In the next couple of years, we’ll all switch to electric cars. From 2035, petrol and diesel cars will not be available to buy. The argument for the transition away from internal combustion engines is settled – and almost no-one serious disagrees.
Yet the review of the Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) mandate is discussed primarily in terms of electoral strategy for Labour and splits between colleagues, rather than in terms of whether a policy remains right in changed circumstances. And that does a disservice to the maturity of the conversation about how best to phase out petrol and diesel cars.
Hard to justify
The ZEV mandate was designed for a world before persistent inflation, protectionism and renewed concerns about economic security transformed the environment facing manufacturers. So the choice for all those who believe in ending petrol and diesel is either to stick stubbornly to policy set on assumptions that didn’t come true – and risk UK car making – or to flex.
The reasons to reform the ZEV mandate are simple: the market for EVs isn’t growing fast enough. This year just under 27 percent of cars sold will be EVs, against a target of 33 percent. And to achieve this, every car sold has had huge support – with government discounts of up to £3,750 off the purchase price and similar price cuts from manufacturers.
No-one thinks we can meet a target of 80 percent in three years’ time through sales. To meet it, UK automotive manufacturing will be forced into ever-steeper discounting of purchase prices, paying fines or being forced to buy credits from Chinese and US EV manufacturers. All of these render domestic carmaking less viable, put jobs at risk, risk automotive and wider manufacturing supply chains and undermine one of the UK’s great export industries.
In short: the ZEV mandate is one of the things making the UK a hard place to profitably make cars.
The challenge is compounded by the flood of heavily state-subsidised Chinese EVs. While the United States and EU have imposed significant tariffs on Chinese EV imports, the UK market remains more open. That makes it even harder to justify a policy that imposes additional costs on manufacturers producing vehicles here in Britain.
That’s why I, and many Labour MPs, support a cut in the ZEV mandate target to 50 percent by 2030. That’s still stretching – and still keeps us on a path to phasing out petrol and diesel. It helps us meet our climate commitments. But it better reflects consumer demand and the realities facing manufacturers.
A just transition should protect jobs, skills and communities
The industry is well on its way into the transition to EVs – and ministers have put huge support in to help with it, through the £4 billion DRIVE35 programme and support for energy costs. You can see that with new Nissan Leafs and Land Rovers rolling off the lines, and the new electric Jaguar being launched.
But if we persist in policy choices that make the UK a less friendly destination to make cars, the investment decisions made in the boards of multinational companies will go against us. We will lose big car plants and the jobs that go with them to other countries – first new lines not coming to the UK, and then work now done here moving abroad. And then a cascade of closures will start down the supply chain – hitting every other sector of advanced manufacturing too.
And that would be a catastrophe. Automotive manufacturing generates around £25 billion in economic value, supports 180,000 manufacturing jobs and anchors a supply chain of more than 2,500 companies. Those jobs matter. They are concentrated in places like the West Midlands and North East – so the impact will not be spread evenly across the country. It will be concentrated in areas that can least afford it.
A just transition means getting to net zero while protecting jobs, skills and communities. It means accepting that no major automotive company can transform itself overnight, however committed it is to electrification. It means recognising that there will be no British EV industry if there is no British automotive industry left to make the transition.
Loosening the ZEV mandate is not about weakening climate ambitions. It is about making sure the path to 2035 does not shred the 180,000 jobs, world-leading expertise and export strength that the UK automotive sector provides. We all agree on the destination. The challenge is getting there in a way that keeps British manufacturing alive.