Britain needs a National Childcare Service

March 19, 2012 11:25 am

By Calum Sherwood and Cat Smith

There’s been a lot of talk recently about welfare reform, but sadly it seems to have been cover for rolling back rather that arguing a case for a progressive welfare system. A long time ago – long before we were born – something happened called ‘Second Wave Feminism’, and in Oxford in 1970 a bunch of these ‘second wave feminists’ got together and pulled together a mini-manifesto of four key demands of UK feminists:

1. equal pay for equal work
2. equal opportunities and education
3. free contraception and abortion on demand
4. 24 hour childcare meaning that childcare should be available at any time for women who worked unsociable hours

Soon after they got their first win, The Equal Pay Act 1970 followed up in 1975 with the Sex Discrimination Act. Although that’s a legislative win it doesn’t mean the demand was met, today women are still paid around 20% less than men and face losing their jobs when they become pregnant. Education is a happier tale; by 1992 more women were graduating from universities than men – however this was predominately from within the arts and humanities, while men continued to dominate the ‘serious’ subjects of engineering and the sciences which coincidentally led to higher paid jobs. With significant cut backs to the arts and humanities at universities, it appears women’s educational gains are once again under threat. Back to the four feminist demands and another win with contraception; many women now chose to control when and how many children to have using the contraceptive pill provided free on the NHS. Abortion on demand hasn’t been met but most women find they can access abortion services once they’ve jumped through the hoops of getting the permission of two doctors; unless they live in Northern Ireland where it is still illegal.

But what about the childcare demand?

Many a working parent will tell you that either they or their partner work ‘just to pay the childcare’, the Daycare Trust findings for childcare costs in 2011 were that childcare costs have typically increased by more than the average wage, the average yearly expenditure for 25 hours nursery care per week for a child under two is £5,028 in England, £5,178 in Scotland and £4,723 in Wales. Worryingly, some 60% of Family Information Services across Britain said that parents had reported a lack of childcare in their area during the past twelve months, with only 12% reporting there was sufficient childcare to meet the needs of parents working atypical hours across their local authority.

Is the demand for 24-hour access to safe childcare a demand whose time has come? We have a National Health Service, why not a National Childcare Service? While we had something like this during World War Two when women were needed to make the bombs and work the land, after the war, the 1950s saw an end to that. If we can make a National Childcare Service during the difficult times of war, why can’t we invest in one to help improve our lives?

A National Childcare Service would end the postcode lottery and enable all parents who wanted to work that opportunity to do so. At a time when we need to grow our economy the government should be enabling parents and carers to work outside of the home. Not only would a National Childcare Service provide greater flexibility and economic security for parents, it would also provide thousands of jobs for those who are graduating from colleges with specialities in childcare.

Many comprehensives now teach childcare courses beginning at a GCSE or BTEC level, and colleges offer qualifications in childcare and nursery nursing. These vocational qualifications are designed to provide people with a non-university focussed route to a good career, yet the state of the private nursery market is one filled with high competition for jobs and wide discrepancies in the level of training given to their staff and the level of value staff are awarded. By creating a National Childcare Service, we could reward those in the childcare profession with the same level of distinction as nurses and teachers, providing careers for thousands who would otherwise face difficult competition in a saturated market, while offering a vital boost to the service economy.

That would be a progressive policy for welfare reform and a policy Labour could have for growing the economy again.

  • http://twitter.com/robertsjonathan Jonathan Roberts

    Where would the money to pay for it come from? (and please don’t say banker’s bonuses. We’ve spent that several times already)

  • externalities

    (in answer to how to pay for it)

    A good start would be a radical look at child benefit and child tax credits. Do we really need both (especially if we had a National Childcare Service), and do we have the right progression of payment for each additional child? “Countries that spend more on services—especially high-quality child care—than on cash hand-outs and tax breaks tend to get better results for a smaller outlay: in Britain the proportions are reversed.”

  • JC

    Predictable to see the ”
    today women are still paid around 20% less than men and face losing their jobs when they become pregnant” comment again. Which companies do this and why don’t you do something about it? I’ve never worked in a company where women get paid 20% less for the same work, nor one where they lose their jobs for getting pregnant. 

    Can those who have experienced this discrimination stand up and document it here as so far it seems one of those stories from the 60s which is still doing the rounds.

    As for who would pay for it, well there’s always the rich. 

  • Quiet_Sceptic

    The 24 hour access part seems particularly unrealistic, raising all sorts of organisational and logistical issues.

    What would the authors propose the state provide for parents needing cover for a night-shift – some form of state nanny service to stay at the home and look after the children or perhaps a child hotel which parents checked their children into every evening?

  • http://www.facebook.com/benjamin.john.murray Benjamin Murray

    I haven’t read this (
    http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/exclusive-cleggs-drive-to-recruit-65000-state-nannies-7645973.html) yet, but the headline seems interesting. The headline at least, reminded me of this post. 

    • http://twitter.com/ben_murray Ben Murray

      Forget it, should have read the article. 

Latest

  • Comment However MPs voted on airstrikes – they must now hold the government to account

    However MPs voted on airstrikes – they must now hold the government to account

    Britain is now at war with ISIL. At some point over the weekend that will cease to be a technical statement and become an on-the-ground reality. RAF jets will take part in airstrikes against the so-called Islamic State. In concert with the Iraqi army and Kurdish forces they will attempt to damage and drive back ISIL, stopping their otherwise relentless military gains. It is a tough but necessary task. The vote in the Commons today was not a close one. […]

    Read more →
  • Featured The 24 Labour MPs who opposed airstrikes against ISIL

    The 24 Labour MPs who opposed airstrikes against ISIL

    The vast majority of Labour MPs (and MPs from across the Commons) voted in favour of airstrikes against ISIL in Iraq today, but 24 Labour MPs voted against the party whip and opposed airstrikes. One of them (Rushanara Ali) resigned as a Shadow Education Minister as a result of a “formal abstention”. Here’s the full list of Labour’s 24 rebels: Diane Abbott Graham Allen Anne Begg Ronnie Campbell Martin Caton Katy Clark Ian Davidson Paul Flynn Stephen Hepburn Kate Hoey Kelvin Hopkins […]

    Read more →
  • News Rushanara Ali resigns as Shadow Education Minister over Iraq vote

    Rushanara Ali resigns as Shadow Education Minister over Iraq vote

    The Commons has voted for air strikes against ISIL in Iraq. There were 24 Labour rebels but there has been one Shadow Ministerial resignation – Rushanara Ali has resigned as Shadow Education Minister after refusing to vote with the party whip on the vote. Ali abstained. Shadow Defence Secretary Vernon Coaker’s PPS Iain McKenzie was sacked for his No vote. Ali is the MP for Bethnal Green and Bow. The last Labour MP for that seat – Oona King – lost […]

    Read more →
  • News Video “This is the hardest test, but the aim is clear” – Watch Ed Miliband’s Iraq statement

    “This is the hardest test, but the aim is clear” – Watch Ed Miliband’s Iraq statement

    Ed Miliband this morning spoke in favour of UK involvement in airstrikes on ISIL in Iraq. He said: “ISIL’s ideology has nothing to do with the peaceful religion practised by people across the world and by millions of our fellow citizens, who are appalled by what we see. And it is not simply that ISIL is a murderous organisation, it has ambitions for a state of its own – a Caliphate across the Middle East, run according to their horrific […]

    Read more →
  • News The one picture that sums up UKIP Conference

    The one picture that sums up UKIP Conference

    “More Tory than the Tories” say Labour. “I am a Thatcherite” says Nigel Farage. Via Buzzfeed.

    Read more →
7ads6x98y