Advertisement — responsive 970x250
Photo: Welsh Labour

For we’re a jolly good fellowship

Welsh Labour has modelled how to rebuild our fellowship with honesty, humility and and hope.

Sorry used to be the hardest word in politics. But after the disastrous result for Labour in the Welsh Senedd elections in May, it was the start of the conversation new Welsh Labour leader Ken Skates wants to have with his electorate.

Skate’s speech was, for me, the highlight of the Welsh Labour conference that Daniel Green and I were delighted to attend this weekend. Look out later this week on our YouTube channel (don’t forget to subscribe to be immediately notified of all updates) for my interview with Skates (and others), where I focus on three words he used: “sorry”, “meaningful” and “fellowship.”

I was particularly taken by the latter – fellowship. This isn’t a term I have heard a lot in my time as a Labour member. We often describe ourselves as a family (having moved away from the more gendered “brotherhood”), we often talk of solidarity – but a fellowship is not a term often used about being part of Labour. Skates – who put the term front and centre of his speech – is clearly aiming to change this.

Something bigger than ourselves

As a wordsmith, I often think deeply about how and why we choose the words we do. Fellowship is a term often used in religious (and especially Christian) thought  – and this may well be a harking back to the kind of religious-style language of Labour’s past (I am thinking particularly of the famous quote that “Labour owes more to Methodism than to Marxism”). There is much about being a Labour member that echoes being a member of a faith group. We believe in something bigger than ourselves and we give service to our fellow human beings in aid of that bigger cause.

But for me, as someone who first read The Lord of the Rings while in primary school and adored the Peter Jackson films as an adult, it is a word inextricably linked with these books about a band of disparate fellows who come from different backgrounds – often with deep historical quarrels with each other (Labour’s factional infighting has nothing on the beef between dwarves and elves). Again here there are great parallels for Labour. We are a group of people of different races, religions, and often cultural beliefs. But we all believe in the bigger project of improving our society and economy so that it works for everyone. We have come together in fellowship to dedicate our lives to making that happen. 

 

But it wasn’t this speech that set the tone for the conference, but the report that immediately preceded it. And Skates started his speech with a clear and unequivocal apology. 

Honesty, transparency and hope

Saying sorry and offering critical self-reflection is often the hardest thing for any of us to do. Harder still for those who are asking to lead. So I am really heartened by the approach that Welsh Labour took to turn over every stone when it came to this review. I spoke to a number of delegates and Welsh Labour members at the conference who all spoke of the spaces and paths that had been created for them as individuals and at ward and CLP level to feed into the report. All felt that their voices had been heard and the difficult messages of the report had not blunted the tough feedback they had given.

There is hope in the report, with a real sense that – with hard work, dedication and, yes, fellowship – there is an opportunity for Welsh Labour to reset its relationship with Welsh voters. And the transparent and honest way that the party in Wales has approached this report speaks well of how they will approach implementing its recommendations. 

Labour may only be at the foothills of its fightback in Wales. But what I saw in Llandudno was that there may yet be again a welcome in those hillsides. And the work to achieve that will be the responsibility of all Welsh Labour members. And they will need the support of and fellowship of all of us to do it. 

I came away from the conference feeling surprisingly optimistic about the state of the Party in Wales. Everyone I spoke to was aware of the challenge they face but spoke to me with a hope and determination to do so head-on. The first test of this will come in the local elections in May next year. LabourList will be working hard to support them and report back on their progress. For now we wish them pob lwc.

Subscribe