Labour must mean business at the next election

October 14, 2013 10:20 am

Have you met “Laura Smith” yet? She’s the rather unconvincing star of the latest ad for Halifax bank. Well, I say “ad for Halifax bank”. If you watch this clip you’ll see that (spoiler alert!) for the first 45 seconds out of a minute of costly air time there’s no mention of banking at all. It looks more like an ad for an airline. This is where we’ve got to today: businesses that pay for expensive ads but who are too embarrassed to say what business they are really in.

Business is on the back foot. And in many cases deservedly so. Clearly the banks, which we’ve all bailed out, still have a lot of work to do in terms of changing culture and working practices. Investment banks seem barely changed at all. Don’t take my word for it – take a look at Joris Luyendijk’s brilliant banking blog on the Guardian web site.

But it’s not just the banks. A trip down the high street can often be a pretty depressing experience. Badly managed, demotivated staff are doing repetitive, unexciting jobs for poor rates of pay. Phoning up a call centre can be a grim “customer experience” too: patience and a robust sense of humour are required. This is not to blame the employees, of course. The businesses they are working for are sometimes just not good enough.

As I argue in a piece for The Independent today there is currently a dearth of inspiring leadership in British business. Yes, times are hard, and markets (please don’t call it a “global race”) can be competitive. But there is no need for the defensiveness and even grumpiness that we see in business circles. Balance sheets have been restored since the depths of the recession, and British businesses are sitting on a lot of cash – hundreds of billions according to some estimates – which they are not investing, either in new staff or new capacity and R&D.

A Financial Times leader today calls on Ed Miliband to tone down what the paper sees as his “distaste” for business. The accusation is unfair. Challenging the energy firms to do better by its customers does not imply distaste for business – merely a desire to protect customers from exploitation by an oligopoly. The 20 month freeze in prices is designed to find time to make the energy market work better. Making markets work better is hardly the policy goal of a subversive. Miliband’s initiative deserves a better and more thoughtful response from the energy companies than it has received so far. Threats of black-outs and investment strikes are no use at all.

It is true that at the last election no significant business figure endorsed the Labour Party, and it’s equally true that it would be good to avoid a repeat of that situation in 2015. Labour should not be an anti-business party. As John Monks, the former TUC general secretary, observed many years ago: “We are all capitalists now.”

But when capitalism is in crisis, as it has been and arguably still is, it sometimes falls to social democrats to help bring it back to health. So Ed Miliband should not be put off by some of the harrumphing in certain quarters, no matter how distinguished the harrumphers are. The challenge now is to show how Labour wants the mixed economy to work better. Labour must mean business even if, sadly, some business leaders still don’t appear to.

  • Dave Smith

    I’m not a ‘social democrat’ I’m a socialist. And whilst I understand the need to ‘tolerate’ a mixed economy it shouldn’t be the end goal but just the beginning. A future Labour Party should promote more big business becoming cooperatives, especially promote and help such endeavours when they wish to start and flourish. Trade union rights should be restored so trade unions can sensible negotiate on behalf of the workers they represent in all sectors. Because when you raise the standards of the working classes you raise the standards of all in society. We should also not be afraid of saying load and clear that we will renationalise all the utility companies as it is immoral for them to be in private hands along with rail and other public transport.

    We also need to make it clear that the Royal Mail will also be renationalised ASAP. Let’s grow some balls! This is what the electorate are crying out for. Not some wishy-washy “we are all capitalist” crap being espoused by ‘social democrats’ if these are you opinions then go to that party set up for you. The libdems! Labour should be about offering real change and not just tinkering!

  • http://couloumat.co.uk/ David Parker

    Well, we have had a mixed economy since 1945. Generalities about making it work do not address the key question of what the mix should be. Experience as well as socialist values have made it clear that there is a very reasonable case for the following in one form or another to belong to the public sector and be publically accountable: transport, energy, health, education, housing. If the Labour leadership were to pluck up the courage to say so it would be better received than they imagine.

Latest

  • News Analysis shows where the Greens are the biggest threat to Labour

    Analysis shows where the Greens are the biggest threat to Labour

    The polls have recently shown a rising level of support for the Greens. This poses a big threat to Labour. With the general election fast approaching, Rob Ford, who’s a senior lecturer at the University of Manchester and co-author of Revolt on the Right, has analysed exactly where the threat from the Greens is at its highest. He’s identified 22 seats with the highest amount of people who could move from voting Labour to Green, including current Labour-held seats such as […]

    Read more →
  • News Scotland Labour commit to Home Rule Bill within first 100 days of government

    Labour commit to Home Rule Bill within first 100 days of government

    Margaret Currant, Shadow Scottish Secretary, has today announced that within 100 days of coming into Government, Labour would lay Scotland’s Home Rule Bill in the House of Commons. As well as pledging to do this, Curran has also outlined other devolution priorities. They include: A full review of how Westminster and Scottish Governments can best work together for Scottish people. Bring together Scotland’s council leaders from all parties to decide on a strategy for working together on areas of UK […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Meet Nigel Farage: what UKIP really think about the NHS

    Meet Nigel Farage: what UKIP really think about the NHS

    The fact that UKIP is more Tory than the Tories has been often stated. Nowhere is it more clear that this statement is accurate than on health policy. The General Election will in part be a fight save the NHS. Not just from the Tories, but from UKIP as well. David Cameron’s Tories may have pushed our health service to the brink, but Nigel Farage has never even bothered to hide the fact that he is a cheerleader for increased privatisation, including through charging patients for basic care. Nigel Farage has today defended his Party Secretary who advocates privatisation of […]

    Read more →
  • News Ukip General Secretary compares the NHS to Hitler’s bunker

    Ukip General Secretary compares the NHS to Hitler’s bunker

    Ukip’s General Secretary, Matthew Richardson has called the NHS “the biggest waste of money in the UK”, the Sunday Mirror has uncovered. Richardson was speaking to right-wing activists in Washington DC, and went on to compare the NHS to Nazi Germany. He said “A number I couldn’t possibly imagine when I was younger is now the amount of money that is owed by my country… of course, at the heart of this, the Reichstag bunker of socialism, is the National […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Scotland “The best deal for Scotland is a People’s ScotRail” – Murphy announces rail plans

    “The best deal for Scotland is a People’s ScotRail” – Murphy announces rail plans

    Jim Murphy has announced his preference for a non-profit organisation, People’s Scotrail, running Scotland’s railways. The Scottish Parliament will gain extra powers – devolved through the Smith Agreement – that include allowing a non-profit organisation to bid to run Scotland’s railways. Murphy has backed this idea. This comes after the SNP awarded the contract to a firm run by the Dutch Government – despite Scottish Labour calling for a halt to the ScotRail franchising process until the Scottish Government had more powers post-Smith Commission. Jim […]

    Read more →