Like Thatcher – Ed Miliband is a “Common Ground” politician

17th October, 2012 4:23 pm

Many people are asking, given the austerity drive of this “party of the rich” led government, the effects of which are really going to hammer home come April of next year, whether Ed Miliband can lean to the left when challenging the government now and coming into the next election in 2015?

Whether or not he can, realistically, many commentators now believe he is pitching to the centre-ground; an assumption which has been made after Ed’s focus on “One Nation” during his conference speech earlier this month.

So political wisdom would tell us that Ed clearly sees a gap in the market worth pursuing on the centre, which leads us naturally to ask: where is Cameron situated these days?

Has he got the backs of the Tory left? At a recent event put on by the think tank IPPR, David Skelton of Policy Exchange pointed out that a large part of the so-called class of 2010 (who Cameron presides over) explicitly carry the message of looking to help the poor, those on low-incomes and the blue-collar “strivers”. To paraphrase William Hague, the compassion to reach out to everybody – in a way which characterised Tory One Nationism – is not a bolt-on extra, and exists right at the top of the Conservative party today.

But against this notion, Tim Bale of the University of Sussex, also speaking at the IPPR event, exemplified in his new essay, Whither the Tory Left, the rift between the LibDems and the Tories, that some like Nick Bowles were hoping to avoid, as evidence for the disappearance of the Tories’ left flank – to the extent that the Tories are without anyone to emphasise what unites the coalition parties rather than divides them.

For Bale, Cameron reverted back to (Thatcherite) type after the 2010 economic downturn and the Tory left has never really regained its ground.

So how does Cameron operate around the centre-ground? During the question and answer session at the IPPR Philip Blond, the director of Respublica, explained that the Tories have never won over the centre while pitching to the right. What instead Cameron tries to do today is drag the centre, kicking and screaming, to Thatcherism.

History is not on Cameron’s side here. In trying to spread privilege, as he said in his speech at Tory conference, he is trying to expose the all-important centre point of the electorate to a space it has never tried to occupy. He is not trying to redefine the centre, rather shift it right.

Others take a different view. In light of UKIP gains in popularity, nearing the Liberal Democrats and overtaking them in Wales, Brian Monteith wrote earlier this year that Cameron does not seek to “move this sandbank but sees it as a landing ground to plant his flag.” In other words, the centre for Cameron is the ends, shifting the right towards it will be the means of a majority.

Wiser people than myself, thus, see in Cameron all shades; he is clearly something of a rorschach test. So how is Ed Miliband going to challenge him?

Is One Nation a “land grab”? Is Ed’s pitch to an abandoned conservatism a cynical ploy? I don’t think so. Ed Miliband is practising a set of politics that he has pursued for some time now. He is not playing politics, he is equipped with a noble set of politics that Cameron has been unable to achieve – blamed, in no small part, on the confusion of his brand and the ultimate direction of the Conservative Party.

Once upon a time, civic conservatism was the high ideal of the Conservative Party, as spelled out by David Willetts. But now through the development of conservative (with a small ‘c’) themes, Ed has not simply taken over where the Conservatives were once a force to be reckoned with, but has started to flesh out his brand in areas where the Tories have already failed to deliver.

He has done this by being the Common Ground politician.

How we know Ed isn’t just “land-grabbing” is that the themes he is developing have been long brewing. By talking so movingly about his background during his speech feeds into an empathetic instinct that has been missing in politics for a long time.

As David Clark has recently pointed out, Thatcher, also a common ground politician (hard to imagine in hindsight), used ideas of freedom and individualism to win the support of many traditional Labour voters in the late 1970s. Similarly, Ed brings with him another narrative of social patriotism and egalitarian populism to broaden his appeal in the next election.

The mood music is in full swing, we need solid economic soundings, but Ed is going the right way about winning his masses. Perceived wisdom says you need to woo the centre to win the day, but if Ed can find the common ground, by proving that his, and not Cameron’s, philosophy and vision is substantive, then we can be in a good place to fight the election in 2015.

To report anything from the comment section, please e-mail [email protected]
  • williamtheconker

    I think you’ll find he is Nick BOLES, not Bowles. And surprisingly, for someone whose father was once Director-General of the National Trust, he seems hell-bent on destroying our green and pleasant land by agreeing to industrial development wherever those entrepreneurs want to do it. 
    Ed Miliband’s One Nation toryism is a ‘land-grab’ – but the Tories have a real land-grab in progress.

  • Dave Postles

    ‘By talking so movingly about his background during his speech feeds into
    an empathetic instinct that has been missing in politics for a long
    time.’

    Give over.  Do you really think that his background resonates with the rest of us? 

  • Dave Postles

    ‘By talking so movingly about his background during his speech feeds into
    an empathetic instinct that has been missing in politics for a long
    time.’

    Give over.  Do you really think that his background resonates with the rest of us? 

  • Dave Postles

    ‘By talking so movingly about his background during his speech feeds into
    an empathetic instinct that has been missing in politics for a long
    time.’

    Give over.  Do you really think that his background resonates with the rest of us? 

  • postageincluded

    I wouldn’t want to compare you to a semi-house-trained polecat, Carl, but  Norman Tebbit has been telling the Tories for a year now that Miliband was “tiptoeing onto the Common Ground”, and warning them that they shouldn’t let him get away with it.

    I’m not entirely convinced by this theory (I rather think that winning an election is like writing a best-seller – everyone  can tell you how it was done in the past, but nobody can really tell you how to do it now).  Nevertheless, saying things that the electorate are already thinking can do no harm, and I think that’s what “Ed’s Speech” did, and it’s where Cameron’s  failed

  • Hugh

    He didn’t really talk about his background. Ed’s background: Oxford, TV, policy, Havard, politics. I don’t remember much about that.

Latest

  • Featured News Leading Labour MPs demand “greedy” Green be stripped of gong over BHS failure

    Leading Labour MPs demand “greedy” Green be stripped of gong over BHS failure

    A series of senior Labour MPs have demanded Sir Philip Green be stripped of his knighthood after he was condemned for his “greed” in a damning report on the failure of BHS by two Commons committees. Jon Trickett, John McDonnell and Owen Smith have all called for Green’s honour to be removed after department store BHS – which he sold to the “manifestly unsuitable” Dominic Chappell for £1 last year – collapsed and left 11,000 people without jobs and 20,000 […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Featured “The abuse needs to stop” – the full warning issued by Labour’s top official

    “The abuse needs to stop” – the full warning issued by Labour’s top official

    Iain McNicol, general secretary of the Labour Party today promised clampdown on abuse. In a statement he said: “Over the summer the party will embark on a big debate about our future. Labour members and supporters will choose our candidate for next Prime Minister of the United Kingdom. “The Labour Party should be the home of lively debate, of new ideas and of campaigns to change society. “However, for a fair debate to take place, people must be able to air their views in […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News “Words of condemnation are meaningless unless backed up by action” – Labour HQ prepares to kick out abusers

    “Words of condemnation are meaningless unless backed up by action” – Labour HQ prepares to kick out abusers

    Labour’s most senior official has admitted there is “simply too much” abuse in the Labour Party and revealed plans to suspend yobbish members and ban them from voting in the leadership election. Iain McNicol, Labour’s general secretary, warned that members had been shouted down, intimidated and abused as he announced a clampdown on bad behaviour in the “coming days”. In an almost unprecedented statement, McNicol reported increased levels of abuse in constituency Labour Party (CLP) meetings as well as online, saying: […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Uncategorized Green’s “failures of corporate governance and greed” at doomed BHS

    Green’s “failures of corporate governance and greed” at doomed BHS

      The recent history of failed department story BHS represents the “unacceptable face of capitalism”, according to a damning report by MPs. Sir Philip Green’s disastrous sale of the chain was the culmination of “greed” and failures of corporate governance, sealing its fate before it was sold to the “incompetent and self-serving” Dominic Chappell and his colleagues, two Commons committees said today.  Green, Chappell and senior colleagues became richer through the “systematic plunder” of the shop’s assets and are all culpable for the […]

    Read more →
  • Featured News Burnham and Rotherham call for Labour officials to extend mayoral selection deadline

    Burnham and Rotherham call for Labour officials to extend mayoral selection deadline

    Andy Burnham and Steve Rotheram have called on Labour HQ to push back the deadline for voting in mayoral selections after delays in issuing ballot papers. The contests, to choose who stands as Labour’s candidates in the metropolitan mayoral elections next year, have been hit by delays in sending out the ballots to members to the 20,000 members eligible to vote. Andrew Gwynne and Olly Martins, who manage Burnham and Rotheram’s respective campaigns, outlined the concerns in a letter yesterday to […]

    Read more →
x

LabourList Daily Email

Everything Labour. Every weekday morning

Share with your friends










Submit