The fight for women’s autonomy continues

3rd July, 2011 11:57 am

By Kate Green MP

One of my very first acts of political activism was as a young student in 1979, when I joined a march of women in Edinburgh against John Corrie MP’s attempt via a private member’s bill to reduce the time limit on abortion from 28 to 20 weeks.

I’d thought the world had changed a lot since then in terms of women’s reproductive and sexual choices. But this parliament has seen some astonishing attacks on women’s autonomy over their bodies.

Conservative MP Nadine Dorries has been leading the charge, first with her Ten-Minute Rule bill to require schools to teach abstinence to teenage girls (not , note, to teenage boys), a bill that secured a majority allowing it to go forward for second reading. To follow that, now she’s tabled amendments to the Health and Social Care bill that would signficantly reduce the ability of organisations which carry out abortions to offer counselling and advice.

Dorries needs to take a careful look at the evidence. Abstinence campaigns don’t work. Education and information are the best means of reducing teenage pregnancy – that approach secured the reductions in teenage conception rates achieved under Labour. In the US, by contrast, a federally-supported, 10-year evaluation of abstinence-only-until-marriage programmes found that these programmes had no impact on youth remaining abstinent, age at first intercourse, number of sexual partners, or condom use.

As to restricting provision of advice on abortion, this will shut out some of the most expert organisations, those with a long track record of supporting women, offering high standards of care, and who absolutely don’t come with an agenda to force a woman to have an abortion. 20% of those receiving abortion counselling from the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, which also carries out abortions, choose not to do so. The support they receive from BPAS helps them to make their own decision. But, crucially, if a woman who’s been advised by such organisations does decide that abortion is the right choice for her to make, she can be confident she’ll have been given full information to make that decision, and will receive the best standards of care.

Dorries is not a lone voice however. I do understand that some of my parliamentary colleagues – and of course some women and men around the country – have deep-rooted ethical and moral objections to abortion. They are of course completely entitled to hold those strong personal views. But personal morality should not be imposed on others outside of the legitimate political process. What’s also deeply worrying therefore is that the government itself is surreptitiously advancing the Dorries agenda – without any real public or parliamentary debate.

First ministers threw BPAS off the sexual health advisory committee – while retaining a place for Life – sauce for the goose but not for the gander which they tried to brush aside. Now we learn that the government is also quietly looking at whether regulations on abortion advice can be changed while avoiding the need for Dorries’ amendments actually having to be debated during the passage of the Health and Social Care bill.

Women do not take a decision to terminate a pregnancy lightly, but when making that decision, they desperately need to know where to turn for advice. In what can be a time of excruciating anxiety, early access to support is vital, and the confidence that advice will be non-judgemental and impartial is essential to give women confidence to seek support. If access to the agencies who can provide high-quality information, advice and care is restricted, we will inevitably see more women desperate but unsure where to turn, bearing children they are ill-prepared or unable to look after, or disappearing into the backstreets. And the most vulnerable, the youngest, poorest and least-well educated women will be those who are at greatest risk.

So thirty two years after I first took to the streets, I’m shocked and distressed to find myself having to return to the fight. Women, and men, who want to halt yet another of this government’s repeated attacks on women’s autonomy must not let these proposals go unchecked.

Latest

  • Comment Featured Local Government Scotland Triumph in London and despair elsewhere: Corbyn looks safe for now

    Triumph in London and despair elsewhere: Corbyn looks safe for now

    Do you have a spring in your step today or simply a sprain in your ankle? After weeks of campaigning around Britain, Labour activists will this weekend slump into the bars or on to the sofa as MPs battle to put their seal on the identity of the real winners and losers from Super Thursday. Jeremy Corbyn defied expectations in English council elections but Labour suffered another dire defeat in Scotland and found its grip on power in Wales slightly […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Jon Trickett: In Jeremy Corbyn’s first national test, we have beaten the Tories

    Jon Trickett: In Jeremy Corbyn’s first national test, we have beaten the Tories

    Back in April, I wrote on LabourList that “we should be looking for Labour to advance on the 2015 election results, where we finished almost seven per cent points behind the Conservatives.” According to the BBC’s projection, Labour has now closed that 7 point gap and achieved a one point lead across the country in yesterday’s elections. That means that in the first national test of Jeremy Corbyn’s Labour, we have beaten the Tories. It certainly represents progress, but it […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Local Government Seats and Selections Uncategorized Burnham considering a run for Manchester mayor – so should he stay or go?

    Burnham considering a run for Manchester mayor – so should he stay or go?

    Andy Burnham is considering seeking the Labour nomination for the contest to be Manchester mayor, it emerged last night. The new post will be part of George Osborne’s “devolution revolution” settlement with Greater Manchester, which will see a host of powers for health, transport and planning handed to the region. Burnham is staying in the shadow Cabinet for now but, as he weighs up several approaches from local MPs, here are five reasons to stand for the mayoralty and five more […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Local Government News Scotland Wales Liveblog: Labour holds Salford mayoralty as hopes rise for Sadiq Khan

    Liveblog: Labour holds Salford mayoralty as hopes rise for Sadiq Khan

    We want to hear from Labour activists and supporters today so please send us your stories and pictures [email protected] The pick of the submissions will be added to the liveblog. 18.09: All of the constituency Assembly Members have now been elected, with Labour up one to nine AMs. They are: Jennette Arnold North East Leonie Cooper Merton & Wandsworth Unmesh Desai City & East Andrew Dismore Barnet & Camden Len Duvall Greenwich & Lewisham Florence Eshalomi Lambeth & Southwark Joanne […]

    Read more →
  • Featured Local Government News Corbyn: We are fighting inequality and forcing the Tories into u-turns

    Corbyn: We are fighting inequality and forcing the Tories into u-turns

    Jeremy Corbyn and his senior allies have launched a fightback after Labour failed to make a breakthrough in English local elections and suffered another meltdown in Scotland. Corbyn delivered an impassioned speech in Sheffield, where he attacked the Tories over their failure to deal with the steel crisis, condemned the running down of the NHS and challenged David Cameron to tackle tax avoidance. The Labour leader was in Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough to congratulate Gill Furniss (above), one of two new Labour […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit