Harris admits defeat in Scottish leadership contest

December 11, 2011 10:16 am

Tom Harris has admitted defeat in his bid for the leadership of the Scottish party, but not without throwing a barb at the party. The MP told Scotland on Sunday:

“Realistically speaking I am not sure that the Scottish Labour party is prepared to take as radical a step as having an MP as its leader yet.”

“My message has been that Labour is in really deep trouble and that we need to think outside the box. There is no indication that the party is prepared to do that yet and I don’t know why.”

Harris has faced an uphill struggle throughout the leadership contest, without the backing of MSPs, constituency parties or trade unions held by his rivals. The result will be announced in one week.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Homfray/510980099 Mike Homfray

    I think Scottish Labour have had the sense to realise that whatever the problems, the answer is not to choose a divisive Blairite MP not in the Scottish parliament. 

    Scottish Labour needs to recognise that Holyrood and the rise of the SNP has changed the agenda, and the choice of a Westminster MP associated with the Blairite ultras would be a major mistake

    • Anonymous

      I love the thinking out side the  box remarks….

    • Andy

      It’s also worth noting, Mike, that Harris failed to secure the backing of even a single MSP in his leadership bid. The Nits would run rings around him for that reason alone.

    • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100001102865655 John Ruddy

      While I disagree with Tom on some of his policies, I think he has got the politics spot on. As someone else has said, SNP seem to do “Labour” better than we do. This is where Tom actually scores very well, he knows what we have to do to take on the SNP. One of the many reasons why we lost the election in Scotland was we were trying to take on the tories, and position ourselves as anti-tory. Thats why it matters less whether the leader is a blairite or not. That is not the battle we need to fight.

  • Daniel Speight

    In a year of mostly bad news sometimes there have been small glimpses of bright light.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1557475545 Jack Bonner

    Ken Macintosh for me. Johann, although more than capable, is too closely associated with past failures and I don’t think she can shake them off.

    I just hope it’s a clear cut result and Ken doesn’t end up losing on the basis of the Union vote!

  • Franwhi

    It’s amazing that the last Labourlist post on Scotland was on the 17th November particularly in the midst of a Scottish Labour leadership election. Talk about moribund.
    I agree that Tom’s not the answer although I’m not sure who is… However I think he is to be applauded in one sense for daring to mix it up a bit in the first place. I fear whoever wins will be pushing a political elephant uphill because the SNP seem to do “Labour” better than Labour these days

  • Hamish

    The only glimpse of light will be when Labour embrace Scottish Independence.

    • Dave Postles

      Scottish independence.  It grieves me to say so, but I believe you are right.  An association with the Nordic countries will be beneficial.  You will replace ‘England’ for inward investment for access to the single market – the rest of the world is only interested in the UK as a point of access to the single market.  You will have immense energy resources which can be linked into a network grid of the North Atlantic. 

      • Dave Postles

        I actually meant the North Sea grid!

    • http://twitter.com/Newsbot9 Newsbot9

       And so abandon it’s principles? Yea, I’m sure you’d love that.

      • Anonymous

        Principles seem to have placed it in a mess, sadly people now do not want the labour way, so you find out why and then you change,

        • http://twitter.com/Newsbot9 Newsbot9

           Yes, try “being left wing”. It’s what I’m advocating, if you missed that.

          • Anonymous

            Left wingers died out with Wilson for god sake.

      • Hamish

        Would that be the principle that every nation has the right to determine its own affairs apart from Scotland?

  • Anonymous

    Tom Harris talked and wrote sense. He looks and acts normal.

    That debars him as a Leader.

    (see E Mlliband as a contrast.)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Mike-Homfray/510980099 Mike Homfray

    I agree. If Tom Harris had wanted to take this direction, then he should have stood for Holyrood last time. That is now the centre of action in a devolved Scotland. However, I think were it not for the fact that he is out of favour at Westminster  he would not have expressed interest in this post – and hasn’t before. 

    It is an issue for Labour that young activists in Scotland still seem to want to pursue a Westminster rather than Holyrood career

    • Franwhi

      ..and the not so young like M Curran and C Jamieson who have moved onward and upward from Edinburgh to Westminster. Do they believe Holyrood is a “sand pit” on the way to bigger and better things ? I don’t understand why you wouldn’t want to serve in the devolved administation of your own country unless you felt your career was more important than your constituents.   

  • John Ruddy

    Theres a different reason for that. The MSPs have never wanted an MP as leader.

Latest

  • Comment Will the Tory MP who wants to charge patients to use the NHS debate me?

    Will the Tory MP who wants to charge patients to use the NHS debate me?

    Earlier this week, Channel 4’s “Dispatches” asked if we are addicted to our doctors. It highlighted the increasing pressure the NHS is under and some of the costs associated with those pressures. My opponent in Bristol North West – Tory MP Charlotte Leslie – said that, in respect of A&E and GP surgery appointments that are deemed unnecessary, that “…we do need a charge I think to just enable people to think a little bit about what their use of […]

    Read more →
  • Comment Free information and free broadband – business policies of the future?

    Free information and free broadband – business policies of the future?

    Us folk in business are a straightforward lot. Yes, we like big picture ideas and visions of the future – but we also need real-life, practical policies and plans. And with nine months to go until the general election the business community is hungry for greater clarity on what Labour business policy will actually be. The latest offering from Policy Network, Owning The Future, edited by Chuka Umunna, is rich in big ideas about Britain’s role in the global economy. […]

    Read more →
  • News Burnham: the SNP are misleading Scottish people on the NHS

    Burnham: the SNP are misleading Scottish people on the NHS

    On Monday, Scottish National Party (SNP) leader Alex Salmond promised that in an independent Scotland, the NHS would be protected from cuts and privatisation. However, Andy Burnham, Shadow Secretary for Health has said that by making such pledges, Salmond is confusing the debate over independence and misleading people in Scotland: “If Salmond seriously cared about the NHS he would be explaining how he could possibly afford to fund it properly after a yes vote – with the £6 billion cuts […]

    Read more →
  • Video Stella Creasy vs Austin Mitchell on AWS and women in Parliament

    Stella Creasy vs Austin Mitchell on AWS and women in Parliament

    Last night Labour MPs Austin Mitchell and Stella Creasy went head to head on Newsnight over Mitchell’s comments on All Women Shortlists and female MPs. It was – unsurprisingly – a fiery discussion. Here it is: (h/t: Guido)

    Read more →
  • News Polling Marginals polling finds Labour vote reaching further into Tory territory

    Marginals polling finds Labour vote reaching further into Tory territory

    The latest batch of Lord Ashcroft’s polling in marginal constituencies has been published this morning. His previous marginals polls have been generally good news for Labour, showing heavy gains from both the Tories and Lib Dems, although more recently they have shown that UKIP pose a threat to to Labour’s success. With Labour having previously shown comfortable leads in most of the the marginals we hold, and many of our main target seats, Ashcroft this time concentrated on four of […]

    Read more →