Advertisement — responsive 970x250
Photo: BBC

Is this the start of the end of neoliberalism?

The Milburn report is breathtaking in its political ambition. Say it quietly, but this is a blueprint for ending neoliberalism.

When Andy Burnham said he wanted to end 40 years of neoliberalism, the general reaction from the commentariat was a combination of baffled head scratching and snooty sneering. For far too many, the economic and political settlement set in the 1980s by Margaret Thatcher is not a political choice but a simple reality. This is how it is. You can no more change this than you can stop breathing air.

Yesterday we published a piece by my brilliant predecessor Tom Belger on the need for Andy Burnham to define neoliberalism in order to end it. Tom argues (rightly) that neoliberalism is about the commodification of the state – as demonstrated by so many state services being outsourced despite a litany of failures by the private behemoths that win these contracts.

Reshaping our horizons

Tom is right, but this isn’t, for me, the whole story. The outsourcing of state services is definitely a core symptom of the political philosophy of neoliberalism. But it is more than this. Neoliberalism has – for far too long – completely reshaped what we believe the state can and should do. It has lowered the horizon on which any and all decisions can – or even should – be made.

Neoliberalism is deeply bound up with shareholder primacy – the notion that a company’s first duty is to make short term profits for its shareholders. While neoliberalism is about the state doing less and companies doing more, it is therefore essential to look at what those companies that thrive under this system are like, as they shape the services and economy that define our lives. And it is their constant drive for short term profit that has led to so much of the damage Tom sets out. 

We have all decried ‘Treasury thinking’ over the years. In fact, it was the sense that the attempt to reform welfare under Starmer and Reeves was led not by principle but by spreadsheets that led to those reforms failing. But this too is a symptom of a deeper problem – that the Treasury is not simply captured by the short-termism of neoliberalism but that they can see no possibility of working any other way. This is how it has always been done.

It isn’t. Neoliberalism was a highly radical and deeply controversial shift away from the consensus at the time. It was an experiment with completely rewiring the British economy and the British state. It is now very clear it is an experiment that has failed.

Breathtaking audacious scope

What does this have to do with the Milburn report? Well, what Milburn has set out is almost breathtaking in its audacious scope. And underneath it all are two principles that will fundamentally undermine the neoliberal consensus.

First, this is a report that is deliberately long in its time horizons. It has long been briefed that this will not save money from the welfare bill soon. This is about deeper, longer term changes that will eventually save money but whose core purpose is not to do so – it is to transform lives. That is the sequencing being sold here and it is a fundamental break with the short-termism that governments have long felt inevitable.

Secondly, this is a big reassertion of the state as an enabler of a good society. That is the direct opposite of the philosophy of neoliberalism.

It is perhaps ironic that a man often referred to as an ‘arch Blairite’ is the one who has proposed such sweeping changes to a consensus Blair thrived under (though it is also worth remembering that this moniker was once often ascribed to Andy Burnham. People do grow and change as the circumstances around them change). But Alan Milburn has managed the politics of these changes as deftly as Blair at his peak.

Deft politics

The whole process of this review, from the interim report setting out the problem starkly to the preannouncement of much of what we could expect, has been a masterclass in political communication. And this has been true of how the politics have been managed within Labour.

The argument Milburn consistently makes is not an attempt to answer Tory attacks on the welfare budget but rather to address the question of what welfare is for. Milburn is making a moral pitch to the party and the nation rather than a fiscal pitch to the Treasury or an attempt to ape the penny-pinching of Tories who continue to know the cost of everything and the value of nothing.

He has done this in a way that has brought together most of the Labour Party. In fact, one MP I spoke to yesterday (who is a long way from being a Blairite and was a leading rebel over Starmer’s welfare reforms) told me that Milburn’s performance at the PLP meeting on Monday was one of the most impressive they had ever seen.

The pitch-rolling was just the start of a long process of implementation and, as such, I am pleased that Milburn will continue to be at the heart of the process. We will need this deftness of touch to see through these reforms. There will be some who will look at individual parts of the package that they are uncomfortable with and view them through the lens we all too often fall back on – that of protecting the vulnerable from the worst impacts of the existing system. I believe that would be to miss the point. There is a long road ahead of us, but yesterday, the government did not just show that it can be ambitious for young people who have been failed for far too long. It also showed that the system under which we all assumed we would always live can be challenged. Milburn and Burnham have given us a sense of what ending neoliberalism will look like. It will be up to all of us to take up the challenge of making this a reality. 

Subscribe