Russia is conducting concerted and increasingly audacious attacks on western democracies. The recent attacks on Ireland, with hoax bomb threats ahead of the European summit in Dublin, join a litany of attempts to disrupt the west’s businesses and critical infrastructure. A recent report from the House of Commons Library states ‘such threats are not new, but they are becoming more sophisticated and intense, facilitated by the pace of technological change’.
‘Putin Tax’
Putin’s war on the west is designed to undermine our morale, test our defences, and stretch resources, all with a degree of plausible deniability, and just under the threshold of traditional armed conflict. In January 2025, the former head of MI6 Sir Alex Younger described this hybrid threat as “everything that stays below the threshold of war…from disinformation to sabotage to cyber or economic coercion… [whatever] offers the adversary the opportunity to achieve its security objectives in a way that is short of armed conflict”.
Graeme Downie MP’s excellent report on “the Putin Tax” – estimated an annual cost to British taxpayers, businesses and public services of Russian, sabotage, critical infrastructure threats and other forms of hostile state-activity of £2-£2.5 billion. This is probably much higher now, and set to increase.
Downie also writes that over 300 Russia-linked cyber incidents affecting UK companies have been identified since 2022. A recent wave of cyberattacks that superheated supermarket fridges and bomb hoaxes against airports and planes across Europe indicate our vulnerability. A security company says Russia could direct a “destructive cyberattack” on European energy or heating systems this winter. There are also fears that attacks could knock out our railways for a week.
Disinformation and misinformation
One of the most powerful and relatively cheap tools in the Russian arsenal is disinformation and misinformation: cognitive warfare to promote divisive narratives, including on Ukraine and migration, that distort our perceptions and soften our resolve.
The scale of the threat means that Europe’s leaders must inform their populations, but without creating panic. The latest warning is from Air Chief Marshal Sir Richard Knighton, chief of the defence staff, who told the Financial Times that Britain needed to “catch up with our European allies”, that Moscow’s “appetite” for risk “has quite clearly grown”, and that the term “hybrid activity” no longer did justice to the gravity of its actions. Knighton says that “This is the most dangerous period I’ve known in my adult life . . . That threat — principally from Russia, but more broadly globally — is rising.”
Estonia’s interior minister Igor Taro also told the Financial Times that Russian acts of aggression in Europe should be considered “state-sponsored terrorism” rather than hybrid incidents, which is too soft a word. Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk has warned that it is difficult to differentiate between hybrid war, cyber war and provocations at Europe’s borders with Russia.
The dangers of disruption and climate emergencies such as flooding underpin the British government’s Be Ready campaign urging us to prepare for three days without vital public services such as power, banking, and the internet.
The message is accompanied by advocating rearmament that returns us to Cold War levels of defence spending and recently saw Wes Streeting opening the first arms factory in Britain in many years.
Popular support for Ukraine remains strong and underpins rearmament because defeat for Ukraine will encourage Russian aggression. The name of the game is deterrence. We don’t savour the need to spend billions more on defence, but if deterrence fails we will end up spending considerably more.
George Robertson’s Strategic Defence Review sets out the government’s plan, and enshrines the commitment to attain defence spending of 3 percent of GDP by 2030 before reaching 3.5 percent plus 1.5 percent on related infrastructure by 2035. Graeme Downie MP, Polly Billington MP, and others argue that the plan for 3 percdent should be frontloaded in next year’s spending review.
Strength maintains peace
The rationale for increased defence spending must be explained in simple terms and without the usual confusing defence sector jargon. We need to spell out the central concept that military strength and readiness maintains peace, and weakness encourages conflict. This is the founding principle of NATO. Of course the public demand value for money and safeguards against profligate and inefficient procurement. As Labour, we should also point out the concomitant economic benefits of increased defence spending, creating and sustaining UK industrial jobs and apprenticeships. Ministers have rightly been at pains to link defence with reindustrialisation and economic growth.
So far, organised opposition to rearmament has come from the usual suspects whose superficial statements don’t add up. The Stop the War group ludicrously proclaims that Western leaders are addicted to war. Others more understandably argue we should first right social injustices, but our enemies won’t wait for us to fix domestic deficiencies.
The Labour movement is rusty about defence, which is not surprising given decades of the peace dividend that followed the end of the Cold War in the early 1990s. We cannot ignore the descent towards war and must prevent war through deterrence to defend our continent.
Bipartisan support can sustain a whole society approach to our national security. It’s time for the Conservatives and others to form counterparts to Labour Friends of NATO. The warnings of danger ahead – if we fail to deter Russia and others – are ever clearer but we need informed party and public consent.