.  I did get a glimpse of this approach in Ed Balls’ speech.  Fairness is incredibly important.

  • James Brown

    Spot on. We should hear more about this.

    NB – ‘society’s’ not “societies”

  • James Brown

    Spot on. We should hear more about this.

    NB – ‘society’s’ not “societies”

Latest

  • Video Cameron refuses to answer question on secret government plans to hike interest on student loans

    Cameron refuses to answer question on secret government plans to hike interest on student loans

    Last week it was revealed that the government discussed secret plans to hike interest on pre-existing student loans, meaning that anyone with a student loan will be expected to pay far more than expected. Today, the Prime Minister was asked about this – he spoke for nearly a minute but wouldn’t answer the question. What does he have to hide? How much more does he expect graduates to pay?

    Read more →
  • Comment Who benefits? Delivering on energy and infrastructure

    Who benefits? Delivering on energy and infrastructure

    Across the industrial north, it is striking how old pit villages and industrial towns are proving far less willing to embrace renewable energy than the noisier, more polluting fossil fuels and industries which shaped their identity. Energy companies are getting a nasty shock after mistakenly believing that these communities would not bat an eyelid at a few wind turbines on the surrounding hills because they had been content to make huge slag heaps part of the landscape in decades past. [...]

    Read more →
  • News Put reckless bankers in jail – Media roundup: June 19th, 2013

    Put reckless bankers in jail – Media roundup: June 19th, 2013

    Subscribers to our morning email get the best of LabourList – including the Media and blog round up – every weekday morning. If you were a subscriber you would have already received this (and much more) in your inbox. You can sign up here. Put reckless bankers in jail Britain’s banking bosses should face jail if their decisions force fresh bailouts, the Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards says today. The commission’s hotly anticipated report urges the Chancellor, George Osborne, to oversee the [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Wise heads – 5 ex-ministers Miliband could put in the Shadow Cabinet

    Wise heads – 5 ex-ministers Miliband could put in the Shadow Cabinet

    Last week I highlighted 5 women from the 2010 intake who Ed Miliband could add to his Shadow Cabinet in the coming months. Today I’ve taken a look at five of the wise heads on the backbenches with experience of government who could add something to Miliband’s front bench team in opposition: Alistair Darling – the obvious candidate for a return to the Shadow Cabinet at some point, Alastair Darling managed the remarkable feat of overseeing a financial crisis, and [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Unison Conference 2013 Why the government are keen to use trade unions as a scapegoat

    Why the government are keen to use trade unions as a scapegoat

    “Mike Bassett did a better job as bloody England manager than David Cameron has as Prime Minister” Ricky Tomlinson tells me as he pauses for photos with union members at UNISON’s annual conference in Liverpool. Ricky’s just delivered a powerful opening speech to 2,000 UNISON members packed into the Echo Arena. Just like the final scene of his film Mike Bassett: England Manager, Ricky leaves the stage with his clenched fists pumping the air as thunderous applause fills the room. [...]

    Read more →