Home

Debate reaction – 8 in the morning, April 16th

8am

By Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

* Nick Clegg stole the first debate by offering himself up as a fresh alternative in an “electrifying, fast-moving” broadcast, says the Guardian.

* The Times says this was a “gladatorial battle for the modern age”.

* Clegg wins on style, Brown on substance, Cameron on shallowness, says Alastair Campbell.

* No knock-out blow or disastrous gaffe, but Clegg wins through, says the Independent.

* The Telegraph goes over what was said in the debate, issue by issue.

* Guardian columnists give their views on the TV debate.

* Mike Smithson says that although last night may have hurt the Tories, it could also hurt Labour.

* Nothing fundamental changed last night in the frame of the election as a whole, writes James Crabtree.

* Why has David Cameron ditched his “Broken Britain” mantra?

John Prescott and John Denham give their reaction:

Alex is the founder and CEO of The Cares Family. He was editor and first director of LabourList in 2009-2010, during which time he established the site as the number one Labour blog, and later an aide to Ed Miliband.

View all articles by Alex Smith
Subscribe to our daily email

More from LabourList

DONATE HERE

Do you value LabourList’s coverage? We need your support.

Our independent journalists have been on the ground during this local and by-election campaign, which marks the first key electoral test of Keir Starmer’s government. 

We’ve been out and about with Labour activists and candidates across the country from Bristol to Hull, and will soon be heading to Cambridgeshire and Lancashire – as well as Runcorn and Helsby. We’ve also polled readers for their views on the campaign.

LabourList relies on donations from readers like you to continue its fair, fast, reliable and well-informed news and analysis. We don’t have party funding or billionaire owners. 

If you value what we do, set up a regular donation today.

DONATE HERE