What a waste of money

18th April, 2012 9:27 am

Those of you who follow me on Twitter will know that I’m spending a few days this week in Strasbourg, as the once a month “Strasbourg session” of the European Parliament takes place. The whole European Parliament decamps to France for a week, leaving behind MEPs offices, the debating chamber and all of the offices of the European Parliament in Brussels to move to, wait for it, exactly the same (give or take) set of offices in Strasbourg. The complex itself is huge, and yet is only used for a fraction of each year.

Ladies and Gentlemen – welcome to one of the world’s great boondoggles…

As a pro-European, Strasbourg is a challenge for me, because it encapsulates something that is fundamentally wrong with Europe as an entity – the power of vested interests (in this case, the French desire to have the Parliament meet on their turf). Few think that heading to Strasbourg once a month is a good idea, and the vast majority of MPs oppose it. Last month they voted 429-184 for a “single seat”. That’s the largest majority yet.

Labour’s MEPs are particularly keen to end the travelling Strasbourg circus. Their leader Glenis Willmott has outlined “three important reasons why we should now stop this farce”:

1. Governments should be seen to practice what they preach. It is a scandal to cause this totally unnecessary carbon footprint. (The University of York have estimated a carbon footprint of an extra 20,268 tonnes of additional carbon dioxide caused by this move.)

2. Governments are asking everyone in the public sector to tighten their belts. (Estimates claim a cost of €206 million on the extra seat.)

3. We only meet here for historic reasons. Strasbourg represented reconciliation between France and Germany, but that generation has more or less disappeared now. We are now the new Enlarged Europe and the significance of the end of Franco-German hostility is now consigned to history text books

Unfortunately MEPs don’t get to decide where they meet. The Strasbourg session was agreed by EU governments as part of a protocol attached to the Treaty of Amsterdam (agreed by John Major as British Prime Minister) and is decided on by the Governments of the EU, not the parliament. Over a million signatures have been collected to call time on Strasbourg, but as yet that’s been to no avail. If moves were made by other EU governments to abolish the seat then France would simply veto. So it stays. The European project has delivered prosperity and unparalleled peace and security for its members. But sometimes the EU institutions are their own worst enemy…

But if the EU were to leave Strasbourg, what would become of the city (whose economy is boosted by the sessions) and the EU complex itself? Willmot has a few suggestions

“there are endless uses for the revamped European Parliament building. It could perhaps be a centre for European Summits making use of its excellent interpretation facilities, or perhaps a new European University. There are a host of ideas. ”

All of which must be better than spending €200m+ a year on moving a whole parliament hundreds of miles, surely?

Look out for more dispatches from Strasbourg on Twitter, and tomorrow on LabourList.

  • Russell

    Perhaps the 420+ MEPs who don’t like meeting in Strasbourg should just stop going? If only  100 or so turned up every month then the whole thing becomes (even more) pointless and something would surely have to be done…

  • treborc1

    Unemployment office, great idea

  • Dave Postles

    It’s inappropriate today, Mark, when we discover that the Kuwaitis are launching an investigation into whether the Kuwaiti government in 2009 paid Blair £27m for ‘advice’ and when Tom Clark, in his column in ‘Society’ in The Guardian, reveals that it was Blair who asked every year for an ‘initiative’ on welfare.  Criticism from Labour about anything is misplaced.

    • geedee0520

       Well – launching an investigation doesn’t mean that they did pay Blair that money etc. But never mind – he is clearly guilty.

      It is absolutely appropriate to raise the issue of EU waste at any point, no matter what else is around.

  • ovaljason

    If you spent time in any other branch of the EU you would find the same grotesque level of waste.

    Having seen what you’ve seen, Mark, why would you think the EU behaves differently in any other area of policy or function?

  • Razvan onstantinescu

    Yes it is an absolute waste of time and money.  Of effort as well, I know an MEP who had a heart attack (literally) yo-yoing between Brussels, Strassbourg and his consituency back in England.  Absurd.

  • Razvan onstantinescu

    Yes it is an absolute waste of time and money.  Of effort as well, I know an MEP who had a heart attack (literally) yo-yoing between Brussels, Strassbourg and his consituency back in England.  Absurd.

  • http://www.facebook.com/matthew.blott Matthew Blott

    Pointing out EU waste is futile. Mark Ferguson makes some good points but acknowledges himself nothing can be done. But its surely time we had a proper debate on the EU itself if only to put to bed this question for a generation. The Labour Party should commit itself to an EU referendum – a simple in or out. It would be populist and might well ensure them victory and end the squabbling for the next twenty years.

  • http://www.facebook.com/matthew.blott Matthew Blott

    Pointing out EU waste is futile. Mark Ferguson makes some good points but acknowledges himself nothing can be done. But its surely time we had a proper debate on the EU itself if only to put to bed this question for a generation. The Labour Party should commit itself to an EU referendum – a simple in or out. It would be populist and might well ensure them victory and end the squabbling for the next twenty years.

  • John_Haylett

    Boondoggle — is Mark a septic or has he caught the Radio 4 disease of believing that opinions expressed by north Americans or in their terminology have greater intrinsic value?

Latest

  • Featured News “Harry was a proud socialist” – Labour MP Harry Harpham dies, aged 61

    “Harry was a proud socialist” – Labour MP Harry Harpham dies, aged 61

    Tributes are flooding in for Harry Harpham, the Labour MP for Sheffield Brightside and Hillsborough, after passing away from cancer at age 61. Harpham was elected for the first time last year, having worked as a miner – and being a stalwart of the miners’ strike in the 1980s – and later became deputy leader of Sheffield City Council. He made his final contribution in Parliament at PMQs just a fortnight ago, blasting the Government for only offering “warm words, hand-wringing and […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Trade Union Action Week Unions The Tory Trade Union Bill is an unnecessary, undemocratic and unfair attack on working people

    The Tory Trade Union Bill is an unnecessary, undemocratic and unfair attack on working people

    Starting on Monday 8th, the TUC will be running #HeartUnions week; seven days of action to celebrate the vital work done by unions, their reps, and members in workplaces and in society. It comes at an important time for the movement, threatened as it is by the Trade Union Bill, the greatest attack on workers’ rights in a generation. The Trade Union Bill is unnecessary. The UK does not have a problem with industrial strife and we already have some […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured Labour was the party of the union. Now Corbyn needs to admit Labour’s future is federal

    Labour was the party of the union. Now Corbyn needs to admit Labour’s future is federal

    The history of the Labour Party is the history of the union. It was created in its current form when the Scottish Workers Parliamentary Committee merged with what had been the Labour Representation Committee in 1909. In Glasgow, Labour’s unionism was its principle means of warding off sectarian strife. The party became near hegemonic. Over the last decades Labour’s role as the Scottish establishment cemented Edinburgh to London at an elite level. But the growing estrangement of Labour from the British […]

    Read more →
  • News McDonnell: Growth forecast cuts show Osborne’s austerity is driven by ideology

    McDonnell: Growth forecast cuts show Osborne’s austerity is driven by ideology

    The latest economic growth forecast cuts from the Bank of England and the European Commission go to show that George Osborne’s austerity agenda is not working, John McDonnell said today. The latest Inflation Report from the Bank of England cut the GDP growth expectation today, in a move the Shadow Chancellor has described as “unwelcome”. McDonnell slammed Osborne failure to realise sooner the growing financial insecurity internationally. “It’s unwelcome that both the EU Commission and the Bank of England have cut […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Labour launch major review to combat home ownership free fall

    Labour launch major review to combat home ownership free fall

    Labour has today launched a major review into the sharp decline in home ownership. The Redfern Review was commissioned by the Shadow Housing minister John Healey shortly after Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership victory in September, but will be run independently of the party. The review is headed by Pete Redfern, Chief Executive of residential development company Taylor Wimpey, and will report its findings to Labour in late summer. Redfern today set out five major themes that his review will study: the constraints […]

    Read more →
Share with your friends










Submit