Is David Miliband returning to the fold?

October 18, 2012 12:43 pm

David Miliband has been understandably keen to keep himself out of the limelight – and avoid commenting on domestic politics – in the two years since the Labour leadership contest. Many people – including me – have called for David to return to the frontbench, but by the end of this year’s conference I had begun to suspect David was thinking of moving away from front line politics, despite being a more visible presence around the conference centre itself.

And yet all of a sudden in the last twenty four hours there has been something of a (controlled) explosion of activity from the elder Miliband. There was a column in today’s Guardian, in which he pushed for public service reform (although not acceptance of Tory public service reform, like Mandelson did yesterday). In fact, the following paragraph on a different kind of state sounds like the kind of thing key Ed Miliband outriders like Marc Stears might have said:

“The fiscal crunch requires a different kind of state. The failure of the government’s economic policy makes how much less we spend, and how and where we spend it, a core issue. We cannot meet our goals on jobs, health, education, long-term care and tackling poverty without changing the way government goes about its business.”

Just as interesting – although less widely reported, was that David Miliband’s speaking tour of UK universities started up again yesterday. David did that last year, so it’s no surprise to see it return, but the accompanying press release is about as on message as it’s possible to be:

“Students in the UK are now facing the reality of government policies that are dividing this country. I am looking forward to setting out the values of the Labour Party to students now getting directly hit by regressive Tory policies. A united, ‘One Nation’ Britain reboots its economy and builds a fairer society in the context of massive global change with a shift of economic power from west to east.

“I am also going on this tour to listen, to listen to the voices that will shape our country’s future and to show them that politicians need their ideas and capacity to help change our country. After last year’s success with the Living Wage campaign I am also looking forward to more victories with Labour Students and Movement for Change to demonstrate that it is the Labour Party that best represents the aspirations of young people and the community of respect and dignity in which they want to live.”

One Nation? Living wage? It’s a statement that either Miliband could make.

What David Miliband has been trying to do over the past two years is slowly reintroduce himself to the debate, until we reach a point where his interventions don’t automatically trigger off a spate of media comment. Now that Ed Miliband’s position as Labour leader is beyond dispute, he may well have acheived that. And with him chairing a policy review meeting in the next few days, those writing off a possible David Miliband return – myself included – may be proved wrong, after all.

One thing is for sure though, the current situation isn’t tenable in the long term. By the next election David Miliband should be back in the shadow cabinet – or he should retire.

  • Doctor Yellow Face

    What i think is far more likey is that David will play a key role in manifest development and contribution much like he did before 97 and so on. 

    I can see a ed speech that pans out as such: 

    “families thoughout are nation are facing difficult times whether they be job related, mortgage related or for great personal reasons. 

    We in this labour party know that times are tough for families and I know the challanges families face look at me and my brother for example. 

    But throught this nation families pull together to make the tough decisions to steer a path out of the storm. 

    So today My family is pulling together in the national interest. To deliver a one nation Britain with a level playing field, fair taxes, fair pay, fair cuts and to rebuild Britain  stronger if not for our generation but the next. 

    My brother David will be leading the development of the 2015 labour party GE campaign and will be along with me the shadow cabinet   and you the people of our nation building a platform for change and growth, shared prosperity, shared opportunity and shared values. “ 

    Just sayin 

  • http://www.robbiescott.com/ Robbie Scott

    Foreign Secretary when we were busy ferreting people away to North Africa to be tortured. I hope not.

    • AlanGiles

      Exactly – and still a defender of the Iraq war. It just seems New Labour is going to use that nice decorator Jon Cruddas to apply a fresh coat of paint to the rusty old boat. It really seems to have learned nothing.

      • Cari_esky

        I hope and my father who has been a Labour supporter since the 50′s, hopes David does come back into the fold and influences Labour a great deal. The Labour Party needs him at the moment because he can bring a lot of thought and ideas to the Labour Party which ultimately persuades people to vote for Labour.
        All this talk about him whilst he was Home Secretary is just cover for the fact you and some others just do not like him. I do honestly think David will prove you wrong.

    • http://twitter.com/renieanjeh Renie Anjeh

      Not helpful and just cooked-up conspiracy theories. Two Milibands are better than one.

  • http://twitter.com/joefd j farrington-douglas

    “until we reach a point where his interventions don’t automatically trigger off a spate of media comment” 
    Is this blog not part of that trend? Will there be a time when David can contribute to debate without triggering a spate of Labourlist textual analysis and excited discussion of the hidden Milibandological subtext? 

  • ColinAdkins

    David is a busted flush. His return will herald more internecine warfare from unreconstructed Blairites, opportunists and careerists.  The right-wing press will also ‘big up’ David in contrast to Ed so they have a fall back PM if the next election turns out like the current polls and the most overrated politician (Boris Johnson) since John Moore has not replaced Cameron as Tory Party leader which currently looks unlikely. Let him go.

  • ColinAdkins

    David is a busted flush. His return will herald more internecine warfare from unreconstructed Blairites, opportunists and careerists.  The right-wing press will also ‘big up’ David in contrast to Ed so they have a fall back PM if the next election turns out like the current polls and the most overrated politician (Boris Johnson) since John Moore has not replaced Cameron as Tory Party leader which currently looks unlikely. Let him go.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Homfray/510980099 Mike Homfray

      I think I agree. There are plenty of other things he can do

  • markfergusonuk

    Now now Joe – the point at which David Miliband writes a column and not even LabourList mentions it, we will probably all be dust ;)

  • postageincluded

    Retire.

    It’s not the man, or his politics that make me say this. It’s the suspicion that the Tories have trawled through the records for dirt on him, and will leak it when it suits them. And there are a lot of left-liberals who will simply sit on their hands in 2015 if he has a big role in the Shadow cabinet.

  • postageincluded

    Well I do like him, and I’m not an Iraq-war fundamentalist either. The trouble is that an important percentage of Labour’s target voters think he’s soiled goods. And the Tories, and especially the LibDems, will use his prescence in the Shadow Cabinet to damage Labour. For the sake of the party he should let go of his ambitions for government.

  • Dave Postles

    I think that Labour could manage without the Office of David Miliband.  Please sign the petition against austerity as featured in the letter in The Guardian today:

    http://www.coalitionofresistance.org.uk/2012/10/peoplespetition/

  • Jeremy_Preece

    Too late now I know, but I wished that DM had stood for Labour as Mayor of London. He probably would have won it, and stalled the Boris bandwagon. He also would have been able to work in front line poltics and out of Ed’s way.

    Interms of the press, I think that much of our media will try anything to try and sink anyone who is made leader of the Labour Party.

    I think that after 2 years it would be good if DM could join the front bench. I only wish that he had the courage to have stood against Gordon Brown, and left the latter to do what he did best, which was economics and balancing the books. .

  • Alexwilliamz

    I honestly think things have moved on. I’d rather see new blood coming through with genuine leadership qualities, than trying to drag back the best of a pretty average bunch. Still would not be shocked to see an extraordinary rendition ‘leak’ sometime near an election if he was back in a position of responsibility. The next election needs to be about the coalition’s record not Labour’s from 8 years ago.

  • Brumanuensis

    Ho-hum.

    I’ve never been David Miliband’s greatest admirer, but if he genuinely wants to help out, we could use him. 

  • MarkHoulbrook

    There is a perception that manufacturing consent for the return of David Miliband will help Labours cause. It will not. More of the same is not on the menu. Too many cuckoos in Ed cabinet will lead tothe leaders downfall.

  • AlanGiles

    ” I do honestly think David will prove you wrong”

    Do you, Carl?. Well, we will have to see what proves more attractive to Dave – “The Office Of David Miliband” being paid £50,000 p.a. to “advise” a Pakistani bank a couple of days a month and all the other little baubles, or the  opportunity to talk down to us all like schoolchildren with his pompous lectures.

    I take it you and your dad were great admirers of New Labour and wish for 1997 again because D Miliband is as unreconstructed a New Labourite as that other old has-been Mandy. The way forward is to go back 15 years?. Frankly I don’t think so.

    As for that little matter of his attitude and behaviour when he was H.S. extraordinary rendition and all that, well perhaps we should all just close our ears eyes and minds and pretend it never happened.

    • Cari_esky

      I really don’t know what you are on about. I am just an ordinary voter who takes an interest in politics. Yes my dad liked Blair and he also liked Foot, Healey and Kinnock.. And we realise a Labour government is better than not having one at all. It’s just that certain times require something different and in 1997 Labour could not govern how it governed in the past. The social and economic environment was different. As the times are different now which require something different.
      Now because we like Blair and we like David doesn’t mean we want to go back to 1997. We are not that stupid. I want some things renationalised and I want the Unions to play a greater role in people’s work places because I believe they bring security and better working conditions/benefits to the average man and woman and a voice to counteract the people who seem to get away with what they like.

      As for the rendition I have no knowledge of it but I do know that anyone in Government has to make hard and difficult decisions that go against their own ideas. It always happens and if we pick on these things we will never be happy with any politician.
      I takeityou

  • robertcp

    I have read David M’s article and I am completely underwhelmed.  Both parties have been waffling on about public sector reform for at least 30 years and I am not convinced it has made a lot of difference. 

    Cameron was right when he criticised pointless reorganisations but wrong when his government has done a lot of er, pointless reorganisation.

  • Daniel Speight

    Being rather cynical I suspect, but is this an admission by the Blairites that Plan A to unseat Ed Miliband hasn’t worked? Are we now about to see Plan B?

  • Daniel Speight

    Being rather cynical I suspect, but is this an admission by the Blairites that Plan A to unseat Ed Miliband hasn’t worked? Are we now about to see Plan B?

  • Daniel Speight

    Being rather cynical I suspect, but is this an admission by the Blairites that Plan A to unseat Ed Miliband hasn’t worked? Are we now about to see Plan B?

    • http://twitter.com/waterwards dave stone

      The anti-LIvingstone campaign within Labour was, I think, a dress rehearsal for the ousting of Ed. But that fell flat due mainly to major gains elsewhere in local government.

      Following the conference speech (which seems to have produced some disarray within the cuckoo’s ranks) Ed is secure. But the threat of an SDP Mk2 initiative in the run up to 2015 remains.

      Should the SDP Mk2 materialise they will be doomed to failure. The National Health Action Party have said they are prepared to stand against pro-privatisation Blairites in the next general election – and it is the pro-privatisation Blairites who will most likely populate the ranks of an SDP Mk2.  An electoral alliance between NHS supporting Labour and other pro-NHS groups against commercially motivated interests will win much favour from the electorate.

      • John Reid

        Oona King who stood agianst Livingstone was Ed Milibnads biggest supporter, those who were’nt that keen On Ed Like Luke Akehurst and Ellie reeves were big Ed supporters As Was Of course Neil Kinnock who was Kens biggest critic,
        Regaridng the Anti Ken Idea,
        Yes,  Dan Hodges said he would sooner see Boris and voted for labour on the assembly and Lord Sugar said he wouldn’t vote for Ken, But I recall Ken saiyng vote for Independent Lufthur Rahman, and that when he left Labour he was voting for green On the London Assembly, in 2001 and he wouldn’t vote Labour at the 2001 general election,

        What ever you say about the SDP they were deselcted as candidates by Militant and felt they had to leave to give the Public a viable alterantive to a hard left labour and alot of them had been tories or went on to Vote tory in 1992 (Chirs grayling andrew Micthell,Andrew Cooper mark Hunter, andrew Hunter, David Owen, George And Eric brown ,Chris brocklebank and they sided with the Liberals who included John Thruso, Cyril smith and David alton all of whom’s politcal views were much more close to the Tories than labour, they weren’t career politicans but felt that htey had to stay in politics as the party they were once in didn’t represent them and that they wanted a centre left party for the public,

        If there are these Blairites and they are deseleted By the GMB len Mcklusky putting pressure ,I see them just joing the Tories like Luke Bopzier did, or the Lib dems like Ben bradshaws secretary did don’t see them forming A sdp Mk2,

  • http://twitter.com/waterwards dave stone

    “What ever you say about the SDP they were deselcted as candidates by Militant”

    Shirley Williams, David Owen, Bill Rodgers and Roy Jenkins (the ‘Gang of Four’ founding members of the Sainsbury bankrolled SDP) were not deselected by Militant. 

  • Cari_esky

    If people really don’t like David’s politics then get someone to stand against him to take the Labour candidacy in South Shields. Then we can see what the voters of South Sheilds think because in the end it is the constituents who elect him.

  • http://twitter.com/RF_McCarthy Roger McCarthy

    ‘One thing is for sure though, the current situation isn’t tenable in the
    long term. By the next election David Miliband should be back in the
    shadow cabinet – or he should retire’.

    Seriously why?

    He is a properly elected MP and can carry on representing his constituency for decades without holding office again – as a large majority of all past Labour MPs have done.

    The problem is with the media for whom two brothers locked in deadly political rivalry sounds just like the plot of a Jeffrey Archer novel and thus injects a much needed element of ‘human interest’ into dull (but in fact literally life and death) policy arguments.

    And statements like the above reinforce this toxic narrative.

    The fact is that David M had a lot more invested in the New Labour project than Ed and for personal as well as political reasons cannot join the rump ultra-Blairite faction plotting  against his own brother – s0 it seems quite reasonable to me that he should spend as long as it takes to re-evaluate his position (in the wider ideological sense that you’d expect from someone called Miliband) before deciding whether to seek office again.

    A sudden Damascene conversion just after the leadership election and his taking the Shadow Chancellorship  (which became open in Jan 2011 when Alan Johnson resigned) would have done neither his nor the Labour Party’s credibility any good whatsoever.

    My own hope is that after completing his period of reflection he does come back next year and they send off Douglas Alexander to sort out the Scottish party so that David can return to the Foreign Office brief.

    But if he doesn’t I can see no reason why he can’t carry on as a loyal backbencher for as long as he wants to and the voters put up with him.

  • http://twitter.com/renieanjeh Renie Anjeh

    As I say, there is less than hald of a cigarette paper’s difference between Ed and David. I hope he returns to the fold soon, we need him. Two Milibands are better than one – both are brilliant.

Latest

  • News Put reckless bankers in jail – Media roundup: June 19th, 2013

    Put reckless bankers in jail – Media roundup: June 19th, 2013

    Subscribers to our morning email get the best of LabourList – including the Media and blog round up – every weekday morning. If you were a subscriber you would have already received this (and much more) in your inbox. You can sign up here. Put reckless bankers in jail Britain’s banking bosses should face jail if their decisions force fresh bailouts, the Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards says today. The commission’s hotly anticipated report urges the Chancellor, George Osborne, to oversee the [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Wise heads – 5 ex-ministers Miliband could put in the Shadow Cabinet

    Wise heads – 5 ex-ministers Miliband could put in the Shadow Cabinet

    Last week I highlighted 5 women from the 2010 intake who Ed Miliband could add to his Shadow Cabinet in the coming months. Today I’ve taken a look at five of the wise heads on the backbenches with experience of government who could add something to Miliband’s front bench team in opposition: Alistair Darling – the obvious candidate for a return to the Shadow Cabinet at some point, Alastair Darling managed the remarkable feat of overseeing a financial crisis, and [...]

    Read more →
  • Featured Unison Conference 2013 Why the government are keen to use trade unions as a scapegoat

    Why the government are keen to use trade unions as a scapegoat

    “Mike Bassett did a better job as bloody England manager than David Cameron has as Prime Minister” Ricky Tomlinson tells me as he pauses for photos with union members at UNISON’s annual conference in Liverpool. Ricky’s just delivered a powerful opening speech to 2,000 UNISON members packed into the Echo Arena. Just like the final scene of his film Mike Bassett: England Manager, Ricky leaves the stage with his clenched fists pumping the air as thunderous applause fills the room. [...]

    Read more →
  • News Unison Conference 2013 Unison set out their expectations for a Labour government

    Unison set out their expectations for a Labour government

    Unison General Secretary Dave Prentis set out his tests for continuing to support Labour this afternoon. Speaking at their conference in Liverpool, Prentis said: For too long we’ve built the careers of Labour politicians, only to be let down when we needed them most. I don’t want to hear Labour apologising for past mistakes, I want to see a clear agenda from Labour for the future. We must not support a Labour Government that does not : put an end [...]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Scotland Why on earth shouldn’t Nigel Farage visit Scotland?

    Why on earth shouldn’t Nigel Farage visit Scotland?

    You’ve got to admire Nigel Farage. Like a comedian who’s already died on stage at the Glasgow Empire, he’s put on his “optimistic” hat and chosen to return to Scotland to campaign for UKIP. His last visit, you will recall, was memorable for his being forced to seek refuge in an Edinburgh pub from a mob of nationalists and trots shouting “SCUM!” at him as he tried to convey his message (a tad harsh, I thought. But I suppose “gentleman [...]

    Read more →