Labour must make the case for patient involvement

13th February, 2013 11:58 am

Since the formation of the Coalition Government no topic has generated as much heated debate as health and the NHS. Understandably, the vast majority of this debate has focused around the Health and Social Care Bill. However other fundamental changes have received much less attention – far fewer people are aware that from 2014 all new branded drugs will be subject to a revised process of drug pricing known as value-based pricing (VBP).

This change represents an opportunity to move away from an unwieldy system that delays access to life-extending drugs, results in inequalities in access to new medicines and relies on temporary measures such as the Cancer Drug Fund in England. Worryingly this is an opportunity that is in danger of slipping away.

Under the new system prices will be set based on the perceived value of a drug rather than its cost alone. Amongst other determinations, this new system includes considerations of the ‘wider societal benefits’ that any new drug would provide. To date, much of the debate around these ‘wider societal benefits’ has focused on the importance of helping people get back to work. This is an important issue, but one that is not relevant to everyone.   In particular, it may disadvantage those who are already retired, unable to re-enter the workforce due to ill health or are children or young adults who are still in education or training.

Although value-based pricing is scheduled to be introduced in 2014, not enough has been done to consult the most important group of all: patients. Availability of new drugs is always a highly emotive issue – despite this, little information has been made available about how VBP will work in practice. This lack of openness has prevented meaningful engagement with patients and patient organisations.

Having identified this gap, Prostate Cancer UK has commissioned a report outlining the views of people affected by cancer on these important changes. This report Value-based pricing: Getting it right for people with cancer, published in partnership with fourteen other leading cancer charities, shows that people affected by cancer want to have an equal role with the pharmaceutical industry and the Government in the design of the VBP system.

Patient groups have the experience, the knowledge and above all, the desire to help develop a better system. Clearly, a new process is needed to ensure that the views of people affected by these changes can be considered in a meaningful way alongside evidence on the clinical and cost effectiveness of drugs. Prostate Cancer UK are keen to work with politicians from all parties to get the best possible system for patients and are interested in hearing from anyone who wants to take action on this issue.

There are clear opportunities to champion the rights of patients, making the case that those most affected by VBP are at the heart of the system. As the Francis report made clear, the time for greater involvement of patients and patient groups in decision making has arrived, the case must be made before the chance for meaningful reform is wasted.

Dr Sarah Cant is Director of Policy and Campaigns at Prostate Cancer UK


  • Comment Featured A clean energy revolution is in reach within a generation

    A clean energy revolution is in reach within a generation

    In a few days’ time world leaders will gather in Paris for the UN summit on climate change. It will be a poignant moment. The Paris attacks were acts of hatred, designed to divide us from one another, crush people’s hopes and destroy lives. By contrast these talks, taking place in the same city, will be a huge opportunity for many countries to come together to put individual interests aside for our common good. It will be our chance to […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Hilary Benn tops LabourList readers’ Shadow Cabinet rankings

    Hilary Benn tops LabourList readers’ Shadow Cabinet rankings

    Shadow Foreign Secretary Hilary Benn is currently LabourList readers’ top ranked Shadow Cabinet member. Benn had the highest average score in the monthly survey, where readers rank each member on a scale of 1 to 5. His score came to just shy of 3.4, while second placed John McDonnell was close behind with slightly over 3.3. McDonnell had a high-profile week after responding to George Osborne’s Autumn Statement in the Chamber of the House of Commons, while Benn has been […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Shadow Cabinet on course to give MPs free vote on Syria

    Shadow Cabinet on course to give MPs free vote on Syria

    The Shadow Cabinet appears to be on course to give Labour MPs a free vote on airstrikes against ISIS in Syria next week after Hilary Benn confirmed his support for military action on the Today programme this morning. The Shadow Foreign Secretary said he is “convinced of the case for effective action” in Syria and said that a free vote may be where “we end up”. He also rejected the suggestion that he would resign over the issue on the […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Full text of Momentum’s draft letter to Labour MPs about airstrikes on Syria

    Full text of Momentum’s draft letter to Labour MPs about airstrikes on Syria

    Momentum, the pressure group founded out of Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership campaign, is urging its supporters to send this letter to Labour MPs. I am writing to you as a Labour voter to urge you to oppose Tory proposals for the UK to join military action in Syria against ISIL/Daesh. I am sure we would both like to see the defeat of both ISIL and the Assad regime – but it is not clear that this is an achievable aim. The military […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Full text of Jeremy Corbyn’s letter to Labour MPs about airstrikes on Syria

    Full text of Jeremy Corbyn’s letter to Labour MPs about airstrikes on Syria

    Dear Colleague, The Prime Minister made a Statement to the House today making the case for a UK bombing campaign against ISIS in Syria. A copy of my response has already been circulated. We have all been horrified by the despicable attacks in Paris and are determined to see the defeat of ISIS. Our first priority must be the security of Britain and the safety of the British people. The issue now is whether what the Prime Minister is proposing […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends