You are here: Home » Archives »

Today’s PMQs has lessons for the TV debates

March 10, 2010 1:06 pm

Author:

Alex Smith

Share this Article

Brown Gordon

By Alex Smith / @alexsmith1982

UPDATE: Alastair Campbell has made a Vlog on the TV debates, why the hype doesn’t matter and why Gordon’s substance will shine through.

UPDATE: Watch Cameron losing his rag in PMQs.

I increasingly dislike watching PMQs on a Wednesday. The paper waving gamesmanship and jeering should have no place in a discussion as serious as Defence spending, when the country is fighting war and soldiers are dying. Really, it should have no place at all in any discussion at the heart of the supposed “mother of Parliaments”.

But there were one or two lessons from today’s session that I think should point the way for how Gordon Brown should try to perform in the imminent TV debates between the party leaders.

As David Cameron became shrill and petulant at one point, even appearing to stamp his foot in faux incredulousness, Gordon Brown didn’t react in kind. Instead, he got on calmly with the job of focusing on the substance and policy matter at hand. If anything, rather than rising to Cameron’s anger, Brown became more calm and in control, rather than less. It made Cameron look shrill; Brown more statesmanlike.

Such expression could be even more beneficial to the TV debates, where the studio will be quiet and every tick will be highlighted and magnified in the post-match analysis.

I tweeted during PMQs that:

ALEx Tweet

Several responses suggest others might agree. @NorthBriton45‘s reply best exemplifies them:

Respondents to LabourList’s PMQs LiveChat Quick Poll might also agree. In spite of the headlines David Cameron’s anger may get, 50% of participants said Gordon Brown “won” PMQs today, while 38% said Cameron won and 13% said Nick Clegg. On who won on the Defence spending debate, the point at which Cameron got feisty, Gordon Brown’s numbers increased to 60%.

Message to Gordon? If Cameron gets stroppy, Keep Calm and Carry On.

Comments are closed

Latest

Local Government News
Boris and the 2 billion pound “clerical error”
By Mark Ferguson
Earlier today on BBC’s London Politics Show, it was revealed that billions of pounds were inaccurately added to Boris Johnson’s official budget document – a mistake that a spokesperson for the Tory Mayor attempted to dismiss as a “clerical error”. At over £2 billion – that’s some clerical error… A spokesperson for Ken Livingstone said: “Boris Johnson claims anyone arguing for lower fares for Londoners doesn’t understand the transport finances, but now it turns out it’s Boris Johnson’s transport figures [...]
Read more →
Featured
The sad truth behind Andrew Lansley’s eyes
By Conor Pope
“Michael,” said the Prime Minister, without looking up from his desk, “I thought you said this would be easy?” “Easy? That what would be easy?” replied the Education Secretary, whose face had occupied a near-permanent state of mild bafflement, which was slowly becoming the kind of ever-present British institution that decades from now will be ruined by ill-thought out reforms, or having a roof built over it in case it rains. “This NHS business. You said it would be easy.” [...]
Read more →
Comment Westminster
On prayer in Parliament
By Kerry McCarthy
The court ruling that prayers should not be on the formal council agenda at Bideford Town Council has been met with predictable outrage. The Mail says it could be extended to Parliament – I’m not sure it’s quite the same scenario, as in Parliament prayers are said when the session begins, at say. 2.30pm, and then another bell goes a few minutes later and those who didn’t want to be in there for prayers enter the Chamber. So you can [...]
Read more →
Video
Burnham: ‘Pride’ put before NHS
Read more →
News
NHS polling – public tell Cameron to drop the bill
By Mark Ferguson
There’s some devastating YouGov polling on NHS “reform” for Cameron to digest today. Firstly, the public are firmly against his reforms. Almost half (48%) of the public oppose the reforms, compared to just 18% who back them. But it’s not just the broad idea of the reforms that the public oppose – it’s the specifics. On the question of whether increasing competition in the NHS will improve health services (something which Labour were not against in principle in office), the [...]
Read more →