If you are reading the Alan Milburn review trying to understand why people can’t find a job, look at why they can’t find love.
Meet Sarah, a 21 year old graduate. You probably know many young people like her, maybe you are one too.
Sarah never stopped trying. Her New Year’s resolution was to put herself out there, and she did, hundreds of times. Only seven responded, all with a “thanks, but no thanks,” which felt more humane than being ghosted outright. She still thinks about them, and it stinks. She feels strung along. All those hours polishing her profile. All that preparation for the first meeting: picking the right outfit, rehearsing her opening lines. She is fantastic; all seven reassured her, just not the right fit, not the right time. What did I do wrong? She wants to plead with them. But there is no point in begging.
Rejection and dejection
She knows each rejection makes the next one more likely. She feels bitterness settling in and her mood deteriorating. She worries people will pick up on her low confidence through the screen before they even meet her.
The apps were meant to make this easier, but it just feels like adding insult to injury. They serve an avalanche of prospects, most of them out of reach, with no way to screen them. Plus, she now has to worry about fakes. Is she talking to a real person or a bot?
It enrages her that people pretend that where you are from and who your parents are doesn’t matter. Of course it does! Anyone who picks you knows your social and family circle are a resource they can tap into too. That’s why some of her simpler classmates got scooped up fast.
Most of her friends who are good at this got experience early on. Usually through friends of friends in high school; that’s the only way. Some also had anxious parents who pushed them since they were teens. She found that too involved back then, robbing them of their fun years, but now she realises the advantage.
At night, she soothes her wounded ego by scrolling, then gets angry at headlines claiming her demographic has given up or doesn’t care. They have no idea how much she wants this, or how hard she’s trying. If the other side is as desperate as the headlines say, why won’t anyone pick her?
She gets angrier still when she gets lumped in with the people she knows who are not even trying. Some people have always made excuses, she knows that. It’s easy to feel sorry for yourself, like life owes you something for nothing just for being born. But she is not a loser, not a liar, not a cheat and how dare those rags suggest that.
People try to put us down
Her parents are convinced she is just being picky. At Sarah’s age, her parents and their peers didn’t get to choose; they accepted the first offer because otherwise they would lose out. But why should she accept being mistreated, given less than she is worth, and live a life devoid of the most basic fulfillment when she knows how good this can feel if you get it right? Has anyone ever thought that maybe she is not the problem? Maybe if she needs the threat of going without to go for it then maybe there is something wrong with the thing itself? The system’s stacked against her; damned if she does, damned if she doesn’t.
She finds her critics comically cynical. The problem is that the gain doesn’t justify the pain. And rather than trying to fix the pain, people try to convince her the pain is temporary,an illusion or even her fault, when she is the one expected to bear it on her own body. She is the realist here!
What is Sarah looking for? A partner or a job? Read her story again with Alan Milburn’s review side by side and you will see that many of the factors keeping young people out of the job market are also holding them back from finding partners.
If you have no experience by the time you graduate, you may be done for life. Nobody wants to train you from scratch, and you reek of desperation. Why would anyone invest in you when so many others are ready to roll? Or when a machine can replace you just as fast? Your role was once considered an asset; now it’s a liability, an expense to be minimised. The lack of loyalty is baked into the deal. The mutual contempt can no longer be hidden. And this is as true of myths about Gen Z dating as they are about the myths about the ‘snowflake’ generation unwilling to work.
Technology rather than freeing young people has worn down their time, confidence and grit. Many in Westminster believe that what’s missing in their life is a bigger stick. That the Sarahs of this world are too incentivised to stay out of work, just like they are incentivised to stay single. But the reverse is also true.