Finance nightmare haunts Labour

July 17, 2013 9:28 am

Such is the increasing unthinking, banality of much of the Metropolitan media, that two significant contributions to the debate over Labour’s links with the unions were lost over the weekend.

The first came from former MP, Minister and Diarist, Chris Mullin, who warned that the proposed changes to union affiliations could lead to ‘a decade of one party rule’, with Labour starved of cash, out of office.

He also said that it was high time that we began to hear many of the positive arguments for trades unions, since what they have achieved over decades in terms of holidays, maternity rights, equal pay and much more makes up what we might like to describe as our ‘civilised society’ – albeit one that the Tories seem determined to sweep away.

Mullin might have mentioned that all too often the anti union rhetoric has been most damaging and noxious when it has emanated from super-annuated ex Labour Cabinet Ministers, such as Messrs Mandelson, Blunkett, Reid and Howells. Most of these are now taking the corporate shilling, and each appearance by any of the above often serves to remind many voters why they turned against Labour last time around.

The second came in the shape of wise counsel from Professor Keith Ewing of the UK Constitutional Law Group and a long standing Labour Party member. Writing in Tribune and on Unison Active, Keith Ewing warned of another imminent political attack on free speech – and the unions.

It came in the Government’s recent announcement on political lobbying, which in a quite great breathtaking assault on the unions had the audacity to compare these great democratic and voluntary organisations to private corporations.

The intent is quite clear – any money spent by an affiliated union campaigning at a general election will be declared as Labour Party spending and not as ‘third party expenditure’ as it is at the moment. This legislation has its origins in what has recently been instituted in New South Wales, and bares all the sticky finger prints of the Prime Minister’s spin-meister, Lynton Crosby.

If this goes through, at a stroke the voice of the unions during election time will be silenced unless the Labour Party agrees to what the unions are doing or saying, for fear that it will cut into party election spending. It is as Keith Ewing says, nothing more than a blatant attack on free speech.

If this legislation does succeed it begs the question; where will Labour find the £20 million it will need for the General Election?

In different circumstances, Ed Miliband would be able to call upon the unions to help, even if it did mean that they had little or nothing to spend on their own campaigns. But he has managed to throw a serious spanner in the works with his proposals that trade unionists should ‘opt in’ to the political levy for Labour.

For the real problem in advance of this possible legislation – and in advance of any rule changes on the party union relationship, the hare has been set running. Although Ed Miliband has been told that many of those on the Executives of affiliated unions have been seeking to move away from a link they believe has brought them precious little over the years, the recent storm around Falkirk and the attacks on the unions often from within the party have persuaded still others that the relationship is all but over. It is therefore possible that some unions may disaffiliate from the Labour Party before the next General Election is even called.

It is staggering to think that so little of this has been thought through and just how vulnerable Labour as a party has now become. It is astonishing that no attempt has been made to speak in advance to people such as Keith Ewing, or indeed any of the union general secretaries, before the die was cast.

If I were Ed Miliband, I think I might be tempted to put the planned Trade Union Review by Lord Ray Collins into the deep-freeze, take what the Tories say on the chin – after all they will never call for individual shareholders to ‘opt in’ to the Conservative Party – and sit down with the unions to resolve the differences that have emerged since the utterly unnecessary and overblown Falkirk affair.

  • Kris

    To be honest it’s summer and sunny and I was ignoring politics for a bit ( hint: most people are) then Ed Miliband sent me an email about Labour and the unions and Falkirk… I am not sure who in the comms department thinks this is a good idea but I really doubt it is.

    Anyway for me the real issue is the corporate lobbyists and the fact they have their claws quite clearly into all the parties — and this looks like a blatant attempt to have it all their own way with the Labour Party. So I was unimpressed with Ed’s plan to shoot himself in the foot– what I am looking for is strong action against corporate lobbyists and influence – this was just another sign that far too many people in Labour ( the article mentions some key offenders) are for big global business who have no interest in Britain or its people except to exploit for cash. I am beginning to lose faith in Ed to do anything about it. If this carries on my vote is lost to Labour but in any case without funding they are doomed anyway.

    Who on earth is advising on handling this? The comms strategy is a total mess and has been for some time but this one takes the biscuit and has made a summer storm in a tea cup that would have passed most people by in to a full blown crisis.

Latest

  • News Hague claimed expenses for protest meeting on NHS reforms (but he backed them every single time)

    Hague claimed expenses for protest meeting on NHS reforms (but he backed them every single time)

    The Mirror reports today that: “William Hague claimed hundreds of pounds on expenses to fund a protest meeting – to fight his own Government’s NHS reforms. The Cabinet minister was accused of hypocrisy for campaigning against hated health service cuts in his constituency, while backing the ­Coalition’s changes in Westminster.” Hague spent over £300 on the meeting, including hiring a venue and advertising the meeting in his local paper. The Mirror reports that he voiced “acute concern” and said “I will take all the views […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Angela Eagle calls on Tories to “come clean” over membership figures

    Angela Eagle calls on Tories to “come clean” over membership figures

    There have been reports in recent weeks that Tory Chairman Michael Green  Grant Shapps is set to announce new Tory membership figures at their conference. However, these “higher membership numbers” may not be as they seem, as over Cameron’s time as Tory leader 118,600 members have abandoned his party. With that in mind, Angela Eagle has written to Shapps urging him to come clean, rather than fudging the numbers. Here’s the letter: Dear Grant, I am writing to urge you to […]

    Read more →
  • Comment 10 things the Government can do to help the high street

    10 things the Government can do to help the high street

    As new high streets minister Penny Mordaunt plans to embark on a national town centre tour, Labour’s high street advisor Bill Grimsey offers 10 suggestions on where she should take immediate action to stop the rot, rebuild confidence and help lead a genuine high street recovery. 1. Recognise that town centres and high streets can no longer thrive as a retail destination alone. It’s well documented that there’s too much retail floor space in the UK. I can’t fault Penny’s enthusiasm […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Scotland Scotland: we need a federal future

    Scotland: we need a federal future

    Gordon Brown is right, the work on a more sustainable settlement for the UK must begin the day after a prospective No vote – the status quo is morally and politically indefensible. As has been much noted, an overwhelming number of Scots are in favour of more powers for the Scottish Parliament. If the desire for autonomy under a common unionist structure is not accommodated, it will only push more Scots into the nationalist camp. We must not simply win […]

    Read more →
  • News Video Alistair Darling does the Ice Bucket Challenge

    Alistair Darling does the Ice Bucket Challenge

    Alistair Darling has become the fifth Labour MP to take a soaking for the Ice Bucket Challenge. Earlier this week, we saw Merseyside MPs Stephen Twigg, Luciana Berger, Alison McGovern and Steve Rotherham get drenched for a good cause. Unfortunately, no further MPs were nominated to take part until Scottish actor James McAvoy put the pressure on Scottish referendum opponents Alistair Darling and Alex Salmond to do their bit. Darling has wasted no time – and the staff at Better […]

    Read more →