London now below “doomsday scenario” number of police officers

January 9, 2013 11:55 am

The following exchange took place at the Home Affairs Select Committee in September 2012:

Mark Reckless: What is the lowest numbers of officers you expect there to be in 2015?

Stephen Greenhalgh: The worst case, the doomsday scenario is at or around 31,000.

According to the latest figures (for November, just two months after Greenhalgh’s appearance at the Commons) the number of police officers in London is 30,939.

In May 2010 there were 33,147 (a difference of 2,208).

Boris Johnson pledged an extra 2,000 police officers at the last Mayoral electionanother broken promise.

  • Winston_from_the_Ministry

    Hmmm, not quite as simple as you make out here Mark. As factcheck showed: http://fullfact.org/factchecks/have_police_officers_risen_fallen_Boris_Johnson-10036

    • jaime taurosangastre candelas

      As you say. Overall numbers are also not necessarily a particularly useful statistic, because it does not reveal what the police are actually doing. 90 policemen doing things that are 100% in accordance with agreed priorities are of greater utility than 100 policemen doing things only 60% in support of agreed priorities. The same arguments can be made for doctors, nurses, teachers, etc.

      It is surprising how many clinically trained staff in the NHS are employed doing any number of strange things that do not involve actually dealing with patients, but merely require some (normally fairly low) level of medical expertise. Operating the disease classification and recording databases, for example. The main skill in this is knowing medical taxonomy (ie how to classify, sub-classify, sub-sub classify, etc medical conditions. It is in effect the skills need from a Librarian).

      The dirty secret is that while currently only doctors are taught medical taxonomy as part of their training, you could teach it as a discrete topic to non-medically qualified people, in less than 6 months*****. And it would be a lot cheaper to do so than to spend £350-500,000 on training someone to be a doctor to then do a technician’s job. But, there would be “less” doctors employed in the NHS as a result, and political horror at this apparent lessening of capability.

      Alternatively, full time employed on medical research that is in many cases well behind the research done in proper researching institutions and academia (the NHS has not pioneered much new in medicine for many years). If you speak with one of these colleagues who does this work, often you will find that it is a little “sinecure” that they have found and choose to work in, for whatever their personal reasons, and very few people will challenge it or ask the question “the country spent a lot of money training you, so what output do we get back?”

      (And no one should open the “can of worms” that is the number of part time GPs employed, all trained at 100% of the cost of training, but a significant number opting to work at 3/5ths of capacity and draw the still very large 3/5ths of a full time GPs salary. It is of course their choice, but it is hugely wasteful of the costs of training)

      ***** Biology and chemistry A levels would suffice.

Latest

  • News Miliband’s message tomorrow: young people and the NHS

    Miliband’s message tomorrow: young people and the NHS

    Tomorrow, Ed Miliband will address Conference in his final leader’s speech before the general election. As we reported earlier this evening, rumours are circulating around Manchester that he’s going to announce a mansion tax to pay for increased NHS spending. For the moment, however, these are just rumours. Here’s what we are sure of: He will reveal (and reiterate) 6 key planks to Labour’s policy agenda in the run-up to the general election (listed below). Miliband will put particular emphasis […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Miliband expected to pledge a mansion tax to pay for increased NHS spending

    Miliband expected to pledge a mansion tax to pay for increased NHS spending

    Rumours are flying around Conference this evening that Ed Miliband will tomorrow pledge a mansion tax to pay for an increase in NHS spending. It is now believed to be the major policy announcement of Miliband’s Conference speech. Reports are emerging that Labour will put a tax on homes worth over £2million in order to improve public services in health and social care. The NHS had been widely understood to be the major topic of this week’s Conference, although has […]

    Read more →
  • Comment A little more conversation, a lot more action – getting our infrastructure right

    A little more conversation, a lot more action – getting our infrastructure right

    The infrastructure we use to travel, talk and power our homes and businesses is constantly being renewed and improved. When we get it right, it delivers outcomes that society hugely values such as easier and quicker commuting, allowing people more time to spend with their families, clean, plentiful water supplies and access to affordable energy. The best infrastructure is also future proof and helps to tackle climate change. But infrastructure can also be a source of huge frustration and contention […]

    Read more →
  • News Unions call for Labour to offer EU referendum

    Unions call for Labour to offer EU referendum

    General secretary of the GMB, Paul Kenny, has said that Labour should commit to having a referendum on the EU. Although Kenny is in favour of remaining in the EU, he told the Financial Times (£): “This is now not the European Union we signed up for. There has been a fundamental change. A referendum wouldn’t worry me, people should hear the argument about Europe and put it on the table . . . Labour should offer a referendum on Europe.” He went on […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour to reduce energy bills by improving home insulation

    Labour to reduce energy bills by improving home insulation

    The Sun (£) have reported today that Caroline Flint, Shadow Energy Secretary, is set to reveal new plans to improve ageing homes by insulating roofs, walls and windows – in turn meaning that people have to use less energy. Following on from Ed Miliband’s announcement that a next Labour government will freeze energy bills, this upgrade in insulation will help people across the UK to reduce their energy bills and could potentially have a positive impact in terms of the environment. […]

    Read more →