Our high streets – and the “crack cocaine of gambling”

November 17, 2012 11:59 am

By Carl Packman and Matt Zarb-Cousin

Financial divisions in the UK are growing while the economy of Britain is in dire straits – and the Tory-led Coalition government seem increasingly unable to do anything about it.

Nowhere is this downturn more accurately reflected than in the state of our high streets up and down the country.

Two types of business, which can so often be a blight to our high streets, recongised by Mary Portas in her report for the government, are payday lenders and gambling shops.

Payday lending growth did not appear out of nowhere. For years many working people’s wages were essentially substituted by easy credit that is now, for better or for worse, not available.

Rising prices for our services and stangnant wages meant a dependency for many on borrowed money, sustained only by what researchers at the Personal Finance Research Centre at Bristol University called “the dramatic growth in the mainstream consumer credit market”.

Unsurprisingly the payday lending industry has grown by unprecedented levels. In 2004 it was worth approximately £100 million; today in 2012, conservative estimates put that figure at £2 billion.

These lenders make a fortune off the backs of vulnerable people who are unable to make it to the end of the month by their own means alone – and the government seem complacent in that.

But if the government are not willing to cooperate, it is time for people themselves to do all they can to stop the little shylocks of the high streets.

Lewisham Council has recently set a precedent by calling an end to “legal loan sharks”. The council recently passed a resolution pledging to promote credit unions in the borough, community based organisations that offer access to affordable credit and promote savings.

Councillor Mike Harris for Lewisham Council concluded that the next step now is for the government to give councillors the power to say no to more pay day loan shops in their area.

For it to be effective, this must be done in simultaneity with a national cap on the amount a lender can charge a borrower – to ensure against companies ripping off the most vulnerable.

With gambling, back in April, the Local Government Association published a report suggesting 57% of local councillors believed betting shops were hitting economic growth. The clustering of betting shops on our high streets can be attributed to the cap of four highly addictive FOBTs (fixed odds betting terminals) per shop, causing the pack-like bookies to leapfrog regulations by opening up as many shops as possible.

The effect on economic growth is two-fold. As Clyde Loakes, vice chair of the LGAs environment and housing board, said:

“The general public is less likely to shop on high streets with clustering, while businesses may be less willing to set up on roads with unsavoury clusters.”

On top of this, FOBTs – dubbed the “crack cocaine of gambling” – drain thousands of pounds out of struggling local economies each week. Coral made £945 per machine, per week in 2011, and this figure is forecasted to rise to £1000 by 2013.

They’re targeting our poorest areas, too. Research commissioned by the recent Dispatches programme “Britain’s High Street Gamble” found there were more than twice as many betting shops in areas of high unemployment than there are in areas of low unemployment.

To be clear, in exemplifying these two types of service, the authors of this piece are not naïve to the potentially sour reality of ridding them completely without credible contingency plans – and by no means call for bans.

However it cannot go unnoticed any longer that the toxic economy of betting shops, pawnbrokers and payday loan companies is deterring investment in our high streets and stifling economic growth.

This government is not serious about localism and about doing all it can to stop the destruction of our high streets against capitalism’s predators. But a Labour party, making good on its One Nation promise, can be the corrective our high streets need.

Giving councils more powers to combat the amount of payday lenders and gambling shops, by placing them into seperate use classes, would be a first step. Looking further at ways to stop people from becoming dependent on bad debt is a crucial driver that serious advocates of One Nation politics need to deliver on.

Carl Packman is the author of Loan Sharks: The Rise and Rise in Payday Lending. Matt Zarb-Cousin is a consultant at the Fairer Gambling Campaign. 

This piece forms part of Jon Cruddas’s Guest Edit of LabourList

  • DaveAtherton20

    You say “..local councillors believed betting shops were hitting economic growth.”

    Nothing to do with all the tin pot councils charging extortionate levels of parking meter fees, quasi police in the shape of parking wardens handing out £50 fines when you want a loaf of bread and a pint of milk? Woe betide anyone over staying their allotted time on a parking meter and incurring a £200 tow away fee. Nothing to do with the fact that people prefer to drive to shops and park for nothing or a low charge rather than walk, rather than carry 20lbs of shopping on the bus?

    Any other shop or business has a right to bid for the freehold or lease for the premises and it appears that the politburos of Lewisham et al have through their greed and incompetence have killed the high street stone dead. There does not seem to be a market for scented candles and obscure 3rd World art. Hate the car lose the shops.

    I see you have not mentioned the National Lottery. If you put £millions every day/week/month over enough time if your luck evens out you will lose 50% of your money. You really are better off putting your money of the “No Hope Government” horse in the 2.30 at Ascot.

    Betting shops offer people employment to people and whether they survive is up to attracting enough punters through the door, not some jumped up authoritarian from the council. Also how dare you look down your nose at a past time enjoyed by working class people.

    BTW plan B is while I am typing I am playing on line poker, I also have the choice of a bet on the nags too.

  • PaulHalsall

    We need a new usury law, and a way for people to claim back the excessive interest they have already paid (as per PPI).

  • http://twitter.com/Tech_Recipe Andrew Webb

    Excellent article. You are absolutely spot-on about gambling hitting economic growth.

    It does not take a brilliant mind to realize that if you have a groups of people addicted to something, such as drugs, you’ll have more crime, and gambling is no exception. With gambling people get into impossible situations: some opt for crime, others opt for bankruptcy. Others will steal from their family or employer while some even commit suicide. A percentage of people will use money they have no business in using, that could otherwise have gone into food, toys for their kids, or help the local economy in some way, and this is no small percentage.

    For councils to allow gambling outlets to prey on citizens is just plain wrong. The argument that betting shops and casinos help the local economy is pathetic. The money is basically a tax on the weak-minded and does not create any development at all – not if you mean new infrastructure, new technologies, helping small start-ups or training graduates, apprentices etc.

Latest

  • Featured 8 questions Iain Duncan-Smith must now answer

    8 questions Iain Duncan-Smith must now answer

    In November 2011 Iain Duncan Smith promised – one million people would be on Universal Credit by April 2014. Three years on fewer than 18,000 people are receiving Universal Credit. Despite over £600million being spent on the new benefit the programme is beset by chaos, waste and delays. This afternoon Iain Duncan Smith was forced to appear before the House of Commons to answer questions about this failing programme. But once again he refused to answer the simplest of questions about his […]

    Read more →
  • Comment They left us wanting more – Gordon Brown is only the latest big beast to depart

    They left us wanting more – Gordon Brown is only the latest big beast to depart

    “Always leave them wanting more.” It’s not entirely clear who said it first, but this has become one of the more popular, if rarely achieved, political clichés. Of all the recent political leaders we might have expected to stand aside with a clamour for more ringing in his ears, Gordon Brown would not have featured prominently in discussions. Brown’s Labour leadership culminated in the party’s second worst General Election performance in the post-war era. Although he opted to remain in […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Regional banks: a crucial ingredient to help small business

    Regional banks: a crucial ingredient to help small business

    On 19 November, I was at a meeting at the German Embassy with the head of the German Savings Banks Group, Sparkassen, Georg Fahrenschon. Herr Fahrenschon told us that local savings banks were the biggest single driver of economic resilience through the global financial crisis and in the recovery since. This was because of their support for small businesses, which are the backbone of the German economy. In the US, the economic recovery has been far stronger and more sustained […]

    Read more →
  • Comment To win back people’s trust, we need to be honest about what the limits of politics are

    To win back people’s trust, we need to be honest about what the limits of politics are

    With just over 6 months to go until the next General Election, one would expect there be to a lively debate across the political spectrum mapping the key battlegrounds of the election campaign over the coming months and presenting some of the major policy ideas of each party. Instead there appears to be a general mood of helplessness among both the Conservatives and Labour. Numerous commentators have highlighted a fundamental disconnect between the political class and the electorate; an insidious […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour will set up a national refuge fund

    Labour will set up a national refuge fund

    Today it’s International Day to Eliminate Violence Against Women. Yvette Cooper has marked this by announcing that Labour will set up a national refuge fund and is committed to continuing support for rape crisis centres. Cooper, writing in the Guardian, says that Labour will use the £3million they would save by abolishing police and crime commissioners to do this. This pledge is significant given that under the Coalition, cuts have meant that between 2010 and July 2014  the number of […]

    Read more →