Cameron’s Europe speech – Labour reactions

January 23, 2013 11:44 am

Following David Cameron’s Europe speech this morning, we’ll be bringing you a selection oft he Labour responses throughout the day to the speech.

Update: Tony Blair on a possible EU exit:

“There’s got to be a compelling reason to put that question on the agenda. I don’t see that compelling reason.”

Douglas Alexander, speaking to Sky News, doesn’t rule out Labour backing a referendum at some point:

“Labour doesn’t think that is a decision that we could or would sensibly make at the moment, the priority should be the stability, investment, jobs that we have been speaking about. We have never ruled out the possibility of a referendum in the future, because in international affairs you should never say never, on the other hand, given the changes that are being contemplated in Europe at the moment. We think the priority should be to get on and shape those changes but at the same time send a very clear signal to Business that Britain is looking for business. Alas, that wasn’t the signal that David Cameron was able to send today. 

“Rather than burning bridges and breaking up alliances, we will be building bridges and winning friends. For example, in just a couple of weeks time there are important negotiations in the European Union budget, we want to see both restraint and reform in the EU budget, but to achieve that you need to win allies. At the same time you want to see a greater priority placed on growth across the EU than has been the case to date. We want to see change, for example, in the Common Agricultural policy, in a speech last week I talked about some of the transitional controls for the new countries coming into the European Union. Of course, change is needed in European and of course change is coming, we just don’t think the Prime Minister has a very coherent strategy for achieving those changes.”

Peter Mandelson told Radio 5 that Cameron should be seeking a “better, stronger Europe”:

“My reaction is that what Mr Cameron should be seeking is a vision of a better, stronger Europe and a new settlement in Europe and for Europe, which we can sort out with our partners in Europe. Instead what he’s really seeking is an entirely different form of membership for Britain in Europe, it’s an ultimatum with a deadline without him saying at the end of the day whether he will recommend that Britain should stay in the European Union, and I think that were we to come out on that basis of the European Union it would have very serious negative economic consequences for our country.”

And Labour’s leader in the European Parliament Glenis Willmott said:

“If David Cameron is serious about reform in the EU, he should start by rebuilding the bridges he’s burnt down in the past. He says in his speech today that the European Union needs to change with the times, and that’s exactly why Labour MEPs have successfully worked hard to build alliances and work with colleagues to try and reform areas of the EU like the Budget and CAP,” she continued. Of course the EU isn’t perfect, but talking about referenda just creates uncertainty and costs British jobs – it doesn’t help reform the EU. All Mr. Cameron has achieved is to put the needs of the Tory party before British jobs and what is in the British interest.”

  • JoeDM

    I notice that you did not include Gisela Stuart’s views in the list above. Too “off message” for Ed ?

  • AlanGiles

    We were talking about Blairism and Blairites on LL yesterday, and Mark Ferguson said that Blair was now a historical figure.

    If that is so, why canvass the opinon of Peter Mandelson. Does anybody give a toss what he thinks about anything?

  • Hugh

    Should read: “Former EU commissioner Peter Mandelson, whose £31,000 a year pension (for four years work) when he reaches the age of 65 years is contingent on abiding by his continuing “duty of loyalty to the Communities”, said…

  • AlanGiles

    ” Tony Blair on a possible EU exit:

    “There’s got to be a compelling reason to put that question on the agenda. I don’t see that compelling reason.”

    Especially as he still harbours hopes of becoming the new King of the EU!.

  • Hugh

    Given the sovereign debt crisis, replacement of governments in the likes of Italy, riots in Greece and elsewhere, a new explicit commitment to fiscal and political union, and polls showing 40% wanting to leave what exactly would constitute a “compelling reason” for a referendum – war with France?

    • http://twitter.com/youngian67 Ian Young

      The latest YouGov poll now shows a six per cent lead for staying in the EU
      http://bit.ly/10fMTrG
      No anti Euro party has gained any traction in Italy, Spain, Greece or Ireland and it is none of the business of a UK referendum. By the way what happened to the Grexit that every Eurosceptic bore told us was imminent for the past three years.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Daniel-Smith/516168738 Daniel Smith

    I second Glenys, I heard her speak about Europe and was converted. We do need Europe, and we need to keep paying into Europe; this might sound niave but it is a lot more secure than Cameron running around trying to negotiate a sweetener for the UK.

  • Pingback: Spot the difference: Labour might back a referendum – Greens do back a referendum | Hynd's Blog

Latest

  • Comment Should Labour offer a referendum on the EU?

    Should Labour offer a referendum on the EU?

    The EU question has never been far from earshot in the build up to and subsequent fallout from the recent European elections. Many might well be sick of the arguments by now, but they are likely to come back with a vengeance as the general election draws nearer. The EU debate offers a chance for Labour to carve out a stance that separates them from the Conservatives as well as the Liberal Democrats. And if Labour were take a clear […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Scotland Salmond bests Darling – but the bully boy still can’t answer the basic questions

    Salmond bests Darling – but the bully boy still can’t answer the basic questions

    So with only a few weeks to go until the biggest day in Scotland’s history, Alex Salmond was the victor in last night’s televised debate. He shouted, he hectored, he obfuscated. But the polls clearly showed he was the winner. Indeed, his victory was a clear cut one, whilst Darling’s previous victory was more marginal. Whether or not it will have an impact on the polls remains to be seen (early evidence suggests it won’t), but Salmond performed markedly better than […]

    Read more →
  • News Tories rely on millions from secretive clubs as membership plummets in marginals

    Tories rely on millions from secretive clubs as membership plummets in marginals

    More than half of the money raised for the Tories in many of their key seats come from donations made by unincorporated associations – who do not have to declare where their money comes from. Since the last election, over £5.5million has been given to the Conservative Party from these private clubs and business groups. Harriet Harman will today highlight these figures in a speech in London, where she will point out that analysis of the Tories accounts shows that membership […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Labour’s successful summer (the story you won’t read in the papers)

    Labour’s successful summer (the story you won’t read in the papers)

    The story of this summer holiday season is one the media won’t be reporting because it doesn’t fit their narrative about Ed Miliband and Labour – that Labour had a good summer and used what is traditionally the political off-season to consolidate its position. Traditionally the summer is the “silly season” when the press are short of stories and seize on minor gaffes and squabbles to fill pages. The classic example of this is when John Prescott was left in charge […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Labour needs to take a serious look at UKIP’s manifesto

    Labour needs to take a serious look at UKIP’s manifesto

    UKIP are in the process of putting together a manifesto that is squarely targeted at disaffected Labour voters. In a number of constituencies Labour’s vote is tottering. If UKIP get their pitch right, it could be like giving a shaking ladder a firm kick. Normal people, to the extent they are aware them, consider manifestos as reading material on a par with phone books. And they are right. Especially when the people putting them together brutalise the English language with […]

    Read more →