More Bombardier bungling from the shambolic Department for Transport

22nd December, 2012 12:24 pm

Few issues have demonstrated the Government’s stubborn resistance to logic, common sense and overwhelming evidence quite like the shambolic mishandling of the Thameslink contract.

It is a year-and-a-half since then-Transport Secretary Philip Hammond controversially picked German manufacturer Siemens ahead of Derby trainmaker Bombardier for the lucrative deal, instantly sending thousands of midlands workers into unemployment. Two ministers later and the deal still hasn’t been signed, but current incumbent Patrick McLoughlin, just like Justine Greening before him, seems equally as blind to the abundance of evidence that the department got it wrong.

In Derby, we have felt an incredibly traumatic rollercoaster of emotions.   At first, it was anger at the Government’s apparent belligerence and ignorance in taking no account whatsoever of the devastating economic impact of sending the £1.4bn contract overseas. That was swiftly followed by disappointment and bemusement when it became clear ministers had no intention of budging, despite a 50,000-plus name petition and 10,000 people taking to the streets in protest. The months that have followed have featured repeated bouts of hope followed by frustration as each new piece of evidence that is unearthed is either dismissed or ignored by the Government.

And now we’re back to anger again – as it becomes increasingly obvious that the Government’s resolve to see this one through is nothing to do with sense or necessity but everything to do with a bloody-minded determination not to buckle, however compelling the case that they ought to.

It is like a scene from Fawlty Towers in which Basil keeps digging, digging and digging some more until he has no choice but to meet an inevitable calamitous conclusion.  The big difference is that Mr McLoughlin’s failings, like those of Ms Greening and Mr Hammond before him, simply aren’t funny.

The latest evidence to come to light, and to be roundly ignored by the Government, is the somewhat fundamental concern that the Thameslink trains simply aren’t going to be compatible for wide swathes of British tracks – and that Siemens has no existing ability to rectify that. By contrast, Bombardier not only boasts a compatible model already, but had it been made preferred bidder instead of Siemens, it would have been able to begin production immediately. And ability to act immediately is another major concern with Siemens right now.

It might have escaped Mr McLoughlin’s attention, but it hasn’t escaped the notice of the German media that Siemens has suffered significant delays in providing for another contract it won; this time for Deutsche Bahn, the national rail company in Germany.  The mixed-product manufacturer has blamed system failures but is reported in some of Germany’s largest selling national newspapers to simply be over-stretched. This is all on top of the many concerns that have been raised over the original procurement process, with even the Transport Select Committee hearing strong evidence that Siemens was handed an unfair advantage over Bombardier.

And, let’s be honest, the farce over the suspended West Coast Mainline contract hardly fills you with confidence that the Department for Transport is quite as au fait with these dealings as one might expect. Then there is the fact that the Government has significantly moved the goalposts since it originally contracted for Thameslink.  It is now anticipated that a “super-franchise” will be created, also involving some of the Southern and South Eastern services.

This is significant because even if the Government doesn’t want to admit it got it wrong the first time round, herein lay a wonderful opportunity for ministers to revisit the original decision without necessarily losing face.  It was an opportunity they missed and, sadly, I am increasingly led to believe it is because they simply don’t have the bottle.

I hope I am wrong.  Financial close has not yet been reached on the Thameslink deal, although it is perilously close.  In response to a debate this issue on Thursday, Transport Minister, Simon Burns, said they would complete the deal early in the New Year.

But there is still time for Mr McLoughlin to do the decent thing and ask his department to revisit the original decision in light of the wealth of evidence that has become apparent since then.  I would hope that even if his ministerial duty to make the right choice for the country doesn’t persuade him to do that, then his loyalty to the Derbyshire public who elected him might.

If that doesn’t happen, then Mr McLoughlin and his Government will just have to cross their fingers that the vast majority of us who can see what they can’t have got it wrong. For if we haven’t, I can assure them that all 50,000 of us who signed that petition will be watching the delivery of that contract like a hawk and will be quick to remind them of the dozens of warnings they failed to heed before awarding it.

Chris Williamson is the Labour MP for Derby North

  • jaime taurosangastre candelas

    The terms for the competition were set in 2008, including a need for a long term financing over 30 years. Given the different interest rates at which various bidders could seek long term finance, it is only a matter of simple mathematics that the Siemens bid was cheaper. See: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/transport/8621498/Bombardier-had-little-chance-on-Thameslink-because-of-contract-terms.html . Perhaps, being unused to real world numbers and how the economy functions, the last Labour Government “did not realise” in some child-like fashion the likely effect of their setting of the rules?

    If you do not like the fact that a German company won and that local workshare was not “weighted” in the considerations of the bids or costs, perhaps you should address this worry to the Secretary of State for Transport and indeed the Prime Minister in 2008? Instead of whining about the current Ministers who inherited a process mostly complete, and declaring it to be their fault.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001102865655 John Ruddy

      Perhaps the minister who awared the contract on the basis of cheaper finance, then announced a scheme to provide government support to assist financing of the deal should carry some responsibility?

      There is nothing inherantly wrong in setting up a deal which will provide a guarantee of the train service (which is the type of deal we are talking about) – and its hardly the Labour Government’s fault that Bombardier couldnt provide finance cheaply enough, is it?

      What next from you Jaime? Labour to blame for apocolypse not happening?

Latest

  • News Scottish Labour leadership candidate calls for replacing the House of Lords with an elected second chamber based in Glasgow

    Scottish Labour leadership candidate calls for replacing the House of Lords with an elected second chamber based in Glasgow

    Kezia Dugdale has called for the abolishing the House of Lords and replacing it with an elected second chamber. Dugdale is running against Ken Macintosh to be Scottish Labour leader. In an article for the Guardian, she has said should would like “shake up the UK” by replacing House of Lords with an elected second chamber, which she would campaign to have based in Glasgow. She argues that “people are looking for signs that politicians get it” and that this means  institutions […]

    Read more →
  • News Andy Burnham: I’ll commission an urgent review into legal aid and scrap employment tribunal fees

    Andy Burnham: I’ll commission an urgent review into legal aid and scrap employment tribunal fees

    Andy Burnham will commit to reverse the declining access to legal advice for the low paid by reviewing legal aid and scrapping employment tribunal fees. The leadership contender make this announcement this week as he unveils what his team are calling “a highly personal” manifesto. This comes as figures show legal aid payments for people in debt, on benefits benefits or with employment and housing concerns fell to 10% before the Conservatives’ budget. They also showed ministers cuts £500 million from the legal aid budget […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Kendall sets out plans to deal with the five big issues Labour must prioritise

    Kendall sets out plans to deal with the five big issues Labour must prioritise

    Leadership hopeful Liz Kendall has today outlined five causes that she believes Labour must prioritise to build a fairer country. But in an article in today’s Independent, she says that the party first needs to win back the public’s trust: “Unless we can restore that, we won’t deliver on the causes we believe in.” The Leicester West MP argues that “Jeremy Corbyn doesn’t have a monopoly on hope” as she lays out five broad areas where she wants to see […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Staying together for the kids

    Staying together for the kids

    Can a political party attend relationship counselling? Never mind the big tent: how big would the couch have to be? Or is the Labour party now displaying signs of having irreconcilable differences? Is it time to cut the ties, and the losses, call it a day and move on? The abuse currently being hurled in several directions hardly points to a sense of common purpose, solidarity or collective action. The anger on social media is quite something. Dip any digit […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Having the ambition to put ending child poverty at the heart of leadership is why I’m backing Yvette

    Having the ambition to put ending child poverty at the heart of leadership is why I’m backing Yvette

    Leading the Labour Party is a big job, and it’s a serious job – that’s why we need a leader who brings strength and a track record to the role. Nobody doubts Yvette’s toughness or her experience, but what’s really important to me is the way she’s drawing on that experience to set out her stall for the future of our country and our party, and how that reflects her values. Yvette’s achievements in government, and as shadow home secretary, […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit