Alan Milburn’s final report on youth unemployment, published yesterday, is built on the maxim “work for those who can, security for those who cannot”. It would give every young person a legal right to an opportunity to earn or learn and the support to take it up, in return for a duty to engage. With nearly a million young people not earning or learning, Labour should back a deal like that. But a decade researching insecurity with residents in east London tells me the maxim gets the order wrong for young people, because a guarantee only works if their lives are secure enough for them to take it up. They need security first.
Security first
Milburn’s plan would rebalance a system that spends £25 on benefits for every £1 on helping young people into work or study. Under-25s would move from the health element of Universal Credit onto a single Youth Allowance, and from Personal Independence Payment onto a new allowance for extra costs. Those who persistently refuse to engage could ultimately lose their Youth Allowance. He rightly says crude cuts “work neither fiscally nor morally”, but admits the changes will not be “pain-free” and that some young people could get less support at the start of a claim, which is exactly when they are least secure.
Milburn’s own look at reforms abroad shows why the order matters, finding that where they faltered, “it was often because employment support was not in place before benefit change”. His report promises that support will come first, and that promise has to hold when the Treasury comes looking for the £3.6 billion a year of welfare savings he expects by 2036/37. The prime minister, Andy Burnham, has called the review a watershed moment. If security comes first, the guarantee becomes the best story this government has to tell about opportunity. Get the order wrong and it becomes a story about punishment.
Cognitive taxation
Security matters because insecurity takes something from young people long before any sanction arrives. At UCL’s Institute for Global Prosperity we call it cognitive taxation, the constant drain on attention and planning that comes from juggling rent and bills while wondering whether there will be enough shifts next week. It leaves little headspace for a college course or a first job, and the fear of losing benefits only adds to it. Milburn himself writes that “insecurity has become a persistent backdrop to work, study and independence”. In 2025, one in eight young workers was on a zero-hours contract.
Nor does that insecurity stop once a young person finds work, and Milburn cites a survey in which 54 percent of young people in work had considered quitting in the past year. Our Secure Livelihoods Index found that the most insecure employees take home around £500 a month less than otherwise similar colleagues, roughly £6,000 a year, partly because they tend to get fewer hours. That penalty roughly doubles when insecurity lasts seven years, and the lowest paid are hit hardest.
In east London, Leyton had the highest income and work security of the 15 neighbourhoods we studied, yet its residents also reported the highest debt and financial stress. Separate research by our institute found that when people’s finances worsen, their hourly pay falls and does not recover when things improve. That is why any dip in support at the start of a claim matters, and why protecting young people’s income while they move into work is as important as the offer itself.
Security guaranteed?
The guarantee should therefore be judged by whether young people end up in work they can build a life around, rather than by how many places are filled. Milburn is right to measure success in sustained work. Yet he wants a “cautionary principle” applied to Labour’s guaranteed-hours rules, in case they put firms off hiring young people. That caution has to cut both ways when insecure hours are part of what pushes young people out of work.
He is also right that opportunity “is experienced on a bus route”, and his plan would put mayors in charge of a new Youth Opportunity Service and let young people keep more of what they earn. Every young person’s Participation Plan should deal with whatever is stopping them taking up an offer, from bus fares to rent arrears, and mayors should be free to fund that help, because the mix of insecurities varies sharply from place to place.
Milburn describes the Youth Allowance as “basic financial security provided alongside opportunity and support, never instead of them”. That principle should run through the whole guarantee. Security for those who cannot work is only half the job, and if Labour builds it in for those who can, the guarantee could be one of the best things this government does.