The Arc of Underachievement: How to ensure no school is left behind

November 15, 2012 1:00 pm

One of the achievements I am most proud of is the way in which the gap between the richest and poorest pupils was narrowed by a Labour Government. Analysis carried out by the Financial Times showed that between 2006 and 2010 there was a “sustained improvement in the results of children from the poorest neighbourhoods”.

However, there are still too many pupils in too many schools who don’t achieve their full potential. Addressing this inequality is central to our fight for a One Nation education system.

I have termed this challenge the ‘Arc of Underachievement’.

This Arc of Underachievement runs through many of our seaside towns and coastal cities.  In places such as Clacton, Torbay and Morecambe, there are too many schools which are below the national average for GCSE results.

If you take Cornwall – the probability that a poor child will have GCSE results in the bottom quarter nationally increased by 8% between 2006 and 2010. Whereas in Southwark, the probability decreased by 7%.

There is also an Arc of Underachievement that includes a number of Northern towns and cities in England – including some schools in places such as Hull, Blackpool and Knowsley.

I know that by naming these places, it will produce a defensive reaction.

I am not for one minute saying that all schools or teachers in these areas are not up to scratch.

Some schools are improving, and there is much good practice, but as fighters for social justice, we must not fear to challenge the fact that poor pupils are not making the most of their potential.

As a Labour party, we must fight the idea that ‘you don’t know what we are working with – you can’t turn coal into diamond.’ If that was the case, why is that children in places like Jarrow defy the odds?

There are many beacons of excellence which we should celebrate – places like Bolton, Bury and Manchester in the North West, or Lambeth, Hackney and Tower Hamlets in London.

Michael Gove thinks the only way to improve a school is to make it an academy. Labour’s academy programme achieved great things, but changing a school’s governance structure is no guarantee of success. The most important factor is the quality of teaching and leadership – and that happens in schools of all types.

I think there are three ways in which we can tackle the Arc of Underachievement, to ensure that no school is left behind.

First, is to improve the quality of teaching. That means working with existing heads and teachers to provide better training and support. It also means expanding schemes like Teach First which brings in high flying graduates, and places them in schools in tougher neighbourhoods. I also want to examine the case for providing a rebate on teacher tuition fees if you agree to teach in a school in a poorer part of the country for a minimum of two years.

Second, it is about stronger schools supporting weaker schools. The London Challenge and the City Challenge set up under Labour helped achieve a startling turnaround in the fortunes of schools in the capital and in Manchester. Instead of pitting schools against each other, as Michael Gove would like, we encouraged better school collaboration, and built a sense of pride in the education service. I would extend these challenges to areas in the North and coastal towns that need additional support.

The third element is the wider children’s agenda and investing in the early years. This was a central priority of the last Labour Government, but the Tories are turning back the clock. There are 281 fewer Sure Start centres compared to 2010. Early Intervention budgets are facing a staggering cut of over 40% over the course of this parliament, as over £1.1billion is taken out of programmes to help troubled families, fund children’s centres and provide breaks for families with disabled children. As any parent or teacher will tell you, giving a child the best start in life starts well before primary school.

Ed Miliband set out a radical and progressive vision for Britain when he talked about One Nation Labour. One Nation Education will be fundamental to addressing the divided country we face today – and rebuilding our economy so it works for working people.

What is needed is a relentless drive on school improvement which is focussed on clear leadership, early intervention and effective collaboration. To ensure that no school is left behind.

Stephen Twigg MP is Labour’s Shadow Education Secretary

This piece forms part of Jon Cruddas’s Guest Edit of LabourList

  • http://twitter.com/edsajw Jack Whitehead

    I’ve enjoyed Stephen Twiggs’ rhetoric in ‘The Arc of Underachievement: how to ensure that no school is left behind’. In creating ‘One Nation’ such rhetoric may have to be complemented by the narratives of those of us who are committed to building ‘One Nation’, in which we share evidence-based explanations of our educational influences in our own learning, in the learning of others and in the learning of the social formations in which we live and work, as we seek to live the values of ‘One Nation’ as fully as possible. I’ve included my own narrative in the living theory web-site at http://www.actionresearch.net .

  • http://twitter.com/SolHughesWriter Solomon Hughes

    Perhaps schools could be improved by getting some kind of well funded, democratic local organisation to help them work together and improve. It could be a kind of authority for education, a sort of local one.

    • Dave Postles

      LEA LOL.

  • PaulHalsall

    Look, in any scheme that measures schools 50.1% will always be better than 49.9%. That is a matter of statistics which cannot be just dismissed.

    We need to support all schools to become better, but get rid of the obsessive New Labour, and now Tory, methods of ranking.

  • PaulHalsall

    Look, in any scheme that measures schools 50.1% will always be better than 49.9%. That is a matter of statistics which cannot be just dismissed.

    We need to support all schools to become better, but get rid of the obsessive New Labour, and now Tory, methods of ranking.

  • PaulHalsall

    Let me make this clearer.

    You can NEVER get a situation in which more than 50% or schools are above the national average.

    I really despair when I see figures like Stephen Twigg pushing this nonsense.

    Perhaps Portillo should have won in 1997.

    • Serbitar

      Based on what I’ve heard Portillo say since he left politics behind him I’m not sure that Ribena Boy isn’t somewhat to the left of Stephen Twigg, politically speaking, in many ways and about many things.

  • Dave Postles

    Gove is pushing on an open door – opened by Blair. There will be nothing left. We read of successful schools being closed to promote nearby academies. Could Blair not perceive the unintended consequences? It’s another fine mess into which Blair propelled us. You can make all the distinctions that you like about NL academies and Gove’s academies, but NL placed the door ajar.

    • Dave Postles

      Bung us two mill in a brown envelope and you can have a school and do what you like with it.

      • AlanGiles

        I won’t be too harsh on Twigg. After all following the June 10th BBC TV interview he gave on The Politics Show, where he was all over the place, contradicting himself we know he is an expert in underachievement.

  • Alexwilliamz

    Can Mr Twigg learn some basic lessons, obviously his use of percentages has already been highlighted, but what gets my goat is the belief that teaching will be improved by programmes like Teach First. Is there any actual evidence that students with the Firsts in their degree will make better teachers? The real target should be actual teacher training and then ongoing training. If you set the bar adequately enough during teacher training then you should be able to remove those people who are not going to cut it. This seems to me a far more sensible route than just assuming getting people with strong academic qualifications will automatically produce good teachers. The core skills for a teacher are not going to be evident from a degree classification, aside from the issue of subject knowledge, but even then the specialising at degree level does not garuntee a candidates has the competent subject knowledge of some lower level courses, one would hope they could quickly acquire this of course.

  • Alexwilliamz

    And of course no vision of what post primary education should be about other than achievement as measured through a narrow exam subject.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Homfray/510980099 Mike Homfray

    I agree with the thrust of what has been said so far. It’s far too simplistic to talk in terms of whole areas. Morecambe for example is greatly affected by significant patches if intensive poverty and transitory population and the continued existence if a popular boys grammar school in Lancadter

Latest

  • News Scotland Murphy makes unity candidate pitch as Unite prepare to endorse Findlay

    Murphy makes unity candidate pitch as Unite prepare to endorse Findlay

    There are two interviews with Scottish Labour leader candidates in this morning’s papers. Jim Murphy launches his campaign by talking to the Daily Record (the same paper Johann Lamont did her resignation interview with last week), while Neil Findlay has a short conversation with the Morning Star. Murphy builds on the statement he made last night (“I’m applying for the job of First Minister”) by claiming he wants “to bring the country back together after the referendum.” He said: “I […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Brand or bland? Are these really my choices?

    Brand or bland? Are these really my choices?

    Russell Brand has a book out and a great publicist. His diagnosis of our current malaise is pretty spot on. His solutions however are woolly headed at best and inconsistent at worst. But Russell Brand is being taken seriously. He’s never off Newsnight nor out of the pages of the Guardian. People are flocking to follow him in their thousands. He is Che Guevara for the scripted reality generation. The established left simply don’t know what to make of this. […]

    Read more →
  • Comment If politicians can’t enact the policies people actually want, the system is broken

    If politicians can’t enact the policies people actually want, the system is broken

    This week, Class released a new poll on the theme of fairness and inequality, which will nicely coincide with the debates at our conference this Saturday. Speaking of which, you should totally book a ticket for that as we’re down to the last few. Anyway, I find our polling particularly interesting (I mean, you’d hope I would) because its aim is to gauge public opinion on long-term issues, rather than responding to a given news story. Class polls provide a […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Scotland “I’m standing for First Minister of Scotland and I intend to win”: Jim Murphy joins Scottish Labour leadership race

    “I’m standing for First Minister of Scotland and I intend to win”: Jim Murphy joins Scottish Labour leadership race

    We now have three candidates for Scottish Labour leader, as Jim Murphy’s long-awaited candidacy has been confirmed. The Shadow International Development Secretary and former Scotland Secretary released a statement this evening, saying that his intention is to be Scottish Labour leader and First Minister: “I’m standing for First Minister of Scotland and I intend to win. I want to bring Scotland back together after the referendum. There is so much to be proud of in Scotland but so much we […]

    Read more →
  • Comment I’m not upset about Cameron’s refusal to wear a t-shirt – it’s everything else that gets me

    I’m not upset about Cameron’s refusal to wear a t-shirt – it’s everything else that gets me

    On Monday the news broke that David Cameron has repeatedly refused a request by Elle magazine to be photographed wearing a t-shirt. Why? Because on it, the t-shirt says “This is what a feminist looks like”. There have been a catalogue of ideas floated since about why he might not have done it – “It’s only a mag campaign” or “You shouldn’t dress up the Prime Minister”, say. But really, it’s not important that it was a request from a […]

    Read more →