Labour will be offering a “free vote” on gay marriage – but the whole shadow cabinet will vote in favour

11th December, 2012 10:13 am

There has been some confusion in recent hours about what Labour’s exact position will be when it comes to the vote on gay marriage. The original understanding amongst MPs was that the vote would be whipped, however it now appears that only applies to gay marriages of the civil ceremony variety. Labour MPs will be getting a free vote on gay marriages that include a religious element (i.e. those held in religious buildings). Blame for the confusion over Labour’s position is being laid at the door oft he government, whose own position on exactly what votes will be brought forward has, in the view of the party, been confused. A Labour source confirmed to us that:

“If the Bill includes religious provisions we will respect a free vote.”

That could allow a small but significant number of MPs who oppose gay marriage (or gay marriage held in religious buildings) to vote against the majority of the party without breaking the whip.

This decision is likely to anger those within the party who had hoped Labour would whip the vote.

However senior Labour figures are keen to stress that the entire shadow cabinet will be backing gay marriage – which may not necessarily be the case for the government – and that Labour’s support for equal marriage should not be considered in doubt, with well over 80% of Labour MPs expected to support it, even in a free vote.

To report anything from the comment section, please e-mail [email protected]
  • Redshift1

    To be honest when I first heard this I thought ‘ridiculous’ because I thought we were referring to the civil gay marriages.

    Frankly, given churches have all kinds of restrictions (including regular attendance) on who they let get married in house. I kind of feel that a) do I really as an atheist care if they want to make themselves look increasingly out-dated and anachronistic and b) actually forcing them do them will probably just lead to them finding another excuse not to wed the couple in the building.

    It is the lack of state gay marriage that is unacceptable – with serious implications therefore for the C of E as the state religion BUT for all others, I don’t really see why it matters. Doesn’t it just say to gay people, ‘look why follow that religion/denomination when they think you are inherently living in sin and have no respect for your love?’. Abandon the bigots, let them cast the rope that hangs them.

    • But religious gay marriage is not going to be forced on religions. It’s an optional thing that faith groups can opt into, and most won’t. There is absolutely nothing in the proposals that forces gay marriage in churches – in fact, by having an opt-in system, apparently it helps to protect those that don’t won’t to take part from being taken to court over it.

      • Redshift1

        That’s what I thought initially, but that isn’t what Mark is saying above.

  • Disappointed that it won’t be whipped, and I’m also disappointed that people keep pointing to the religious freedom element as if said freedom was ever at risk. It’s about choice, nobody’s being forced to do anything they don’t want to.

  • Hugh

    I’m slightly baffled that the government has any say whatsoever over whether religious institutions can marry people or not, to be honest – certainly outside the CofE.

    Once the government chooses to amend the civil law to permit same sex marriages, I had rather supposed churches could do what they wanted in any case. I’m not sure why what the quakers get up to within the framework of the civil law is any of the government’s business.

    • I think religious marriages are covered by different laws? Remember civil marriage is relatively modern, it all used to be done in a church originally.

      • PaulHalsall

        That changed in 1857

  • Labour is shooting itself in the foot here. ‘Issues of conscience’ is such a cop out; surely everything is an issue of conscience. If a whipped vote upsets a few oddballs then let them be upset. If they are shadow ministers then they are welcome to see themselves out. They won’t be missed.

  • metrolivia

    Cameron is supporting Gay Marriage in Church because he is after the ‘pink’ vote and for no other reason. I thought this was obvious as he has ostracized most other groups thus far. Labour should not sit on the fence with this one…we live in a democracy and we should be seen to be democratic. The option should be in place for Gay Marriage in a Church and for the individual church to make it’s own decisions..not unlike a landlord choosing who to serve!

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

  • And I think its fair to say that those who vote against won’t exactly do their standing in the party a lot of good

Latest

  • Europe Featured News Corbyn and Miliband team up to warn of dangers of Brexit on climate change

    Corbyn and Miliband team up to warn of dangers of Brexit on climate change

    Jeremy Corbyn and Ed Miliband will hit the campaign trail together today as they champion the leadership the EU has shown on tackling climate change – and warn that a vote to leave would put recent progress “at risk”. It is the first public appearance that former leader Miliband has made with his successor, and comes in a week in which rumours circulated that Corbyn was trying to coax him back into the Shadow Cabinet. During last year’s leadership contest, Corbyn praised Miliband’s […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Europe Featured Chuka Umunna: Don’t take the polls for granted – we must defeat every argument from the desperate Leave campaign

    Chuka Umunna: Don’t take the polls for granted – we must defeat every argument from the desperate Leave campaign

    “Take Control” – that is the slogan of the faltering Vote Leave campaign.  I say “faltering” because they are by no means beaten. Any Labour supporter lulled by the current polls into thinking the Remain camp is on course to win need only cast their minds back to 10pm on Thursday 7 May 2015 – then, after a string of polls suggesting we were on the cusp of winning the last general election, we suffered a body blow and found […]

    Read more →
  • Europe News Sadiq: A vote for Brexit would mean London turning its back on its history

    Sadiq: A vote for Brexit would mean London turning its back on its history

    Sadiq Khan has put forward a “patriotic” case for staying in the EU, arguing that London could swing the vote on June 23. In his first major intervention on the referendum since becoming London Mayor three weeks ago, Khan said the choice about whether to remain an EU member was about values, and that it is “quintessentially British” to want to co-operate internationally. In a speech earlier today, Khan said that an outward-looking, pro-EU stance was “the London way”, adding: “A […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News From the left wing? Momentum and McDonnell launch football initiative before Euro 2016

    From the left wing? Momentum and McDonnell launch football initiative before Euro 2016

    A new chapter is being written in the long history of sport and left-wing politics with the launch of Momentum Football. The Corbynista pressure group has teamed up with John McDonnell and Philosophy Football to launch a series of discussions in time for Euro 2016. Momentum aims to take advantage of the expected surge of coverage next month by holding its football first event on the day England play their opening match against former Cold War foes Russia in Marseilles. The […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Europe Featured Uncategorized Glenis Willmott: With four weeks to the vote it’s clear that Brexit would put at risk jobs, rights and security

    Glenis Willmott: With four weeks to the vote it’s clear that Brexit would put at risk jobs, rights and security

    In just four weeks’ time, voters go the polls in the EU referendum, and while there have been complaints that the campaigns have been too negative, Labour MEPs and the Labour Party will continue to make the positive case for our membership, day in day out, in workplaces, in communities and out on the doorstep, all the way to June 23. This vote isn’t about just maintaining the rights and jobs, influence and security that we have, but about a […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit