A few weeks ago the PM wrote about the importance of discussing an apology for slavery. He said this should not entail a burdensome increase in aid to the countries affected, mainly in the Caribbean, but he did want to look at further cooperation on climate finance and debt rescheduling. At the subsequent meeting of the Commonwealth Heads of Government he was accompanied to CHOGM by Gordon Brown who will consider how to do this.
A major reset in our relations with the Caribbean countries would be very welcome. This should include tackling the tax havens in the British Overseas Territories (BOTS)and Crown Dependencies.
Tax evasion, sanctions avoidance and money laundering
Eight years ago Parliament forced the Tory Government into two major climbdown as it legislated on introducing ‘Magnitsky’ Sanctions for human rights abusers, since used against Russian oligarchs and by taking the power to require the British Overseas Territories and Crown Dependencies to establish open registers of beneficial ownership. The revelations of the Panama papers showed how the rich “stash their cash” in brassplate companies where the ownership cannot be traced in order to avoid paying tax. The Tax Justice Network have estimated the global tax loss from the use of tax havens is $492 billion and the UK loss £33 billion.
But tax evasion is not the only problem – the secrecy also facilitates sanctions busting (eg by the Russians) and the laundering of money which is the proceeds of crime. But the Tories almost immediately delayed implementation of these sections of the Act, which now lie on the statute book waiting to be switched on. It is, perhaps, not surprising that the Tories avoided acting given their own financial links to the City of London, but the Labour Government should act as part of its reset with the Caribbean.
Some of the BOTS, Montserrat, St Helena and Gibraltar, have progressed this. Others, notably the British Virgin Islands which is the most significant in any case, have not.
It would be naive to think tax revenues would immediately jump by £33 billion were this to happen, but undoubtedly there would be significant gains. One argument against acting has been that some of the BOTS have no other viable economic activity. Rescheduling debt, and perhaps even using a proportion of the extra tax revenues to invest in new activities, would be a win-win for both the UK and the Caribbean. It would be a gain to ordinary British taxpayers, to the Caribbean and the price would be paid by the super rich and international criminals.
Next year the UK holds the Presidency of the G20. As part of this we will be hosting a summit on illicit finance. The Foreign Office have set out the aims of the summit as action on crypto (also a way of hiding the proceeds of crime); on the illegal gold trade (which is being used to finance war in the Sudan) and the use of property to hide illicit cash. This last should be extended to action on secret share registers and tax havens.
Inextricably linked
We have the legislation and can act quickly. The Foreign Office under Ed Miliband has already shown that by taking the initiative it can build international coalitions for action as it has done on the West Bank – it can do so here.
Of course this is a policy that is of almost greater interest to the Treasury who are under constant pressure to find more money for worthwhile investments such as defence and tacking the NEETs crisis. Here is a policy that will rake in more money without burdening ordinary people or harming business incentives in the UK.
In his Mansion House speech the Prime Minister said he wanted to lead a government led by our values and in our interests. The Caribbean may be a long way from Makerfield, but as we were 200 years ago, so now we are inextricably linked – so this surely passes the Makerfield test.