Advertisement — responsive 970x250
Photo: Simon Dawson / No 10 Downing Street

‘What does ending neoliberalism mean?’

Burnham can't end neoliberalism unless he explains what it is an why it has done such damage.

Hundreds more criminals have just left prison early to ease overcrowding. If any end up committing appalling, high-profile crimes, this government could be finished. Andy Burnham’s future therefore rests on effective tagging. And yet thousands of offenders “may not be actively monitored”, according to the National Audit Office in July. It said  “poor” performance by Serco meant offenders weren’t tagged on time in Labour’s first year; delays have fallen since but as of February, nearly two in five tag-fitting visits somehow failed.

That’s the same merry band of outsourcers whose subsidiary once “cooked their books” running similar services, pocketing millions owed to taxpayers, as court documents put it. It invented £500,000 a month of “fictitious” equipment, staff and other costs, handily cutting profits and thus money owed under a government clawback clause.

When Burnham talks of ending neoliberalism, it’s that case my mind wanders to. Neoliberalism plausibly explains why New Labour let a private firm handle public safety and signed off generous profits (14 percent plus half anything above it), why company law pays only lip service to social duties, and why parts of a listed company might feel so pressured to enrich shareholders that even those high margins didn’t cut it.

Burnham can never achieve his aim without public backing. He’ll never get that unless he explains what neoliberalism is, and what the problem is. That explanation’s been strangely lacking. Four-fifths of the public don’t understand the word, so better language would be a start.

What neoliberalism is and why it’s a problem

For me, neoliberalism means using the state to commodify as much of life as possible. It’s the belief progress only happens when things are freely bought and sold, guided by profit and price alone, and so state protections and services, social norms and values are market constraints to be stripped away. It’s a monumental, relentless force, holding almost unparalleled sway in economic thinking and transforming countries worldwide for half a century. The transformation’s now so entrenched it feels inevitable to the old and imperceptible to the young.

And what’s the problem? State protections and services, social norms and values do constrain markets  – but that makes many of them a critical ‘force field’ Labour must champion, protect and build, not ignore. At least occasionally we should highlight bulwarks beyond the NHS – the weekends, annual leave, minimum wages, pensions and union rights and power many take for granted at work; the rules and enforcement that keep roads, workplaces and food mostly safe; the public parks, footpaths and beaches we enjoy. Unchecked, neoliberalism would erode them all. Just look at what many countries lack, or our hard-fought gains here since the slums, cholera-filled sewage and 12-hour shifts in pits and fields for five-year-olds in 19th century Britain.

Or highlight what we’ve lost. Dismantling market ‘constraints’ since the 1980s has deepened poverty, unemployment and inequality the world over. For the past forty years, UK poverty’s been at least 50 percent higher than the late 1960s, and in recent years even the patchy, debt-fuelled GDP growth neoliberalism bequeathed has dried up too. 

Why aren’t more in Labour explaining this? And that it’s no surprise free markets often work best for the highest bidder, helping wealth generate more wealth than work. It’s no surprise the top 1 percent’s share of national income has tripled since Margaret Thatcher let neoliberalism rip. It’s no surprise many of the wealthy and powerful backed her and have backed neoliberalism since. They had only made peace with Britain’s unprecedented mid-century welfare state and levelling of incomes out of fear of Thirties-style recession and of communism. By the 1970s they risked “annihilation” as growth and profits floundered, inflation ate their wealth and radical movements gained ground. The “restoration of class power” they’ve enjoyed is unarguable, even if you doubt their co-ordination or cynicism.

Freedom to eat at the Ritz, invest in global markets or live free of state and societal pressures works nicely for the elite, but it doesn’t feed the poor. Good jobs, tax-funded social security and community do. Nor do many hotels, restaurants and the wider economy thrive without the state policing of crime, product safety and fair competition, or state funding of the roads, transport, education and healthcare that workers rely on.

Action and thus explanation is most critical in public services – by definition those we once thought too risky in private hands. Too many outsourced, marketised and privatised services have underdelivered, cut corners, shunned harder tasks, overcharged, extracted undue profits for shareholders and prioritised narrow contractual duties over humanity, common sense or broader public benefits.  This is the neoliberal pattern over four decades, too common to be coincidence. It’s caterers giving children paltry food parcels in lockdown and PFI firms ripping off schools and neglecting buildings, and probation or child maintenance payment services neglecting pressing but harder cases. Outsourcing has worked in some areas and public ownership or control aren’t panaceas, but the balance requires serious thought government-wide.

Labour’s strange silence on good and bad business

Yet oddly, Burnham has said little on outsourcing beyond care, and little of neoliberalism’s pitfalls across public services or the wider economy beyond his powerful ‘public control’ narrative on utilities, transport and housing. Anti-outsourcing policies cover only central government, not the NHS or councils where it’s rife; procurement policies aimed at driving up business standards oddly exempt SMEs.

He’s said little of unions and their new access rights as another bulwark. Most strangely, he’s said little of what ‘good’ business, investors and customers look like, delineating it from the ruthless, uncaring and unrestrained pursuit of wealth alone. Policy ideas to encourage good business practice seem sparse, missing a trick to tame neoliberalism. Instead senior figures flit awkwardly between praising business and profit and bashing them. Limited clarity and positivity therefore risks alienating many businesses that might otherwise acquiesce or become allies in reining in cowboys, asset strippers, monopolies and the other unacceptable faces of capitalism.

The strange silence can’t all be limited or pessimistic ambition, fear of unsettling investors and firms, focus on today’s many problems beyond neoliberalism or a desire not to look stuck in the past (though those are all understandable). If those were all true, Burnham wouldn’t have dared utter “neoliberalism” and John Healey’s conference speech wouldn’t have referenced miners more than companies or technology.

So if Burnham is serious, he needs a more fleshed-out narrative and programme, readying the public for real change by explaining neoliberalism and its pitfalls, simply and consistently. Otherwise ‘ending neoliberalism’ may end up just another major failed government promise, and perhaps Andy Burnham just another rejected Labour leader. Warning outsourcers tasked with helping stop criminals re-offending that they’re in the last-chance saloon might be a good place to start.

Subscribe