Insecure Britain – the reality of life under Cameron

August 20, 2013 9:00 am

Last week Cllr Michelle Collins from Wakefield wrote a prescient piece here about the underlying sense of insecurity people face in Britain today.  She is absolutely right – the reality is that David Cameron’s country is a more insecure Britain.

For over 2.5 million people struggling to find work, Government initiatives are failing to help.  Three years into this government nearly 9 out of 10 people on their flagship Work Programme have been let down.  Their Youth Contract has been a failure and is on course to miss its target by more than 92%.

For others in work, they are earning £1,477 less a year on average than they were in 2010.  Furthermore, analysis of Office for Budget Responsibility forecasts by the House of Commons library shows that people will on average have lost a total of £6,660 in real terms by 2015 under the Tory led Government.

But, little commented on is the fact that those in work now feel less secure and more pressured at work than at any time in the past 20 years according to the most recent UK Skills & Employment Survey.  The ballooning of the use of zero hours contracts is symptomatic of this.

Zero-hours contracts do not oblige employers to offer guaranteed hours of work to their workers.  Some chose the arrangement because they like the flexibility but for many it leaves you subject to the whim and demands of your employer to work at short notice, which promotes insecurity and makes family life impossible to plan.

The Shadow Business Innovation and Skills Team – Ian Murray in particular – has been looking at zero-hours contracts in the context of Labour’s policy review for several months now.  Based on what we have learnt from stakeholders and others, we are clear: there is strong anecdotal evidence that these contracts – which should be the exception to the rule – are becoming the norm in far too many sectors and are being abused.

There is little firm data on the extent of the use of zero-hours contracts but over the summer months, the ONS produced revised figures putting the figures at over 250,000.  This is likely to be a severe underestimate given that in the care sector alone others have estimated there are now over 300,000 employees on such contracts.  This culminated in the CIPD releasing figures this month put estimates on the numbers on these contracts at up to a million people.  Consequently, I have written to the chair of the UK Statistics Authority asking the ONS to clarify the data and publish new figures in light of the evidence that has arisen.  Getting a clearer sense of the reality of their use is a must.

My Labour parliamentary colleagues from Merseyside – Luciana Berger, George Howarth and Alison McGovern – also produced an excellent report detailing their use in the Liverpool area in June.  And Julie Elliot held a Westminster Hall debate last month on this issue.  17 Labour MPs made contributions in Julie’s debate but not one Government backbencher spoke save for Nadine Dorries (but she doesn’t count as she was chairing the debate!).  Is it any wonder that Ministers are perceived as “out of touch” when their party shows such little interest in the job insecurities that working people face.

But, never mind their backbenchers, what about the Government’s Ministerial team?  Under pressure, Vince Cable announced a “review” into the issue but it is wholly insufficient.  Usually the Government would conduct a full and proper consultation with a call for evidence – that is what should happen here.  Instead, as has been revealed in answer to Parliamentary Questions I tabled, 3 officials within his department are spending “part of their time” researching how zero-hours contracts are being used by businesses – this does not afford the issue the attention it deserves.

So, further to the work we have carried out to date, we have convened a summit today including over 20 different organisations representing employers, employees, legal experts and workers currently on zero-hours contracts to consider what action should be taken to clamp down on the abuse of these arrangements.  When the House returns we will follow this up with a debate in the House of Commons.  David Cameron might choose to turn a blind eye to growing insecurity for hard-working families and individuals under his watch – we won’t sit idly by whilst that happens.

Chuka Umunna MP is Labour’s Shadow Business Secretary – @ChukaUmunna

  • poppy2009

    Interestingly there is a high percentage of workers who are happy with the zero
    hours who say it’s working for them. Although there is room for discussion for
    improvement which the conservatives are reviewing in September.

  • http://blessayfromamerica.blogspot.com/ Guy Bailey

    I’ll save you the afternoon Chuka – Ban Them.

  • alexagiusuk

    Ed Miliband having a bad time, poor poll ratings and in trouble taking fire from all sides.

    Oh look Chuka Umunna has written an article about how much he and his team care and how hard they are working.

  • aracataca

    Any suggestion that you’re a Tory troll is, and must remain, pure speculation in spite of the overwhelming evidence from the back track of your comments that this is indeed precisely what you are.
    Roll on the thumbs up from the ‘guest’ votes and unfamiliar names, eh Poppy ?

  • Hugh

    “Interestingly there is a high percentage of workers who are happy with the zero hours who say it’s working for them”

    Is there?

  • Monkey_Bach

    Liam Byrne has been busy too, whiling away the empty hours by writing a book on China!

    http://www.amazon.co.uk/Turning-Face-East-Liam-Byrne/dp/0852653301

    How any diligent, hard-working, full-time Labour MP – let alone Shadow Secretary of State for Work and Pensions – with so much responsibility heaped on his shoulders, and so much to do, could possibly have enough spare time to author a tome like this is incredible! If it was anybody other than Mrs. Byrne’s boy Liam, I would suspect that he might have been neglecting his day job to spend more time time with his word-processor.

    Eeek.

    • http://twitter.com/waterwards dave stone

      Doubtless, a work of such stunning erudition would require many hours at the word-processor – but ideas have been developed and perspectives elaborated. Liam has more than earned his keep and demonstrated a statesmanlike grasp of pressing geo-political challenges while providing a sack-full of policy-shaping suggestions.

      These will surely prove to be invaluable when Labour hits the ground running 2015.

      This short extract will give you an indication of the capability of one of Labour’s foremost thinkers:

      “But let’s also remember the lessons of our history. Times change. The world turns. The next few years may be very uncertain but it seems clearer now how this century is going to unfold. So let’s not hang around. Let’s get on with the job of turning east.”

      • Monkey_Bach

        Simple, universal, eternal, and profound. The west has discovered its own pint-sized equivalent of Confucius whose mature genius is manifest.

        I am in awe.

        Eeek.

        • Mike Homfray

          No doubt he got a research assistant minion to write it, paid for by his millions in his former ‘career’ as a bankster

Latest

  • News Miliband: Labour will close down job agencies that exploit workers

    Miliband: Labour will close down job agencies that exploit workers

    Ed Miliband will pledge to close down job agencies that exploit workers and break the law on the minimum wage. This will include closing the Swedish Derogation – a loophole in EU law that allows employers to pay agency workers less than permanent employees, even if they are doing the same job. Miliband will also reiterate that a next Labour government would stop agencies from recruiting workers only from abroad. As it stands, roughly 350,000 people receive less than the […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Unpaid internships aren’t just bad for young people, they hurt us all

    Unpaid internships aren’t just bad for young people, they hurt us all

    It won’t take a trawl of internet job boards to find one of the most frustrating barriers to social mobility at the moment. Lists of unpaid ‘internships’ for as long as six months that give lists of responsibilities, essential skills needed and stipulations on the days and number of hours you will ‘ideally’ be working. If you’re lucky, you’ll get travel expenses within London, and maybe even lunch. Some employers call their roles ‘volunteer’ positions in an attempt to avoid […]

    Read more →
  • Featured The signals and the noise: the next election remains wide open

    The signals and the noise: the next election remains wide open

    David Cameron is arguably in a worse position than Jesus was on the eve of the crucifixion. Christ was denied three times by Peter. But Dave went to Rochester and Strood on five occasions and still he got the thumbs down. And that’s why the only story this weekend was the continued flatlining of the Tory opinion poll rating as the party struggles in vain to… But no. That wasn’t the story, was it? Instead there has been Labour angst, […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Labour can change the false narrative with a reality check

    Labour can change the false narrative with a reality check

    A false narrative has developed about Labour that must be rejected comprehensively by a party aiming to govern in six months. It claims that Labour has become alienated from virtually the entire electorate. Our response to date has been ineffective. Here are some suggestions for how we may succeed in future. Franklin D. Roosevelt said: “the only thing we have to fear is fear itself”. We should take heed and refuse to be cowed by something as illusory as a […]

    Read more →
  • News Labour consider selling off central London buildings to help pay off debts

    Labour consider selling off central London buildings to help pay off debts

    The Labour leadership say they would consider selling off QEII Conference Centre and the Civil Service Club – alongside two other buildings in London – to help pay off the country’s debt. They say they selling off these government-owned buildings could raise up to £100m, and would be part of a “fairer way” of reducing the deficit. Alongside selling off the QEII conference centre and the Civil Service Club, Labour are also thinking about selling Marlborough House, which is near Buckingham […]

    Read more →