We need to shine a bright light into the dark recesses of Michael Gove’s Department

February 21, 2013 2:32 pm

I’ve been in politics for twenty years, and have seen plenty of rough and tumble. What has been happening in the Department of Education since Michael Gove took over goes much further than that.

The Education Secretary’s closest advisers appear to be acting with complete impunity. Either they have been given carte blanche from their boss to smear and bully those who question his approach, or they are out of control – “feral” in the words of one Liberal Democrat source.

Today’s latest development exposes the behaviour of Dominic Cummings. He wrote an email to the Education Editor of the Independent, Richard Garner. Richard is an experienced journalist who knows the education brief in depth, and is personable and mild mannered.

Cummings is reported to have emailed Richard Garner about a recent piece in the newspaper saying “you should speak to Chris Cook about a good therapist.” This is an extraordinary smear on both Richard Garner and Chris Cook, who works for the Financial Times, and has previously had his mental health questioned by the @toryeducation Twitter account who described him as a ‘Walter Mitty’ figure.  The account, which appears to have close and intimate knowledge of what is happening at the DfE is regularly used to launch personal attacks on people.

This kind of behaviour would be a clear breach of the Code of Conduct for Special Advisers, and if proven on the face of it the allegations seem serious enough that Dominic Cummings should do the honourable thing and resign, given the clear guidance within the Code. The Code specifically prohibits personal attacks such as these, saying they have no part to play in the role of a special adviser or in public life more generally.

These smears would be worrying on their own. But the trouble is they are not isolated. The Observer has reported on a bullying case involving a senior civil servant at the Department of Education who developed stress and physical health problems as a result of perceived intimidation from both Dominic Cummings and James Frayne, who was until recently the Director of Communications appointed by Michael Gove.

The case resulted in a pay out of around £25,000 to the victim, but the Education Secretary denied all knowledge of the case when I asked him about inappropriate behaviour amongst his advisers. This seems incredible given the case involved two of his closest aides.

Both Cummings and Frayne set up a think tank before joining Government, called the New Frontiers Foundation where they argued that there should be a widespread purge of independent civil servants. They worked closely with Bain & Company, the US management consultancy linked to Mitt Romney which has been appointed to drive through a restructure of the department which will result in 1,000 people losing their jobs.

Given the discipline of advisers is the personal responsibility of the Secretary of State, I believe it is high time the Education Select Committee was able to question both the Education Secretary and his special advisers so we can get to the bottom of exactly what is going on.

These cases speak to the ideological extremism that is currently plaguing the Department of Education. That can’t be in the interests of sound education policy or improving our schools.

We need to shine a bright light into the dark recesses of the Department, and find out exactly what has been happening since Michael Gove came to office.

Ian Mearns is the Labour MP for Gateshead and a Member of the Education Select Committee

  • Daniel Speight

    Maybe we still need to find out a bit more about the half-a-million pounds that Gove gave to Rachel Wolf two-and-half years ago after moving into the department. A subject that Guido doesn’t seem to want to expose. What’s that relationship all about I wonder.

Latest

  • News Labour defend minimum wage target from “plainly absurd” criticism

    Labour defend minimum wage target from “plainly absurd” criticism

    Labour has responded to criticism by Alan Milburn today that their pledge to raise the National Minimum Wage is not ambitious enough. Milburn said that none of the plans set out by any party to deal with tackling child poverty were “anywhere near good enough”. Labour’s Shadow Minister for Trade and Infrastructure Ian Murray has hit back at the suggestion, saying: “Labour’s plans would see an £8 minimum wage before 2020 – rising more than twice as fast as under […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Why Labour must be the flag bearer for regionalisation

    Why Labour must be the flag bearer for regionalisation

    We are at a crossroads in our political history, as talk surrounds the future of our involvement in the EU and the question of English votes for English laws. One area that has been discussed fleetingly is the idea of devolution to the English regions. Every time the subject is raised, talk moves onto the failed referendum in the North East. This however was in a different era before the rise of UKIP and the Scottish independence debate that has […]

    Read more →
  • News Milburn says Labour’s minimum wage target not ambitious enough

    Milburn says Labour’s minimum wage target not ambitious enough

    Alan Milburn, the former Labour minister who now chairs the commission on social mobility and child poverty, has launched an excoriating attack on all three major political parties for failing to face up to the reality of poverty in Britain. The commission will today publish its second State of the Nation review, and Milburn says he “hope[s] today’s report makes uncomfortable reading for all political parties”. In an article in this morning’s Times (£), Milburn slams plans to make real-terms […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Freud and the politics of cruelty

    Freud and the politics of cruelty

    That story about the frog not noticing that the water it is sitting in is getting hotter and hotter, with fatal results? Probably not true.  But why let the facts get in the way of a cherished metaphor? There is a bigger point here: sometimes we don’t notice how things are changing because the change is happening bit by bit. That is one of the dangers of moral relativism. A gradual decline in standards can lead you to an ugly place. […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Why Britain’s women won’t “calm down”

    Why Britain’s women won’t “calm down”

    From November 4th until the end of 2014, women across the country will effectively be working for free. The gender pay gap means that women are paid on average 15% less than their male counterparts; we have to work an extra 60 days annually to earn the same amount as a man doing the same job. For black and minority ethnic women, the pay gap is 20%. Women in Britain need a pay rise. It was heartening to see so many […]

    Read more →
7ads6x98y