A new energy?

22nd April, 2012 10:55 am

I haven’t been the happiest of campers lately. I’ve been frustrated at the disorganisation of Labour’s journey of change and frustrated by our inability at times to lose some of the worst habits picked up in Government. At times I, like others, have questioned whether Labour has a proper theory of change and a sense of how to implement it.

But today, the role of Labour optimist will be played by… me! Yesterday I read same interview that Mark Ferguson read and agreed with Mark’s assessment that the intent should be congratulated. I completely understand Mark’s caution about whether these words are enough on their own. However, they don’t come on their own. Because elsewhere in the Guardian is practical innovation being considered by Ed that could be revolutionary in its implications.

The idea that Labour will become a conduit through which people can save money on their energy bills has several important implications.

Firstly, this gives Labour a whole new way of relating to voters. It’s not just saying “we understand your pain” when talking to people who know how hard it is to make ends meet. A conversation that is ultimately frustrating and peripheral for both parties. It’s offering a real and practical solution. Labour may actually go onto the doorsteps with an offer for – rather than an ask of – voters.

Secondly, this is not a solution that requires Labour to be in Government, but does (from what I understand of the way the scheme would work) to reach a critical mass in local communities. It’s something that will help us to make a practical difference to people’s lives in ways that aren’t cruelly curtailed by a change of Government. While at the same time the need to build up a large enough customer base to make the scheme work will need Labour to be and remain outward focused in constituencies and communities in order to deliver the promise.

The critical mass needed will also be a reason for voters to talk to each other about Labour. This scheme may well be a way of developing relationships with people not normally accessible to Labour. I have to admit that I was unsure about the idea of the Labour Supporters Network. I wasn’t clear what the relationship would be or how, other than in terms of money, it would differ from a membership relationship. But this idea has energised my understanding of how Labour can change its staid understanding of relationships. I can see how, by becoming a champion of people’s consumer rights not just in policy terms as I have been promoting for some time, but in delivery too.

This move also puts real flesh on the responsible capitalism bones. And by delivering this project it will be actively shown not to be anti-business. It won’t be stopping anyone from consuming, but will be supporting them in consuming wisely. Businesses that are nimble enough to recognise that will, in fact, benefit. It’s a working example of the translation of these values from speeches that please wonks (eventually) to delivering on promises.

Finally, this truly reinforces Labour’s local election message “With you in tough times”. I’m not always a big fan of political slogans. Too often they are a meaningless babble of vague but positive sounding words (Forward, Not Back anyone?). But if Labour pursue this idea and see how it and the ethos it exemplifies can be developed, maybe we can live up to this basic promise in a way that reenergises our relationship with business, with our activists and members and most importantly with voters.

  • aracataca

    Good points Emma but it seems to elide a central factor -namely that governments lose elections rather than oppositions win them. IMHO this policy alone is not going to be a significant factor in our way back to power. However, the intervention of the government into the ‘real’ lives of people like myself where it has effected a 25% reduction in my monthly income and withdrawn the tax credits I received from my severely disabled son is likely to be a significant factor in our next election victory. IMHO it is important for the party at this present juncture to focus even more intently on the disastrous impact of Tory/Fib Dem policies on the real lives of ordinary people and leave the detailed policy commitments until closer to the election.

  • David MacDonald

    And what will Ed do when the immigrant refugee family with seven children and the dear old widow of 88 next door cannot, or will not, pay their bills? Either the Labour Power Co will chase them, ultimately through the courts, and be seen, by its own supporters as “nasty capitalists” or it won’t, the word will get about and no-one will pay their bills.
     
    I recommend Ed finds out about the “Bank of Essex” funded by the Tory controlled Essex County Council for similar, if misplaced, idealistic reasons; it soon collapsed having made a big loss.

    • treborc1

      Why should labour be chasing anyone, if they owe bills it will be to the councils or the companies they owe the bill to.

      The sad fact is labour did little to help with immigration except open the door, they did n little to build housing or the infrastructure to accommodate  this mass intake.

Latest

  • News 2 out of 3 hospitals face potentially huge cuts this year, leaked analysis reveals

    2 out of 3 hospitals face potentially huge cuts this year, leaked analysis reveals

    Labour will tomorrow release a leaked analysis from NHS Providers which shows that two-thirds of Trusts expect to be in deficit in 2015/16 – up from just one in five in 13/14. Analysis of 98 trusts’ financial forecasts shows a projected deficit this year of £759 million – the equivalent of £1.86 billion across all England’s 240 trusts. This is three times higher than just one year earlier in 2014/15.  In order to get out of deficit, hospitals now face having […]

    Read more →
  • Comment “Your struggle is my my struggle” – what Miliband’s Citizens UK speech says about how he might govern

    “Your struggle is my my struggle” – what Miliband’s Citizens UK speech says about how he might govern

    Your fight is my fight Your struggle is my my struggle Your vision is my vision Lets put working people first Lets change the country together 22 simple words. 5 short sentences. But it says a whole lot about Ed Miliband and the way this campaign has suggested he might govern. These were the words that Miliband used to close his speech at Citizens UK this afternoon – the second powerful speech I’ve seen him deliver today. He showed David […]

    Read more →
  • Video “A nation and a movement” – Scottish Labour’s final election broadcast

    “A nation and a movement” – Scottish Labour’s final election broadcast

    Scottish Labour faces a tough election day on Thursday (after a tough election campaign with Jim Murphy hounded on the streets of Glasgow today, nationalists “hunting” Labour MPs and even appealing to Tories – who they claim to hate – for backing). But tomorrow Scottish Labour’s final Party Election Broadcast will be aired, and it’s a passionate appeal to the emotional argument for Labour. The video, narrated by David Tennant, is based on the hugely popular “Fighters and Believers” broadcast, and […]

    Read more →
  • News Video Ed Miliband’s full Citizens UK speech

    Ed Miliband’s full Citizens UK speech

    Ed Miliband today made a speech at the Citizen UK conference, which David Cameron controversially pulled out of yesterday. In a short but well-received speech (at the place where Gordon Brown made his most famous speeches as PM on the Monday before the last election), the Labour leader said: “Friends, that’s why your fighting my fight. Your struggle is my struggle. Your vision is my vision. Let’s put working people first. Let’s change the country together.”

    Read more →
  • News Polling Quid pro quo? Tories set to save Clegg’s skin in Sheffield Hallam

    Quid pro quo? Tories set to save Clegg’s skin in Sheffield Hallam

      New polling from the Guardian and ICM show that Nick Clegg may hang on to his seat in Sheffield Hallam – but only thanks to tactical voting from nominally Tory voters. The headline figures are Labour’s Oliver Coppard on 34% to Nick Clegg on 42%. Were this to be translated into votes on the day Nick Clegg will be comfortably re-elected though with an 11% loss between now and 2010. In recent months leading Tory figures like former Conservative Home and […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit