Ian Mearns MP explains why he resigned as a PPS

March 22, 2013 7:06 pm

As we reported yesterday, Gateshead MP Ian Mearns resigned as a PPS following his rebellion against the party line (along with 40+ others) on welfare sanctions. Mearns has told International Business Times his reasons for rebelling – and resigning:

“Based on my casework experience I do not have any real faith at all that Iain Duncan Smith could oversee a fair, open and transparent mechanism at the DWP. We were voting for possible sanctions on everyone since 2011. That’s not fair.”

“Then I had to resign, or it would have been a case of getting the sack because I had voted against the wishes of the leadership of the party on this issue.”

“The line being taken by the frontbench team was one that everyone was not comfortable with. I have talked to colleagues and many of them who abstained did so with a very heavy heart.”

“The timing was unfortunate. On the day of the Budget, the frontbench did not want to run the risk of being called irresponsible. But there’s neither a good nor a bad time when we want to do the right thing.”

  • Dave Postles

    Heartfelt thanks to him, but really the rest should have had the same integrity. In any case, where were they during the discussion in the chamber?

  • AlanGiles

    At least Mr. Mearns can hold his head high knowing that he voted with his conscience. In his place I would have done the same thing. There are times when you have to say enough is enough and resign as a matter of principle.

    If other backbenchers did what they did with “a heavy heart” then they have themselves to blame for their weakness and cowardice. I don’t know how they can live with themselves.

    I wonder if Byrne will ever have the decency to resign, or Miliband find the backbone to sack him.

  • Daniel Speight

    “The timing was unfortunate. On the day of the Budget, the frontbench did not want to run the risk of being called irresponsible. But there’s neither a good nor a bad time when we want to do the right thing.”

    Forget the spin and the strange excuses, I suspect this is the real reason for the abstention command. It is still fear of the tabloids.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=36910622 Edward Carlsson Browne

      Which is bizarre really, because under what circumstances could you imagine the Daily Mail not calling us irresponsible?

  • http://twitter.com/kathiebennett kathleen bennett

    what a lovely man

  • Monkey_Bach

    Mr. Means behaved honourably.

    But is Labour really saying that the Party can only be depended upon to do the right thing, on non-special days, when there’s absolutely no danger that somebody, somewhere, might call it a rude name?

    Could Labour be weaker, more cowardly, and pathetic than this?

    I am speechless.

    Eeek.

  • Rosie2
  • http://www.mr-omneo.co.uk Mr Omneo

    Ian Mearns should be applauded for having the courage of his convictions. Something you could once expect from nearly all Labour MPs. Sadly those days seem to have passed.

  • http://www.facebook.com/daniel.gardner.18062 Daniel Rendarg

    And this is why people like me stopped voting Labour – one brave guy, with 35 colleagues while the majority of the party abstains because its budget day. What a pathetic excuse. If you want my vote back you need to stand for something beyond tomorrows headlines. Not impressed. (But very well done Ian, you at least give me hope)

  • Jeremy_Preece

    What an honerable man. I say take Ian Mearns and give him Liam Brynes’ job.

    And there is nothing to be gained by trying to appease the right wing media either, at the end of the day the thing that people respect is those who stand up for their principles.

Latest

  • News Tom Watson teams up with former Conservative Shadow Home Secretary to sue the government over DRIP

    Tom Watson teams up with former Conservative Shadow Home Secretary to sue the government over DRIP

    It’s reported today that Tom Watson, the Labour MP for West Bromwich East and former Campaign Co-orindator, has teamed up with David Davis, the former Conservative Home Secretary, to sue the government over the Data Retention and Investigatory Powers bill (DRIP). DRIP – which has been introduced into a European Court of Justice ruling that said actions taken under the Data Retentions Act of 2009 were illegal – gives the government extensive surveillance powers and makes it so that internet and phone […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour accuse Maude of “politically inspired civil service bashing”

    Labour accuse Maude of “politically inspired civil service bashing”

    Cabinet Office Minister Francis Maude has been accused of causing a crisis in Whitehall morale through “routine, politically inspired civil service bashing” by his Labour counterpart Michael Dugher. This comes after Sir Bob Kerslake stepped down from his role as Head of the Civil Service last week, a situation that Dugher describes as “shabby”. Speaking to the national trade union committee today, Dugher said that Kerslake’s departure comes due to Tory ministers fomenting a poor working relationship, say they had: “made […]

    Read more →
  • News Polling Latest Ashcroft marginal polling shows UKIP could win top Labour target seats

    Latest Ashcroft marginal polling shows UKIP could win top Labour target seats

    Lord Ashcroft has released his latest polling of marginal Conservative-held seats where Labour are in second place – in other words, Labour’s top target seats. He last polled these fourteen seats in late May, and the results suggested that Labour would win thirteen of them. The latest fieldwork, however, shows a greater swing to UKIP, and not just from the Tories: they’re taking plenty of Labour votes too. Labour are now on course to win just eleven of the seats, with […]

    Read more →
  • Comment No child should be too hungry to learn

    No child should be too hungry to learn

    Universal healthy free school meals is a policy that has been pioneered by Labour and by Labour councils in Southwark, Hull, Newham, Islington and Durham. At the National Policy Forum (NPF) over the weekend, Labour’s policy for the General Election was thrashed out and during this a commitment was made to finding ways to extend this cross cutting policy. The consensus wording makes Labour’s current record and future ambitions on free school meals clear. Just over a year ago, the […]

    Read more →
  • News Cameron could be as bad as Putin, says former Cabinet minister

    Cameron could be as bad as Putin, says former Cabinet minister

    David Cameron risks comparisons with Russian President Vladimir Putin if he goes ahead with plans to allow Parliament to veto rulings by the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), according to former Attorney General Dominic Grieve. According to The Times (£), Cameron is reportedly planning to make the proposal a centrepiece of his Autumn conference speech, in an effort to win over Tory backbenchers and UKIP voters. Grieve has had a long-term opposition to the idea, with many suggesting it is […]

    Read more →