Britain is broken. But it is the system that is broken, not the people

16th January, 2013 9:15 am

Politics is about struggle, about the clash of interests.  It is, ultimately, about how to create a society of common interests.

So let’s take a contemporary example – “One Nation”.  I applaud Ed Miliband for the way he has raised this idea and for the content he is trying to give it. But let’s not pretend that we are “one nation”, or that we will become one without the conflict that Ralph Miliband placed at the heart of politics.

We cannot create common interests across a society that is now more unequal than for generations simply by wishing for it. So how do we get to “one nation” and what part does working-class politics play?

The labour movement has been the backbone to political change and progress for generations; if the 20th century was the century of the working class, it was so because of organised labour and the trade union movement, itself a child of conflict (over who benefits from the wealth generated by capitalism). That is why the ruling class is so keen to keep trade unions in legal shackles.

Britain was the first country of trade unionism – a point reflected in Danny Boyle’s inspirational opening ceremony at the Olympics. If we measure the success of the labour movement as the extent to which it re-shaped the responsibilities of government, the 20th Century saw victories on an unimaginable scale.

It is a remarkable feat that, at a time when wealth was accumulated at the top and poverty for working people who lived ‘hand to mouth’, the labour movement was able to secure such radical change. The working classes, against all odds, transformed society.  If you were to have a Monty Python moment and say “what has the trade union movement ever done for us” some would of course talk about better pay and improved conditions at work. I would go much further, and say that the political activity of the working class secured almost everything we value today: democracy, peace, equality, our welfare state.

The idea that capitalism or the ruling elite would have introduced democracy or social equality or welfare on their own is fanciful. Much of these achievements are under pressure today.

I grew up in vibrant and politicised communities – life was centred on the docks.   Around work were formed the circles of working-class life – trade unionism, community, the Labour Party. Today, we cannot simply start from there. We cannot build a future working-class politics on a basis which has long eroded.

Perhaps the more significant change is the decline in secure and stable employment. Capitalism is the only system which has normalised unemployment. It is the responsibility of any system to offer work to people, and if it fails in this basic obligation, don’t blame the victims. In the last two weeks 11,000 jobs have been lost – HMV, Jessops, Honda to name a few. Today’s hard working poor – victims – are tomorrow’s benefit scroungers, if you listen to the right wing press.

We must first confront the crisis of confidence born of increasing marginalisation, to say that we speak for the working class, that the working class speaks for a better world for all – and we have to organise and fight on that basis.

Unite is leading the way with an ambitious new programme to recruit, organise and educate across the whole of our communities. The unemployed, the disabled, carers, the elderly, the voluntary and charity sector – it is time for these people to be organised and to be given a voice. Who better to do this than the trade union movement?. This sits comfortably within our traditions. Unite’s community membership scheme means that those not in work – aged 16 to 116 – can join our family for 50 pence a week. Community branches are springing up across the country, and our activists are going into communities, empowering people to do something for themselves.

Unite is also working to meet the needs of our members through the creation of a new credit union network. My union says pay day loan vultures have no place in our society, profiting off the misery of people on poverty pay. So our members will be able to obtain credit without having to resort to the ruinous interest rates of the pay-day loan companies.

The 21st Century is not ringing out the death knell of the labour movement; it is sending out a call to arms.  The apparently endless economic crisis which began in 2008 is seeing to that. In 1992 Margaret Thatcher claimed ‘It is the end of Socialism.’ A few years later Tony Blair declared ‘that the Class war is over’.  No doubt from the boardroom of JP Morgan or wherever he is now, it may look that way.

But this is false evidence that we have nothing left to fight for.

We are told that strike action, civil disobedience, direct action and protest are all somehow unpatriotic. Our history tells us they are not. Our `rulers’ are deeply afraid of Ralph Miliband’s assertion that politics is about conflict. They believe that those without hope, without jobs, now looking at cuts in their meagre welfare, that families being shunted out of London because of housing benefit changes should simply put up with it. Council leaders from our major cities have warned that people might respond with anger and civil disorder.  I would not be surprised.  We have seen remarkable local protests recently: from 20,000 in Eastbourne and 15,000 on the streets in Lewisham to defend their NHS to 350 people crammed into a room to protest against a library closure in Newcastle.

Protest against inequality is alive and well – look at the work done by UK Uncut to challenge outrageous tax avoidance by Vodafone and other giant corporations. It takes courage to risk unpopularity and vilification. But the truth does prevail.

The labour movement’s message must be one of ‘hope’. Britain is broken. But it is the system that is broken, not the people.

I am proud to associate Unite with these initiatives, and to hope to form a longer-lasting alliance between organised labour and radical protest, even if it comes from outside our traditional movement. And, as I have made clear before in relation to the trade union laws, while I do not ever advocate violence, nor do I preach worship of the law at all costs. So my message to capitalism is this:  mend your ways or risk mounting social breakdown and disorder.

People need a political voice.  Labour is the natural, historic, vehicle for their voice. But should there be any return to the discredited recipes of Blairism, the Labour Party will be over for me and I believe millions more besides.

In the midst of an unending economic crisis, with what Ralph Miliband would have called a discredited ruling class at the helm, it is time for the working class to step forward with its own vision and alternative.

Our values are eternal. Let’s stand courageous, and triumph like those that have gone before.

Len McCluskey is the General Secretary of Unite

  • dave stone

    Well said,Len – nail on the head, as usual.

    Unite’s community to membership scheme meaning that “those not in work – aged 16 to 116 – can join our family” is an excellent forward-thinking initiative. I’d urge everyone who wants to get stuck into meaningful political and trade union activity to join:

    • AlanGiles

      I agree. Len is one of the very few LL writers who has had the courage to point out that we are not “one nation” and given very good reasons to explain why.

      I think that if Labour continues to make this subtle distinction between “strivers” who are in work and struggling and people who are not working being somehow less value will rebound on them. I made the point yesterday that as I no longer do (paid) work I am not a striver. Makes you feel a bit of a second class citizen in Labour eyes, and I worked all my life – just imagine how those sort of slights must come over to somebody be they 18 or 40 or 50, who, through no fault of their own, just cannot get a job – especially when in some areas you have 50 people chasing one vacancy.

  • JoblessDave

    I am nervous about the rhetoric the author employs, and strongly question the democratic legitimacy of his approach.

    Q “So how do we get to “one nation” and what part does working-class politics play?”

    A It has no part to play, any more than asking “what part does landed gentry politics play?”: the idea of any one small group creating a “society of common interests”, which is then to apply to the majority is not democracy. I agree that all voices must be heard, but believe that to divisionalise the discussion is to miss the point of “one nation” ideals.

    “We are told that strike action, civil disobedience, direct action and protest are all somehow unpatriotic.”

    Not unpatriotic, but profoundly undemocractic: akin to saying “if we don’t agree with the will of the country we’ll stop it doing what it said it would do” and this is commonly-held to be a reason why politics shifted so far and so fast to the right in the late 70’s and 80’s: British people will typically sympathise with the under-dog, but they don’t like being bullied by a vocal minority.

    The author also repeatedly raises the spectre of Ralph Miliband as, undoubtedly, a name check siren call, without actually making clear the hard extent of the Marxist principles he is appealing to, which have been at the fringe far-edge of British politics for almost a century. I worry that such an approach boarders on the intellectually-dishonest, by appealing emotionally to people without making the consequences fully apparent.

    All that said, I applaud the author for having his convictions: I believe as a broad church Labour can listen with respect to these views, however quite frankly I see no place from them in directly influencing modern Labour party policy.

  • Chilbaldi

    “So my message to capitalism is this: mend your ways or risk mounting social breakdown and disorder”
    with all due respect, this is the sort of language that alienates 99% of the country.

  • JoeDM

    The voice of Old Labour, a rare sound these days.


  • Comment Featured Unions A fair sharing economy?

    A fair sharing economy?

    Despite the clunky delivery, it is good to see Labour talking about what challenges we will face as the world of work changes dramatically. For many people that change is pretty daunting: it isn’t just accelerating, it’s spinning off in new directions. The digital revolution is connecting people in ways we could never have imagined five years ago. There are robots seemingly waiting to take just about every manual job and algorithms eyeing up a lot of the white collar middle management […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Full text of Jeremy Corbyn’s email to Labour Party members about Syria

    Full text of Jeremy Corbyn’s email to Labour Party members about Syria

    On Thursday David Cameron set out his case in the House of Commons for a UK bombing campaign in Syria. We have all been horrified by the despicable attacks in Paris and are determined to see ISIS defeated. The issue now is whether what the Prime Minister is proposing strengthens, or undermines, our national security. I put a series of questions in response to the Prime Minister’s statement, raising concerns about his case that are on the minds of many […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Uncategorized Corbyn turns to Labour Party members in Syria dispute

    Corbyn turns to Labour Party members in Syria dispute

    Jeremy Corbyn has emailed Labour Party members to ask their views on military action against Isis in Syria, as it has appears increasingly likely that the Shadow Cabinet will grant Labour MPs a free vote on the issue. In the email, the Labour Leader says that he does not “believe that the Prime Minister made a convincing case [on Thursday] that British airstrikes on Syria would strength our national security or reduce the threat from Isis.” “When I was elected […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Tom Watson backs airstrikes against Isil and says he has a mandate as Deputy Leader

    Tom Watson backs airstrikes against Isil and says he has a mandate as Deputy Leader

    Tom Watson backed airstrikes against Isil in Syria today, putting himself at odds with Jeremy Corbyn. Watson said he agrees with the Shadow Foreign Secretary, Hilary Benn, that “there is an imminent terrorist threat being directed from Syria” that requires a military response. And he insisted in a BBC interview that he would not resign from the Shadow Cabinet if Labour MPs were denied a free vote on the issue, as he is “the Deputy Leader of the Labour Party […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Unions Corbyn says “welcome home” as firefighters’ union reaffiliates to Labour

    Corbyn says “welcome home” as firefighters’ union reaffiliates to Labour

    The Fire Brigades Union have today voted to affiliate to the Labour Party – 11 years after breaking off ties. The decision was made at a special conference in Blackpool. The news that the union, which has 38,000 members, wants to rebuild links to Labour has been welcomed by Jeremy Corbyn who said the move “marks a milestone in the building of our new politics and our labour movement.” The FBU’s general secretary Matt Wrack, who is considered a left […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends