The case for a Rural Living Wage

January 16, 2013 4:03 pm

As a minister at the old Department for Children, Schools and Families, I was very proud when Ed Balls agreed it would be the first government department to pay the London Living Wage. The high cost of housing and the concentration of poverty in the capital makes the case overwhelming; but the case for a rural living wage is equally strong.

If you are poor in rural areas it is a real struggle. The quality of life attracts asset rich retirees and second home owners, making housing often unaffordable. Local shops are a long way from distribution centres, competition is limited, and so prices are higher than the average. Wages are also low as local jobs can be limited to cleaning, care, hospitality and micro businesses; or if you’re lucky, the public sector. But the local council will be underfunded relative to urban councils, and can’t afford the support services you need if living in poverty.

The best way out of poverty is work – but only if work pays. Topping up low pay through the tax system is one way forward, as the tax credit system has shown. Better still is for employers to pay decent wages. That is why I hope Labour colleagues in the Counties will campaign for a rural living wage in this year’s Council elections.

It is also why I will be pressing Ministers this evening to withdraw their amendment to the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform (ERR) Bill that would abolish the Agricultural Wages Board (AWB) for England.

Set up in 1917, the AWB has put a floor under wages for almost a century. It means farmers’ representatives negotiate terms and conditions every year with unions, and workers then get reasonable pay, protection and career progression. Without it, workers will have to deal direct with their employers, the reality of which would be pay cuts for the workers (of around £32.5m per year) and the burden of staff negotiations on farmers. Indeed, the latter is one of the reasons why the Farmers Union for Wales agrees with the Welsh Assembly Government in retaining the AWB.

Previously, as an MP, I represented the Frampton Estate where the Tolpuddle Martyrs had worked before their arrest in 1834. The outcry at their treatment and transportation was a crucial moment in the history of the trade union movement.  It was born out of James Frampton’s power to bully, and his influence over the local judiciary in passing such an extreme sentence.

But today, as Unite the Union say, “there is no more ‘tightly-knit’ community than a small rural community, where a farm worker’s employer, employer’s spouse or other members of their family may be in positions of social control such as a justice of the peace, a parish councillor, a school governor, all of these and more.” This makes negotiation by workers in these communities very difficult indeed.

Or as my colleague Margaret Prosser said when this issue was last debated in the Lords, “The most particular aspect is that in many circumstances the relationship between the worker and the employer is very personal. The relationship often involves just one or two employees and one employer. It is a very close relationship where day-to-day friendship and trust has to be established. How, in those circumstances, can the employee raise for himself or herself the sorts of questions that need to be answered if that employee is to feel secure in his or her employment and endeavour to improve his or her circumstances?”

There are many other reasons for retaining the protection that the AWB gives 154,000 workers in England – a much better deal for young people, better training, the particular conditions in what is a dangerous profession.  In return, the impact assessment says the positive employment effects will be ‘not significantly different from zero’.

It is also shocking that the consultation period for this proposal has been only for four weeks, with Ministers trying to rush the plans through. For me however, the AWB is the starting point for a living wage for everyone in rural England – and this move by a Lib Dem farming minister will undo the good work by Lloyd George almost a century ago.

Lord Jim Knight of Weymouth is Labour’s Shadow DEFRA Minister in the Lords. This piece was first posted on the Labour Lords blog.

  • Quiet_Sceptic

    You mention housing costs, for a lot of villages a ‘living wage’ wouldn’t even come close to paying for housing, even well paid jobs wouldn’t get you a house. You aren’t going to overcome that with a living wage or housing benefit.

    Part of the solution has to be having the planning system tilted in favour of allowing social housing to be built in rural area even when those areas are in scenic locations. You see no end of villages where virtually all development seems to have stopped sometime in the mid-1970s and the only thing built in the last 20-30 years has been very large, executive detached homes or perhaps more accurately, small mansions.

    • TomFairfax

      Hi QS,
      ‘ You see no end of villages where virtually all development seems to
      have stopped sometime in the mid-1970s and the only thing built in the
      last 20-30 years has been very large, executive detached homes..’

      Precisely. Even the so called ‘affordable’ homes built before 2010 were really just ‘smaller’ homes and not particularly affordable.

  • http://www.facebook.com/jim.crowder2 Jim Crowder

    There are few enough jobs in the countryside as it is. Putting up the costs of employment for companies that employ people won’t help.

  • TomFairfax

    I’m not convinced about a rural living wage. The main issues are housing and jobs and this proposal doesn’t deal with either. Second homes blight the communities because they are occupied part time and therefore mean local business see their markets shrink and close destroying jobs, while at the same time depriving the locality of housing available to those from the area. In some cases a Jersey style solution may be necessary to stop the rot.

Latest

  • News Labour to auction off Patrick Stewart’s voice to raise election funds

    Labour to auction off Patrick Stewart’s voice to raise election funds

    Labour will be holding a gala dinner with an auction to raise major funds for next year’s election campaign. Hosted by Stephen Fry, attendees will be able to bid on a host of items, including artworks by the likes of Sir Antony Gormley, Anish Kapoor and Grayson Perry, a signed Cristiano Ronaldo football shirt, for Sir Patrick Stewart to record a voicemail for you and… a five-a-side football match against the Shadow Cabinet. The five-a-side team includes Jim Murphy, Sadiq […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Time for bigger thinking on our railways

    Time for bigger thinking on our railways

    There is a lively debate across the country about the future of our railways. At the heart of this is a sense – shared amongst the public – that the rail system is not delivering the best deal for us as passengers or taxpayers. For a start, our railways are far more expensive than in other countries. The botched privatisation of the 1990s created a complex split between train, rolling stock and track which has led to needless costs. Our […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour should vote against legal aid reform today, says shadow justice minister

    Labour should vote against legal aid reform today, says shadow justice minister

    Andy Slaughter the shadow justice minister has called for Labour MPs to oppose the coalition’s proposals to change legal aid eligibility, the vote over which is due to take place in the Commons today. The vote is over government proposals to make it so that to assess whether people are eligible for legal aid, they will have to take a residency test. This means, only those who have been residents in England and Wales for a year or more are […]

    Read more →
  • News Growth forecast almost as good as when Labour were in power

    Growth forecast almost as good as when Labour were in power

    Forecasters have predicted that the UK’s economic growth for the last quarter will have risen to 0.9% - up from 0.8% in the last quarter. While this is very good news, and we can all welcome an increase in growth, it is worth noting that this is the highest quarter of growth since the second quarter of 2010 – or in other words, when Labour left office. Labour left the Tories with a recovering economy, and quarterly growth of 1%. By […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Will Labour remember the forgotten local government workforce?

    Will Labour remember the forgotten local government workforce?

    Tomorrow local government workers will make up the majority of those taking part in the largest day of strike action the Coalition has faced. Thousands will be out in force protesting against the government’s punitive public sector pay policy. The Tories, aided and abetted by their friends in the right wing media, are predictably ganging up against the strike and public service workers.  They are doing everything they can to rubbish our members and attack the few employment rights that we […]

    Read more →