Thatcher worship offers diminishing returns for Ed

November 19, 2012 3:45 pm

British politics is so tribal that it still has novelty value to say anything positive about a leader of another party – and doubly so when that person happens to be Margaret Thatcher.

Ed Miliband is set to do just that in a Radio four profile about his leadership tonight entitled: ‘What Does Ed Miliband Really Think?’ As Mark posted this morning, Ed is set to say of La Thatch:

“She was a conviction politician and I think conviction really matters. I think that in the 1970s, it was a similar moment, and that is the biggest parallel. It was a similar moment in the sense that a sense of the old order was crumbling and it wasn’t 100 per cent clear what was going to replace it…”

To be fair to Ed he seems to draw the comparison narrowly, admiring her style rather than her policies:

“The challenge of the future is who can rise to the scale of challenge that the country faces and who can create a project for how this country’s going to be run that is genuinely going to make our economy work, not just for a few people but much more widely.”

It’s become something of a rights-of-passage for Labour leaders to draw favourable comparisons with Margaret Thatcher in a bid to assert their suitability to follow her into Number Ten.

Tony Blair first hit upon the idea of praising her as a way of helping court the right-wing press, while the predictable anger from within the party and unions helped portray him to floating voters as a ‘different’ kind of Labour leader.

Gordon Brown then bent his knee to the Iron Lady, inviting her to tea at Downing Street and posed with her on the steps outside. He even offered to give her a state funeral (not at the same meeting, it is worth pointing out).

Now it is Ed Miliband’s turn.

There are two main reasons why the Thatcher comparison is deemed to have some value. The first, and most obvious, is that rather a lot of people voted for her in 1979, 1983 and 1987 and it would be nice if they instead voted Labour. Drawing comparisons with their heroine is thought to be smart politics, offering voters a rhetorical bridge to walk across.

The second reason is that Thatcher is invariably described as a ‘conviction politician’ and a ‘strong leader’. Qualities most leaders would want others to say they possessed. Yes, she was both, but she was also cruel, reckless and divisive. If he must draw parallels with Conservative figures for definition, then Ed would be better off sticking with the tradition of One Nation leaders like Disraeli and MacMillan.

In fact, the drawbacks of Maggie-love now outweigh their benefits.

Making comparisons with Thatcher’s strength and conviction implies there are no Labour figures for whom the same epithets equally apply. That clearly is not the case (although it is a moot point whether a comparison with Blair or Brown would generate even more controversy).

Finally, to have actually voted for Margaret Thatcher as Prime Minister you need to be at least 42 years old. The law of diminishing returns surely means that Thatcher has less and less cache every time her name is invoked. Daring when Blair did it, the trick now seems perfunctory.

Rather than continuing the dubious tradition of Labour leaders genuflecting before this false idol, the challenge for Ed is to eschew comparisons with her style and actually emulate her record by coming up with a defining set of policies that will ratchet British politics in a new direction and set the terms of political debate for a generation.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001116515833 Michael Carey

    I think this misses the point of Ed making the comparison. The way I read it was that Thatcher was a ground-shifting politician in a way that no PM has been since, just like Ed would like to be- shifting the ground *away* from the Thatcherite settlement.

  • Serbitar

    Thatcher is very elderly, impaired and frail these days… so Ed had better arrange to genuflect to the Blue Baroness and enjoy the customary associated photo opportunity as soon as possible… if you see what I mean… just like former “Labour” leaders Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, who, rumour has it, were the Lady’s own illegitimate political sons (and couple of right bleeding ones they were at that)!

    What that makes Ed Miliband is anybody’s guess.

    (My guess would be a patsy.)

  • Dave Postles

    Is there some competition on 19 November for who can utter the most garbage? First, we have Cameron with nonsense about judicial reviews, now Miliband on obduracy.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1369047172 David Clayton

    Thatcher supporting is not avery bright move if you want Labour to do well in the North of England or Scotland. The gormless metropolitan elite dominating the party demonstrate their ineptitude in following this path. What is the point of a ‘one nation’ Thatcher worshipping Labour Party? Too daft to laugh at.

  • uglyfatbloke

    Conviction? There’s a lot of politicians who should have convictions….for dodgy wars and stealing money for a start..

    Ed’s just eager to get a cheery word in the Daily Mail and this is one of the easy ways of going about it. He might also try attacking poor people and foreigners, promising to throw money at Trident, persecuting cannabis, confusing the EU with the ECHR and complaining about them,…and of course voicing his support for keeping the house of Lords as a retirement home for failed politicians and for preventing a democratic electoral system.

  • David B

    I take it as a realisation that she was right!

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘redistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘redistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘predistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘predistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘predistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘predistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘predistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    Well said Kevin. I suspect this latest Ed Miliband’s idea came from the same bag carrier who thought ‘predistribution’ would sound good.

  • Daniel Speight

    I have a bad feeling and hope very much I’m wrong in my suspicions. (I am often wrong. Just over a year ago I honestly felt that some in Labour would jump at a chance of joining a national government. Maybe the scare that Progress got from the unions was enough to change a few minds. Who knows? It could just be I’m not a very trustful person.)

    Today it must be very tempting to Labour’s leaders that as sections of the Tories drag Cameron further to the right they see that they could take a sidestep also to the right and occupy the ‘centre’ ground being deserted by the government. As tempting as this is it would be a terrible mistake on Ed Miliband’s part.

    Cameron and Clegg claimed the mantle of Blair along with David Miliband, but David lost the leadership contest because the membership didn’t want another Blair. It was a cry to get back to some principled politics that has been missing for so long. Sure Labour could replace the Tories on the centre-right if Cameron caves into his rebels, but remember Cameron couldn’t win a majority on that platform.

    Ed should have a long look at PASOK and learn some lessons from the Greeks on when it’s the right time to part from past economic solutions.

Latest

  • Featured Gordon Brown to announce departure as an MP “within days”

    Gordon Brown to announce departure as an MP “within days”

    Former Labour leader and Prime Minister Gordon Brown is set to resign as MP for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath “within days” according to a report from the Sunday Mirror. Brown, who played a key role in the Scottish referendum campaign this year – giving a barnstorming speech on the eve of the vote that defined the case for the union. Brown’s rumoured departure follows his long-time ally Alistair Darling’s decision to quit Parliament in 2015. The Sunday Mirror reports: “Gordon Brown will […]

    Read more →
  • News Scotland Findlay says information going to party members for leadership vote is “insulting”

    Findlay says information going to party members for leadership vote is “insulting”

    Neil Findlay MSP, who is running to be leader of the Scottish Labour Party, is calling on the Labour Party to clarify what information will be given to members with Leadership ballot papers. At the moment it looks as though the booklet with candidate statements in it only lists the nominations each candidate received from Parliamentarians and not from Constituency Labour Parties, trade Unions or socialist societies. In response to this, Findlay has released the following statement: “Over the last […]

    Read more →
  • Comment It’s Ukip that offends working class sentiment

    It’s Ukip that offends working class sentiment

    After this week’s Twitter row at the Rochester by-election, I am using my keynote speech to the Labour East Regional Conference today to say that it is UKIP who truly offends working class sentiment and represents a party which is fundamentally un-British. Today I am lucky to serve as a Euro MP but, like many in our movement, I grew up on a council estate living in poverty, so don’t need any lectures from UKIP about snobbery. First, we can’t counter UKIP […]

    Read more →
  • News Balls says money raised from banking fines should go to the NHS

    Balls says money raised from banking fines should go to the NHS

    In a speech today at Labour’s East of England regional conference in Ipswich, Ed Balls has announced that £1bn raised from banks who are fined for manipulating the markers should go to the NHS. He is calling on George Osborne to include this in his Autumn Statement, due to take place on the 3rd December. This also comes after many health care professionals said due to funding cuts, “the NHS and our social care services are at breaking point.” Balls […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Scotland Join the 1,000 – building a movement for Labour’s future in Scotland

    Join the 1,000 – building a movement for Labour’s future in Scotland

    Last Tuesday I stopped by a Team Findlay phone bank in Glasgow. I was expecting to see a half dozen people making calls. There were close to 40. And that was just in Glasgow. More people were hitting the phones from Aberdeen to Ayrshire and from Dundee to Dumfries to take part in what we’re calling ‘Call 4 Change’. It’s been like this since my campaign kicked off two weeks ago. We launched ‘Neil 4 Scotland’ in the Miners’ Welfare in […]

    Read more →