The Government is running out of excuses

25th November, 2011 9:44 am

“It’s a hard road to a better Britain, but we’re on the right track” were the words David Cameron used a year ago to justify their economy-crushing austerity measures. Yet the Government’s assertion, with unemployment at a 17-year high and more than a million young people out of work, that it may be hurting but it is working flies in the face of mounting evidence to the contrary. In the autumn statement next week, George Osborne will be forced to admit that as growth has all but evaporated, he will have to increase his forecasts for government borrowing.  The plan is definitely hurting, but it isn’t working.

The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) has already said that government borrowing over the course of the Parliament will be over £46 billion higher than the Government had planned.  And this figure is set to rise next week when we get the OBR’s new forecasts.  If they are in line with the average of independent forecasts, published by the treasury last week, then the Government could be set to borrow over £100 billion more than planned.  Shadow chief secretary, Rachel Reeves, has rightly argued that these forecasts expose the myth that the Government’s reckless economic plan is working when in reality it is backfiring badly.

This is precisely why we need a plan for jobs and growth. As Labour has set out, there are five clear steps the government can take immediately. First, a £2 billion tax on bank bonuses would fund the building of 25,000 new homes and create some 100,000 jobs for young people.  Second, bringing forward long-term investment projects would help get people back to work and strengthen our economy. Third, reversing January’s damaging VAT rise would help high streets as well as struggling families. Fourth, a one-year cut in VAT to 5% on home improvements would help homeowners and small businesses. And finally, a one-year national insurance tax break, for every small firm which takes on extra workers would help small businesses grow and create jobs.

The Conservatives blamed the impact of the previous global economic crisis – the collapse in tax revenues that followed the banking crash – on the last Labour government. This is the ridiculous assertion that, as Ed Balls has summed up so well, somehow Lehmans collapsed in the US because Labour built too many schools and hospitals.  It is a supreme irony that the Tories are now blaming the impact of their own decisions – the fact that growth has all but disappeared in the last year, as the spending cuts and tax rises have gone too far and too fast – on a global economic crisis, principally on what has been happening in the eurozone.

David Cameron argued at PMQs earlier this month that the tiny growth figures should be welcomed amid “a global storm in the world economy”.  And touring the TV studios last week, the employment minister Chris Grayling, said the surge in unemployment was the “fault of the eurozone”.

The truth is the British economy slowed down well before the current eurozone crisis. Figures from the Office of National Statistics show that exports from the UK to eurozone countries in the third quarter of 2011 actually increased by 17% compared to the same quarter of 2010. The last time youth unemployment fell was between February-April 2011, well before the onset of the current eurozone crisis. The Lib Dem peer and former coalition treasury spokesman Lord Oakeshott put it rather well last week when he said:

“It is ridiculous to blame these figures on the eurozone crisis as any economist will tell you it would take between six to twelve months for its effects to have an impact on unemployment here — unemployment lags behind economic indicators.”

Treasury minister David Gauke tried to claim recently on Newsnight that the UK had grown as much as the US.  But the truth is that over the last 12 months the UK has grown by 0.5% (compared to 2.6% in the previous 12 months) while the US has grown by 1.5%.  In fact, over the last year, only Greece, Portugal and Cyprus have grown more slowly than the UK in the EU and only Japan in the G7.

In opposition, David Cameron criticised Gordon Brown for saying the global economic crisis was to blame for the worldwide recession, arguing instead that it was a recession made in Downing Street.  But since coming to power, this out-of-touch Government has become a government of excuses. First they blamed the Labour party. Then they blamed the Royal wedding and even the snow. Now it’s all the fault of the eurozone crisis. Next they’ll be blaming the strikes, if they go ahead next week.  But the government is fast running out of excuses.

The next few weeks will see a number of office Christmas parties taking place in Whitehall. As the mince pies and sherry are being dished out at their bash this year, no doubt the treasury will be reverberating to the traditional sound of Dean Martin’s Let it Snow and Bing Crosby’s White Christmas. As the evidence mounts that their economic plan is failing, I bet George Osborne is carefully studying the weather forecasts, as well as the markets, this year and hoping for an unusually white Christmas.

Michael Dugher is Labour MP for Barnsley East and shadow minister without portfolio

Value our free and unique service?

LabourList has more readers than ever before - but we need your support. Our dedicated coverage of Labour's policies and personalities, internal debates, selections and elections relies on donations from our readers.

If you can support LabourList’s unique and free service then please click here.

To report anything from the comment section, please e-mail [email protected]
  • Anonymous

    I suspect the people like all the other parts of the EU like Greece, like Italy, like Spain, will be  angry with  cuts especially if those cuts affect the new ruling class the middle class.

    I do not think Labour has a hell of a lot to offer, looking at the five point plan, which is now four because the Tories have taken the one on spending on infrastructure.

    But I’m willing to say the Tories will have to have a plan B and at the moment I think the work experience plan is  working although if they left the EMA in place it would have been cheaper and many young people would not be in college or in training.

     Wales did keep EMA and believe me I see young people sitting on Walls in town at night they are drinking cheap drinks from Tesco, it’s hard breaking to see.

    The fact is Labour would be in the same mess little money to spend, and please do not tell me a cut in VAT would get people  buying because that’s rubbish all the companies have taken the VAT hike twice over with cuts in goods and I can tell you now people are not spending.

    Difficult time but do I believe labour has anything to offer us not if this is it. And with little money to spend  and the deficit and the  debt and the mess we are in all you lot are looking at are  road building mainly done by machinbes these days, Rail building low employment as again done by machines and house building mainly now done by migrants from Poland as they cut our sub contractors by not having to pay tax here.

    The new world of the EU, if I was to believe Cruddas and I do not, I would say  have that referendum because the influx of labour from the EU is hurting us at the bottom…. with low paid workers.

  • Anonymous

    “It is ridiculous to blame these figures on the eurozone crisis as any economist will tell you it would take between six to twelve months for its effects to have an impact on unemployment here — unemployment lags behind economic indicators.”

    As the current Government came to power in August 2010, then it will be – by the same argument as the above = 12 months before the impact of any of its policies take real effect. So To compare the last 12 months from October 2010 to September 2011 is to include 9 months when its policies were unable to take full effect.

    So this article is contradictory and just wrong – based on its own statements.

    May I suggest a course in simple logic for the writer as he clearly has no idea how to argue logically and consistently.

  • Social housing is, again, a LONG term solution.  A short-term solution is needed to spiralling rents and the resultant, thanks to HB cuts which face it Labour are not going to reverse, rapid social cleansing this will cause.

    That means rent caps. Even socialist-fearing America uses them, ffs.


LabourList Daily Email

Everything Labour. Every weekday morning

Share with your friends