We are a nation of immigrants. Aren’t we?

December 18, 2012 3:45 pm

I recall as a twelve year old growing up in the ‘Motor City’ that was Coventry and interpreting for my English school teacher who had started arranging English classes at the local Sikh Temple (Gurdawara). Twice a week in the evenings he volunteered (with me) to teach basic English as a second language to members of the local, relatively newly arrived congregation. This was at a time when no provisions had been made by employers, National or Local Government to teach English and hence improve engagement and dialogue between new arrivals and hosts. Many argued that the British State and employers only wanted the cheap labour of immigrants and did not address the issues arising out of settlement.

My father picked up rudimentary English from his colleagues on building sites where he worked as a carpenter and my mother learnt enough English to get on a bus, buy some groceries and say ‘hello and thank you’. How they would have loved an opportunity to learn the English language and therefore engage with employers who exploited them, have meaningful conversations with my teachers at parents teachers evenings and challenge the racists who abused them (P*** bashing was at it’s virulent worst – it was time when it was fashionable for white gangs to seek out and attack people of colour).

Forty year on, Ed Miliband has suggested that the ability to speak English improves engagement, interaction and therefore integration – seems logical to me. However, the dangerous inference is that immigrants choose to or not learn English, though many who arrived in the 60’s and 70’s from the ex-colonies included people from the Caribbean for whom English was their first language and were Christian like the host nation.

The issue of fluency in the English language is no longer on the same scale as it was for the pioneering immigrants of the 60’s and 70’s, most have now passed away or retired to the Indian Subcontinent. Today we have the fourth or fifth generation of children of immigrants from the Indian Sub continent and East Africa. For this generation not only do they speak English fluently but think and dream in English.

Proficiency in English is now relevant for immigrants from Eastern Europe. Again, history repeats itself as Coalition Government behaviour has led to the chronic underfunding of English-language teaching.

With the onslaught of Government policy on privatisation of public services, there are some private contractors who wilfully exploit workers’ lack of English skills, from migrants working in the agricultural sector packing food for supermarkets in East Anglia to cleaners in Westminster or GMB members cleaning and providing catering at Swindon General Hospital.

English language provision in isolation is not enough. Any debate or policy on immigration has to be holistic that addresses issues around housing, health care, education provision and fundamentally strengthening workplace rights with stronger sanctions against employers who wilfully abuse, exploit and in many cases degrade migrants. Yet the Coalition Government is hurtling in the opposite direction with proposals to reduce employment rights, reduce English language provision and it is not surprising that some new migrants are marginalised and a long way away from integrating into the mainstream of Britain.

The influx of migrants has seen a growth in xenophobic attitudes towards people coming into the UK to find work, particularly from Eastern Europe. In areas of Britain with higher rates of unemployment there has been growing resentment.

The last 70 or 80 years we have experienced migration from Europe and the rest of the world. For example Jewish people finding sanctuary from the Nazis, Irish people responsible for building our great railways and canals as well as people from the Commonwealth staffing our hospitals and transport systems. We forget at our peril that we are a nation of immigrants. Or should it be ‘One Nation’ of immigrants?

  • Amber_Star

    People should be required to learn English before they come to the UK, if they are coming here seeking work. Politically, we cannot add English lessons to the list of special support which new migrants will be perceived as receiving at the expense of people who are already residents/ citizens of the UK.
    Public funds need to be spend on helping people who are already here. Unemployment & lack of opportunity blights the lives of too many young & female ethnic minority citizens.

  • Amber_Star

    People should be required to learn English before they come to the UK, if they are coming here seeking work. Politically, we cannot add English lessons to the list of special support which new migrants will be perceived as receiving at the expense of people who are already residents/ citizens of the UK.
    Public funds need to be spend on helping people who are already here. Unemployment & lack of opportunity blights the lives of too many young & female ethnic minority citizens.

    • evad666

      Unemployment & lack of opportunity blights the lives of too many young & female (white and) ethnic minority citizens.

  • Amber_Star

    People should be required to learn English before they come to the UK, if they are coming here seeking work. Politically, we cannot add English lessons to the list of special support which new migrants will be perceived as receiving at the expense of people who are already residents/ citizens of the UK.
    Public funds need to be spend on helping people who are already here. Unemployment & lack of opportunity blights the lives of too many young & female ethnic minority citizens.

  • NT86

    Alongside the requirement to learn English, which needs to be supported by proper public funding, I’m afraid that UKIP’s idea for a responsible and controlled immigration policy is more important than ever. This is a tiny island that has only limited capacity and resources to sustain a population.

  • NT86

    Alongside the requirement to learn English, which needs to be supported by proper public funding, I’m afraid that UKIP’s idea for a responsible and controlled immigration policy is more important than ever. This is a tiny island that has only limited capacity and resources to sustain a population.

  • NT86

    Alongside the requirement to learn English, which needs to be supported by proper public funding, I’m afraid that UKIP’s idea for a responsible and controlled immigration policy is more important than ever. This is a tiny island that has only limited capacity and resources to sustain a population.

  • JoeDM

    The real issue is one of integration.

    The various groups of immigrants down the ages have integrated into our society, becoming part and parcel of British social culture. Where multiculturalism has failed is that it has given some immigrant communities the idea that they do not have to integrate, that they can have their own ghettos with their own separate development.

    Integration into the normal British way of life is the key. Allowing separate development is the path to a future disaster.

    After all the fuss about Polish immigration, where is the problem? I live in an East Anglian town with a big Polish community, but as far as I can see they have learned English, work very hard, contribute to our local clubs, pubs and societies etc. Our local jazz club jam nights has benefited from a couple of very good sax players who drive taxis during the day. This is the way it should be. Not failed multiculturalism.

  • JoeDM

    The real issue is one of integration.

    The various groups of immigrants down the ages have integrated into our society, becoming part and parcel of British social culture. Where multiculturalism has failed is that it has given some immigrant communities the idea that they do not have to integrate, that they can have their own ghettos with their own separate development.

    Integration into the normal British way of life is the key. Allowing separate development is the path to a future disaster.

    After all the fuss about Polish immigration, where is the problem? I live in an East Anglian town with a big Polish community, but as far as I can see they have learned English, work very hard, contribute to our local clubs, pubs and societies etc. Our local jazz club jam nights has benefited from a couple of very good sax players who drive taxis during the day. This is the way it should be. Not failed multiculturalism.

  • JoeDM

    The real issue is one of integration.

    The various groups of immigrants down the ages have integrated into our society, becoming part and parcel of British social culture. Where multiculturalism has failed is that it has given some immigrant communities the idea that they do not have to integrate, that they can have their own ghettos with their own separate development.

    Integration into the normal British way of life is the key. Allowing separate development is the path to a future disaster.

    After all the fuss about Polish immigration, where is the problem? I live in an East Anglian town with a big Polish community, but as far as I can see they have learned English, work very hard, contribute to our local clubs, pubs and societies etc. Our local jazz club jam nights has benefited from a couple of very good sax players who drive taxis during the day. This is the way it should be. Not failed multiculturalism.

  • MrSauce

    Yes we are.
    Was it Churchill who described Britain as a ‘mongrel nation’?
    Long may it continue.

Latest

  • Comment Time to pay school support staff their due

    Time to pay school support staff their due

    The debate about schools, pupil attainment and changes to our education system rages on. Yet there is one group of workers who are rarely discussed or heard in the debate, despite playing a fundamental role in almost every aspect of school life – school support staff. UNISON has almost been a lone voice in championing this overlooked group. School support staff help children learn, keep them safe and healthy and ensure schools run smoothly. They help provide the holistic attention […]

    Read more →
  • Europe News Cooper says Cameron’s migration target is “in tatters” – and Tory backbenchers agree

    Cooper says Cameron’s migration target is “in tatters” – and Tory backbenchers agree

    Yvette Cooper has slammed David Cameron’s major speech on EU immigration, saying that he has spent weeks of “posturing, pandering and making more promises he can’t keep” in order to placate his backbenchers, rather than coming up with practical solutions. Cameron said that he wanted to extend the period that EU migrants would have to wait before claiming benefits from three months to four years – double the two years Labour announced last week. But Shadow Home Secretary Cooper said […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Scotland Labour will implement Smith Commission proposals in first Queen’s Speech, pledges Miliband

    Labour will implement Smith Commission proposals in first Queen’s Speech, pledges Miliband

    Ed Miliband today said that the vow he made to radically devolve powers to Holyrood during the referendum campaign had been ‘signed, sealed and delivered’ by the publication of the Smith Commission’s report yesterday. He told an audience in Glasgow this morning that Labour would fully implement the proposals set out by the report in the first Queen’s Speech if elected next year. You can read Mark Ferguson’s take on the Smith Commission’s report here. Miliband said: “A vow was […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Diane Abbott expected to announce she will run to be London Mayor

    Diane Abbott expected to announce she will run to be London Mayor

    It’s rumoured that tomorrow at London Labour party conference Diane Abbott, the MP for Hackney and Stoke Newington, will announce that she will run to be Labour’s candidate for Mayor of London. Abbott  was Shadow Minister for Public Health until last year and has been the Labour MP for the north east London constituency for twenty seven years – where she doubled her majority in 2010. Prior to becoming an MP she was elected to Westminster City Council in 1982. […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Government is broken – Labour need to use the digital revolution

    Government is broken – Labour need to use the digital revolution

    People are shut out of government and they know it. Government is broken. The British state is not fit for purpose. They both need a radical re-design. I’ve been running Labour’s policy review and we asked two fundamental questions. What do we want government to do? And what role can digital technology play in creating a government that will better serve our country? The answers were pretty simple. We need a new way of governing our country that gives British […]

    Read more →