Advertisement — responsive 970x250
Photo: Lauren Hurley / No 10 Downing Street

A NEET reset

A generational crisis will need a generational investment – but can Burnham and the Treasury find the money and keep sceptical Labour MPs on side?

The long-awaited Milburn review into the NEETs crisis is finally being published today, setting out a “system reset” to avoid a “lost generation” and bring young people back into work, education or training.

At its core is the argument that the current system fails both young people and the taxpayer – and that slashing away at the welfare bill without investment elsewhere solves nothing. The review notes that in 2024/25, for every pound spent on helping young people into work or education, £25 was spent on youth benefits. The report says that, within the next decade, that ratio should be cut to 2:1.

That will mean a significant “downpayment” to fund the extensive reforms Milburn proposes; putting more emphasis on work skills in the curriculum, instant access to mental health support without diagnosis, and cuts to employer National Insurance contributions for young workers to name a few.

It’s a cost that falls on a government already strapped for cash. Although the cost of doing nothing is considerably greater in the long term, it doesn’t make the question for Burnham and the Treasury about where the money will come from now any easier.

The Prime Minister also has to face a second balancing act politically, with a PLP still bruised from Keir Starmer’s attempt at welfare reform. There are already MPs expressing concern at any prospect of tightening benefit eligibility for under-25s, particularly those with disabilities or health conditions, while there will be others who may question whether the proposals do enough to cut the welfare bill.

Ultimately, the challenge for the Prime Minister will be to prove that he can grasp the nettle of welfare reform in a way that isn’t branded as punitive or as an expensive sticking plaster. Tackling long-standing problems, which are decades in the making, has been a cornerstone of Burnham’s premiership to date. The question now is whether he and his government can afford to spend the financial and political capital to take on the scale of the NEETs crisis.

Subscribe