PMQs verdict: David Cameron kills off the Big Society

19th December, 2012 1:40 pm

Well that wasn’t quite the pre-Christmas knockabout PMQs we were all expecting. In fact, it was largely on the sober side, perhaps as a by-product of Ed Miliband leading off with questions on Afghanistan.

The mood was hardly lightened or the pace quickened by his second topic – food banks. It’s a scandal that one of the richest nations on earth in 2012 cannot adequately feed its people. The growth of food banks under this government should be a source of constant shame for the Prime Minister, but the fact that they exist at all should shame our society, and politicians from all parties.

But what was noteworthy in an otherwise sedate PMQs was just how badly Cameron handled the food banks issue. He could have swatted it away, and that would have been callous, but at least intellectually coherent. He could have expressed his sorrow, and that would have been contrite but meaningless. But instead he chose to link the Big Society to the provision of food banks.

That’s what the Big Society is these days, feeding starving children when the rest of society has failed. Or as Ed Miliband put it:

“I never thought that the big society was about feeding hungry children in Britain”

If the Big Society was hobbled before, it is surely stone cold dead now. If it were seen as a cover for cuts before, it’s seen as the back up plan when the safety net is cut now. The Big Society is dead, and David Cameron has killed it. The journey from Steve Hilton to Lynton Crosby is complete.

And so brazen is the PM nowadays, that he didn’t even bother to deny that he’d been socialising with Rebekah Brooks recently. The lines at the food banks may be getting longer, but friends in Chipping Norton are staying as close as ever.

Merry Christmas Britain. It’s cold outside.

  • http://www.facebook.com/stephen.kelly.904750 Stephen Kelly

    Good article – for once Mark

  • Monkey_Bach

    Cameron is a classic bully at once boorish, disdainful, mawkish, and sentimental. He applauds men and women who, out of the goodness of their hearts, donate time or money or food to such good causes, while simultaneously pouring vitriol on the heads of legions of poverty struck, suffering individuals and families that these good causes serve.

    What a despicable heartless charlatan.

    Eeek.

  • Gabrielle

    That was a real ‘WTF’ moment when Cameron came out with his pious pronouncement about the so-called Big Society running food banks. Nothing highlights the failure of this government’s policies than food banks. These are springing up everywhere, even in supposedly affluent areas, and it’s both employed and unemployed people and their children who are having to rely on them.

    Ed really nailed it when he responded with “I never thought that the big society was about feeding hungry children in Britain.”

    Well said, Ed.

    It’s also worth noting that this time last year, all the political pundits were saying Ed was hopeless and probably washed up, after Cameron made a cheap and nasty jibe about he and Clegg not being brothers (ie a dig at Ed’s supposed rivalry with his brother). This snide jibe was hyped up by Newsnight, Nick Robinson and many other hacks as the most devastating witticism in the history of PMQs and Ed was duly written off. Bit premature wasn’t it?

  • markfergusonuk

    Thanks for your faint praise

Latest

  • Video When Ed Miliband met a hen party

    When Ed Miliband met a hen party

    Ed Miliband was in the North West yesterday. This is what happened when he got to Chester, and his battlebus bumped into a hen party: Selfie! Selfie! Selfie!

    Read more →
  • News Scotland Tom McCabe, former Scottish Labour MSP, has died

    Tom McCabe, former Scottish Labour MSP, has died

    Tom McCabe has died aged 60 after a short illness. McCabe was the first MSP to ever be elected; his victory in Hamilton and South was announced just 75 minutes after the polls closed. He won by around 7,000 votes and represented the constituency from 1999 until 2011. During this time he was also the minister for parliamentary business for two years (1999-2001), deputy minister for health and community care (in 2003) ,and minister for finance and public service reform […]

    Read more →
  • News Tory housing minister warned about risks of right-to-buy plan

    Tory housing minister warned about risks of right-to-buy plan

    At their manifesto launch the Tories unveiled their right-to-buy proposals and they haven’t been met with much enthusiasm. Even the public don’t think they’re a very good idea. It seems there’s not even agreement on this contentious policy among the Tories. The plans the Tories are proposing would extend the right-to-buy policy to housing associations tenants. Cameron also said that councils would be have to sell off their most valuable remaining properties – the money from this he argued would be […]

    Read more →
  • News Video Cameron suggests rise in food bank use is down to better advertising

    Cameron suggests rise in food bank use is down to better advertising

    After George Osborne’s difficult Marr interview last week (where he failed to answer the same question 18 times) it was David Cameron’s turn on the Marr sofa today. He claimed that the Tories are running “the most positive campaign” before proceeding to attack Labour (and the SNP) every chance he got. But the most telling moment was when Cameron was asked about food banks: Here’s the chart from The Independent that should shame the Prime Minister and his government:

    Read more →
  • News “I want to reach out to Tory voters” – Miliband says he’s still set on winning a majority

    “I want to reach out to Tory voters” – Miliband says he’s still set on winning a majority

    With the general election so close, Ed Miliband has said that he wants to reach out to Tory voters. In an interview with the Observer, Miliband said: “I am a politician of the left, but I am positioned where the mainstream of politics is positioned. I am on the centre ground of politics.” In contrast he says Cameron is “ideologically beached”. The Labour leader built upon this argument explaining how his ‘centre-ground’ position could appeal to voters from across the […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit