For a few years now, it’s been near impossible to travel through Westminster without bumping into a talking head banging on about how young, disillusioned men are falling for the hard right.
We have been repeatedly warned about a process that saw them hanging out in chatrooms, taking a well-trodden path from disgruntled social media users to Farage fanboys to Incel warriors.
All of which was – and is – based on a few bumps and lumps in polling, a lot of hearsay and frankly terrifying pictures of young white fascists beamed over to Blighty from the US.
Most of this discourse failed to mention one important fact: that the young men in question are often so out of touch with society that they’re almost impossible to engage in qualitative political research.
Which was why earlier this year PF Global, a London-based agency where I am a partner, launched a project to go and meet these voters (or non-voters) where they actually are. I’m talking about the city of Los Santos.
Never heard of it? Think this is a hoax? Then you’re probably over the age of 40 and, more likely than not, a woman. Los Santos is the fictional city around which the most recent Grand Theft Auto revolves.
The PF team went online, started gaming, and, much as they would in Hartlepool or Crewe, began chatting to the people they met about their lives, local issues and politics. Over the course of several months and very many long evenings fuelled by junk food and soft drinks the team honed their virtual drive-by skills while simultaneously winning the trust of more than a hundred young men who had never previously discussed their politics with pretty much anyone.
Lacking hope and lost in a cycle of decline
What PF found was rather less dramatic than the characterisation of a bunch of manosphere keyboard warriors. They found a large demographic section of our society who, in essence, could not find any kind of hope in the towns and small cities that they lived in, places locked in a cycle of post-industrial decline.
There were undoubtedly those who were tempted by the dog whistles of the far right, with Rupert Lowe and Restore coming up worryingly often.
But this was not a nest of incels egging each other on to more and more radically right wing views. In fact, the politics of this group was much more aligned with the views of their non-gaming friends and neighbours in the corners of so-called Left Behind Britain.
The shadow of long-term unemployment was omnipresent and the nearest they got to having firm opinions centred on the cost of living – specifically the price of petrol – and the absence of the kinds of jobs and apprenticeships that they wanted to do. They were often deeply resistant to the idea of working in a fast food joint or call centres.
All of which leads me to Alan Milburn.
As I ploughed through all 250 pages of the Milburn Review on Monday night, two nagging questions kept popping into my head. The first was whether it had been written by AI and the second was whether the proposals being promoted really could shift the needle on long term youth unemployment.
On the first question the jury would still seem to be out, but on the second our recent GTA research sheds a little light. And the answer is not particularly cheering. While the idea of a doubling or even trebling of the number of apprenticeships (as proposed by Milburn) would undoubtedly be welcomed, the Neets whiling away their days/weeks/months on GTA that we spoke to were not desperate to have their hands held as they navigated a way out of their bedrooms and back into work
Decent towns, decent jobs, decent pay, decent lives
In fact, what they really just wanted was a decent town, with stuff to do, and decent jobs, with decent pay that allowed them to improve the quality of their lives. In essence, they want and need a raft of things outside the Milburn’s remit.
But these things do sit squarely in the prime minister’s promise to achieve good growth in every postcode – and ensuring that growth is felt in genuinely tangible ways.
It’s not that complicated, really. Want to stop the drift of young men towards aimlessness and potentially the lure of the far right? Then build an economy that creates jobs in places where they are needed most and that pay a decent salary. Ideally make sure their hometown doesn’t feel like it’s becoming a desolate wasteland.
It’s all about economic and industrial policy; everything else is window-dressing.