Ed Miliband is not Tony Blair – he’ll need to seize power in his own way

February 4, 2013 6:33 am

It’s now well known that the single greatest explanation for Labour’s steady lead in the polls is the defection of former Liberal Democrat voters to the party’s ranks. If Labour can sustain a decent proportion of this new Lib Dem support it is on track to be the largest party in the next parliament.

But new Fabian Society research shows that an outright majority in 2015 also depends on Labour winning over people who didn’t vote at all in 2010. The good news is that huge numbers of people who declined to vote at the last election now say they’ll back us. But the party will only secure a majority if it can persuade these new supporters to actually cast their ballots in two years’ time.

We used a specially commissioned You Gov poll to assess the voting intentions of people who didn’t vote in the 2010 election. You Gov’s polling methodology is particularly suitable for this analysis because the pollster uses a panel of respondents and so is able to re-question people who originally told them they didn’t vote immediately after the May 2010 election. The poll found that 23 per cent of the sample of 2010 non-voters now say they’ll vote Labour. According to Fabian Society calculations using the data, this means an estimated 1.4 million people in the non-voter group now plan to vote Labour.

This shift in support is factored into Labour’s headline polling numbers and has boosted Labour’s lead by around five percentage points, which could translate into an extra 40 seats in the House of Commons. With the polls expected to narrow as the election nears, the stickiness of this non-voter bloc is likely to make the difference between a hung parliament and a Labour majority.

2010 non-voters are so important because the party has won very few supporters directly from the Conservatives. Despite the troubles the government has faced over the last 12 months only one to two per cent of voters have switched directly from Labour to the Tories (estimated at 400,000 people). Hardly ideal perhaps, but let’s not beat ourselves up too much. Even without many ex-Tories, we’re well ahead in the polls so the priority is to hang on to the supporters we’ve got.

That means accentuating our positives. I’ve suggested before that Labour is doing well because it is succeeding in building a centre left coalition of support. We know that Labour’s post-2010 converts are just as left-leaning as our 2010 voters, so it’s likely that many of the non-voters we’ve acquired are former Labour supporters who gave up on the party in the latter half of our term of office (rather like many of the ex-Lib Dems who are now returning to us). As these broadly left-leaning voters have seen the effects of the coalition and as Labour’s time in office has grown more distant they have been prepared to consider the party again.

Labour’s strength is therefore based on the return of former supporters who turned away from the party and new voters who share the same values. Meanwhile Labour’s failure to attract 2010 Conservatives has a silver lining: it means the party has fairly few current supporters who might switch back to the Tories as their mid-term blues recede. I’d argue that Labour’s polling lead is much more vulnerable to apathy and disenchantment among its loose centre-left coalition than it is to deserters from Conservative-inclined ‘swing voters’. Labour must craft its manifesto and campaign with this in mind.

In other words, 2015 is set to be an ‘Obama-style’ election, with very few people likely to switch between the two main parties and a Labour victory dependent on motivating and mobilising sympathetic voters. This analysis indicates that Labour stands a strong chance of winning as long as we can learn from the grassroots campaign techniques of the Democrats.

Ed Miliband is not Tony Blair and he’ll need to seize power in his own way. Blair’s success was based on winning over disillusioned ex-Tories who are so far resisting Miliband’s appeal. But Ed has won the backing of people who had given up on voting as well as former Lib Dems: the Fabian research shows that together there are enough of them for Labour to win.

Andrew Harrop is the General Secretary of the Fabian Society

  • http://twitter.com/KulganofCrydee Kulgan of Crydee

    The problem for Ed Miliband is that he is not seizing power. He is drifting on his way to No10.

  • JeevanJones

    When it says “over the last 12 months only one to two per cent of voters have switched directly from Labour to the Tories”, I’m assuming that’s meant to be written the other way around?

    Some very good points, particularly around non-voters. Labour supporters are notoriously hard to get out to vote, and non-voters even more so. Labour has to really focus on getting them out. There’s a massive difference between people saying they will vote, and actually doing it on election day.

  • NT86

    Winning back Tory voters is a lost cause IMO. They’ve got their own problems and their defectors are going to be eyeing UKIP with orgasmic eyes. Only traditional Tory seat which can return a Labour MP is Birmingham Edgbaston. Gisela Stuart’s a very good local MP and Eurosceptic.

    The good thing about the Lib Dems winning 6 million votes in 2010 is that it’s opened up a huge opportunity for Labour to seize, and I think that they should be able to hold onto them as most tend to be ideologically more inclined to Labour than the Tories.

    But tapping into the non-voter section of people must be Ed’s target strategy. Some of them might have been former Labour voters who simply didn’t show up to polling stations (understandably) last time.

    • AlanGiles

      Quite the most telling example of how out of touch senior Tories are was demonstrated on The World This Weekend yesterday. What was exercising the minds of former party chairmen and MPs most?. The economy?, No. Not even the EU. It was – gay marriage.

      Now I have no wish to marry another man, but quite frankly what other people choose to do in their private lives is a matter of complete indifference to me. I would imagine most people would be more concerned about rising food and fuel prices, the problems with trying to do more with less in social services, and a general feeling that nobody has any real answers to the problems that face this country. I am sure gay marriage figures very low on the list of priorities.

      At the risk of getting more “downs” under my comments, I would say the only reason Ed Miliband is doing reasonably well, is because the Coalition are doing super-bad.

      However, it is foolish to pretend Labour has very much to say (or rather they have a lot to say, or will have, once Crudas comes down from the mountain with the tablets of stone.). Whether actions will follow the endless words, who can hazard a guess?

      Here is an example of the sheer banality of our probable future Prime Minister. Perhaps he had been eating radishes that day?

  • Chilbaldi

    Another US election fetishist – US electioneering is almost completely irrelevant to what works in this country. You maybe had a nice holiday over in the US one November but that’s about it.

  • David Parker

    Even without the aid of polling it was blindingly obvious that it was the steadily growing disillusionment with New Labour that turned voters to the Lib- Dems (who sometimes appeared to be more left-wing) or a caused them to stay at home. Any reversion to the neo-liberalism of the Blair years in order to attract convinced Tory voters would be an error. On the other there are significant numbers who can be won back to policies which focus on the common good, promote public services and small businesses.

Latest

  • Featured Scotland Friendship and solidarity must prevail, as the fog clears

    Friendship and solidarity must prevail, as the fog clears

    The air hangs thick this morning with the referendum. Last night a deep fog rolled down across Edinburgh, but in reality it is the campaign which has blotted the vision and stopped even the keenest of observers from seeing what lies just a few footsteps ahead. The final days has provided one crucial clarification though – the No campaign is capable of great passion and powerful rhetoric. Mocked, endlessly criticised, a reputation dragged through the muck. Despite it all – […]

    Read more →
  • News Scottish Referendum – The Liveblog

    Scottish Referendum – The Liveblog

    Are you campaigning in Scotland today? Send us your stories (named or anonymous) to elections@labourlist.org – and we’ll run the pick of them on the liveblog. 14.39: Update from Mark: “After campaigning in Leith this afternoon, I popped over to the Better Together office there to speak to campaigners and grab a cup of tea. After a few minutes I stepped outside to check some messages and make some phone calls. And that was when someone spat at me. He […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Scotland Please don’t go

    Please don’t go

    I’m pretty well known for writing from a personal perspective. So I thought a column comparing the pain I feel about the referendum to the pain of my divorce would be easy to write. maybe a little trite even. How can this compare to that kind of personal pain? Well, it does. Maybe it shouldn’t, but it does. I feel like a lover treading on eggshells desperate to please. I really, really don’t want Scotland to leave me. So yes, […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Scotland Solidarity – a view from South of the border

    Solidarity – a view from South of the border

    “Solidarity” has always been a special word for me. But it has never been an easy one to define. Loyalty, unity, mutual support; all of those come into it but none of them quite sums the word up properly. Somehow solidarity is the “whole” that is more than the sum of its parts. But however difficult solidarity may be to define, you know when you see it and you know it when you experience it. As a trade unionist and […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Bring your old football kit to conference

    Bring your old football kit to conference

    Every football fan has got a favourite football strip. That kit your team wore when they won the Cup, or the first game you went to, the season you got promoted, or the first year you had a season ticket. I’ve got more football tops than I’d care to admit – Athletic Bilbao, Kaizer Chiefs, Brazil, Scotland, South Africa, for some reason Motherwell and Middlesbrough. I also have a couple belonging to a team from Glasgow that play in green […]

    Read more →